Re: To patent or NOT to patent?
Alan in Little Washington (NC)
OK- I'm talking from experience here- the INCRA I-BOX, Infinity Lock Miter Master, and a half a dozen other products in various stages of development.
First, there is no such thing as a "Provisional Patent" just a Provisional Patent "Application." A PPA doesn't result in a patent. It is fairly new as far as the patent process goes, being created during the Carter Administration. It is very limited in what it does and the protection it provides- not much. A non-disclosure agreement provides almost the same protection with potential licensees, though not all will sign an NDA. A PPA basically provides a date marker, that when combined with a follow-on "Utility Patent Application" establishes the earliest date of invention. It only costs a tad over $100 to file on-line (there are penalties for not filing online). There is no set format so high-end CAD drawings aren't mandatory. I used one of the SketchUp stylistic line drawing formats but believe you may be able to submit scanned, carefully hand-drawn illustrations (check on that first). A PPA is reviewed by USPTO just to make sure the required elements (applicant sheet, description, drawings, fees) were submitted, but the content is NOT reviewed, unless there is a challenge to a subsequent Utility Patent Application that claims the earlier PPA date. A PPA is only valid for one year and can not be renewed. You can use "Patent Pending" during that year. If there is a delay (no overlap) in filing for a Utility Patent Application you can not claim the earlier date.
A Utility Patent Application costs only slightly over $2000+ in filing fees (see here: http://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/ac/qs/ope/fee010114.htm ). I say "only" because in addition to the filing fees and depending on the complexity of the item and application, patent attorney fees can run $10,000 - $20,000 or more. It is nearly impossible for an individual to file without using a patent attorney due to the language, negotiation process, etc. etc. Then, if you are lucky enough to have a patent issue, you must pay maintenance fees at various anniversaries to keep it in force: 3.5 yr ($400), 7.5 yr ($900), 11.5 ($1850) for a "micro-entity"; much more if you don't qualify as such. Oh, as others have said, a patent is only as good as the attorney you hire to defend it. USPTO does not take any action against anyone who infringes on your patent.
By the way, it is very doubtful any woodworking tool manufacturer will buy your's or anyone's design outright (too risky and costly for them, for what may turn out to be a pig in a poke) so licensing is the only realistic option. Since the licensee will be paying all costs to turn your idea into a manufactureable, retail-ready product, typical licensing fees for this type of stuff are only 0% to 5% of wholesale (upper range for items with REALLY good sales potential or those that are patented or likely patentable. Say your widget retails for $20 and wholesales for $10. At best, you will only receive .05 X $10 or $.50 (50 cents) for each item sold. Each product, each company, each licensing agreement are unique- some may want to limit your compensation to a certain total or to a certain period of time. Unless your widget is a high-dollar and high-volume item, it won't make you rich- extra beer money maybe.
My suggestions:
1. First, educate yourself on the patent and licensing processes- read Pressman's "Patent Pending in 24 Hours" or any of Pressman's books on the patenting process. They are available from Amazon or in the reference sections of some libraries. Read the World Intellectual Property Office (WIPO) training manual on Licensing Intellectual Property (available online).
2. Do an informal patent search to make sure your idea hasn't already been invented- use Google Patents for free. Check retail catalogs to see if anyone is currently marketing something similar. A sobering statistic- depending on which source you read, 95% - 99% of "all patented items" never make it to market!!!! (not because they aren't good ideas, but because they can't be economically manufactured.)
3. Build the best prototype possible to ensure it works like you want.
4. Prepare a well written and illustrated product information brouchure.
5. Go to Rockler's website- they have a product idea submission process.
6. FASTCAP likewise accepts new ideas- you can read about it on their website.
7. Try Lee Valley/Veritas.