Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

Posts

If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

#1

If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

charlie belden

were to be made if solid wood, using traditional joinery, modern glue and finsihes

a) are there Ikea designs that you would like to have in your home if they were were in solid wood, etc.?

b) would you be willing to pay the significantly higher price for it?

c) would you seriously consider MAKING the piece instead?

Re: If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

#2

Re: If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

Gary Smyth

Yes, there are designs I would use In fact, some Ikea hardware is better and less expensive than some similar catalog offerings..

No, I would not pay someone else significantly higher prices for it

Yes I would consider making something using Ikea design

For the most part for me Ikea furniture is temporary furniture. I don't believe that I have ever bought anything at Ikea that doesn't already have a specific function planned. I use it to solve a problem and it stays until something better comes along. When that happens, someone or some organization is donated the item. Day care centers and churches always seem to have a need for the Ikea stuff. I rarely have trouble finding others putting Ikea anything to use.

In Western PA there is an Ikea in the suburbs of Pittsburgh, it is crowded -- mostly with college students, newlyweds, first timers, downsizers, divorced. But Western PA also has four or five estate sales each week. I find that I can find better furniture, more suited to my taste, and at lower cost than that at Ikea. Transportation of the stuff is the major con. I may have to search for something for a while, but the Ikea stuff serves until something strikes me as better for me.

Re: If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

#3

Re: If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I'm not sure I entirely understand your premise, or maybe I just partially disagree with it. Some IKEA furniture, or at least some components of it, is made from solid hardwoods. That being said, I still don't think these "up-market" material choices raise it above "curb furniture", due to several shortcomings, for example, the KD fasteners, finger joints or butterfly joints, and failure to properly season the wood before gluing it up, finishing it, and wrapping it in plastic before shipping it.

Re: If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

#4

Ikea as inspiration

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was in Orlando and encountered my first Ikea store. I have seen some nice Scandinavian antiques, as well as modern pieces. I optimistically thought there might be some good designs to be found in the store. I found the offerings uninspiring. I did buy a nice wood rug but I don't believe I will ever return to a store again.

Re: If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

#5

Re: If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

charlie belden

I understand the problem of how they JOIN components. But IF they used more traditionaly joinery AND used solid wood rather than particle board, would you consider buying a piece of IKEA furniture - or making your own out of solid wood?

Basically, my question is about their designs rather than their construction methods.

AS for being made of "hardwood", the term is a bit misleading, at least if the definition of "hardwood" means the tree from which the wood comes - has leaves, rather than needles - and NOT the actual, measurable hardness of the wood. There are "softwoods" (from trees with needles rather than leaves) that are phyically harder than some "hardwoods (wood from trees that have leaves). BALSA, which I think comes for a tree that has leaves, is MUCH softer than say Southern Yellow Pine - or juniper.

Re: If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

#6

Re: Ikea as inspiration

charlie belden

Bill:

Was it the proportions of the pieces, the look of the wood", the detailing (edge treatments for example) or how they worked that you found uninspiring? How was it different from the Modern Scandanavian pieces you found attractive?

Re: If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

#7

Clint Searl

Re: If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

Clint Searl

We purchased a solid oak dining table that couldn't be duplicated in material, fit, and finish at twice the price we paid. I also outfitted a kitchen with IKEA cabinets that with some modification to their approach to installation that were as nice as and perform as well as mid-price stuff at a much lower cost. All of their case work and cabinetry is well designed.

Re: If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

#8

Re: If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

AZ in Colorado Springs

a. I don't know (haven't been inside an IKEA store since 2004)

b. highly unlikely

c. Aha! My daughter is getting married soon and contemplating furnishing a home (her current roommate will be moving out and taking her furniture along and the fiance has little furniture of his own). She has gotten some furniture ideas from IKEA and we were discussing this on the weekend. She was unsure how to afford quality furniture and I suggested pursuing less expensive, interim solutions and I'd build whatever she needed, a few pieces per year. (I have a kitchen island, step stool, and mission style entry table/mirror set [which I posted about a few weeks back] in work as wedding gifts.

So, the answer to "c" is yes -- I'll be building it instead (for whatever items are inspired by a visit to IKEA).

Cheers

Re: If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

#9

Re: If an Ikea piece of furniture . . .

Sgian Dubh

"a) are there Ikea designs that you would like to have in your home if they were in solid wood, etc.?"

Some of their products are already in solid wood. Those that aren't I wouldn't want in the solid.

"b) would you be willing to pay the significantly higher price for it?"

No.

"c) would you seriously consider MAKING the piece instead?"

No.

To put my answers into context I believe if you are thinking of somehow making items inspired by IKEA forms then you are missing a trick somewhere because you are not buying into the IKEA philosophy and modus operandi that the company operates under.

It's true that much of their furniture is not especially durable, but it is cheap and replaceable, whether you like the 'wastefulness of that way of living or not. At the same time their approach to the design process, their manufacturing procedures, their high level quality control, attention to detail, project management, very tight price monitoring, rigid overseeing and organisation of their supply chain, etc are all a fundamental and elementary part of their business philosophy. The result is what you get, and I don't think their generally rather 'boring' take on Scandi influenced design (made acceptable to many buyers through material/ hardware/ finish choices, price, fit, finish application, etc) translates readily to items that are closer to hand crafted. On their own IKEA designs aren't interesting enough nor well suited to a more woody crafted approach. Slainte.