Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

To patent or NOT to patent?

Posts

To patent or NOT to patent?

#1

To patent or NOT to patent?

David C. Lykins

Hello everyone at Wood Central. Unfortunately like many in the US, I lost my full time job in 2008, worked a couple of contract gigs after that but in 2011 I lost both my job (contract ended) and then lost my home. In July of 2011, I reluctantly moved to Illinois and have been living with family and STILL unable to find ANY employment. Therefore I'm contemplating to either file for a patent or just present a tool I designed and prototyped to a company and try to get royalties. A few years ago I had a couple of E-mails with Incra and they seemed somewhat interested in the tool but I've sat on my butt about it because of the cost to get CAD drawings and file for a provisional patent.

The tool that I invented will mark and punch the center of a billet to be turned on a wood lathe, in addition it has a place to attach a pencil in order to mark the center line of a piece of wood even if the wood is wider at one end. You can actually mark and punch the center of the piece of turning wood in just a couple of seconds versus drawing lines and then using a center punch.

Anyway, I don't feel as though I have the funds to have a CAD drawing done and file for the "provisional" patent, so I'm contemplating giving up the patent & manufacturing rights and presenting it to a couple of companies that would hopefully pay me a royalty.

So I guess my question is "What would you do?"

Any suggestions are GREATLY appreciated.

THANKS!

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

#2

Clint Searl

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

Clint Searl

1. It's a limited market; who's gonna buy it; so estimate how many might get sold and at what cost and price.

2. What would you get from each sale? Times forecast = your income.

3. Can it be easily replicated by a manufacturer or craftsman?

4. Is it unique enough to be patentable?

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

#3

Re: To patent or NOT to patent? *LINK*

Dick Coers

Patents are only as good as your ability to protect it. What if you spend the money for the patent search and patent attorney. You get the patent and then someone violates it. How would you afford a lawyer to sue them and then have a lengthy court battle? Then if not found in your favor, you pay the lawyer bills. As has been the case for almost forever, takes money to make money. Even with that show the Shark Tank, those people have to sign an agreement with the production company, that 5% of your company, or 2% of your future royalties, has to be paid to them, even if no "Sharks" want to partner with you. Find someone to buy the idea. Sure won't be easy because they will want to see working prototypes and probably field testing reports.


http://www.forbes.com/sites/jjcolao/2013/06/13/is-shark-tank-really-worth-5-of-your-company-business-owners-say-absolutely/

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

#4

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

Tom in Toronto

I actually had a big idea a couple of years ago that I thought was worth millions on how to revolutionize and capture the patent process. Just because of things like this.

All that said, I think you may want to consider a patent anyway, if only to protect your rights not to have someone else come in on top of your invention. Stopping someone else from making your thing is just one part, and relatively hopeless. But you can end up unable to make your own invention, because it gets patented by others. Another reason for protection is if you do want to sell it to someone, it has to be patentable anyway. I have no idea what the cheapest way to have your patent registered is in the US. I have looked at a variety of patents, and never seen a cad drawing with any of them.

If you are thinking of a patent look into what patents actually cover. You may have a very good product that is not already out there, that does not mean it is novel in the way patents are intended to cover novel stuff. These days most of the patents I see, seem to have little original in them, so you can get a number issue for almost anything, it really doesn't mean much. This is a step beyond the previous world where protection was often a mater of litigation, as others have mentioned. Today, the patent office is either so swamped, or so careless that they issue ridiculous patents leaving it to litigation to ferret out whether the patent should have been issued as well as whether it will stand. So the fact you achieve a patent, is a bit like insurance; you don't even know what you have in the way of coverage, until you go to court, and you can loose there regardless.

Not sure I would buy your product, there are so many versions of a tool like that, that I don't see sufficient added value. Not that lack of novelty, or utility seems to stop many woodworking tools. I would approach Lee Valley. They would pretty much need to sell your product anyway. They do make products other woodturners have invented. And they do have a reputation for honesty.

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

#5

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

OK- I'm talking from experience here- the INCRA I-BOX, Infinity Lock Miter Master, and a half a dozen other products in various stages of development.

First, there is no such thing as a "Provisional Patent" just a Provisional Patent "Application." A PPA doesn't result in a patent. It is fairly new as far as the patent process goes, being created during the Carter Administration. It is very limited in what it does and the protection it provides- not much. A non-disclosure agreement provides almost the same protection with potential licensees, though not all will sign an NDA. A PPA basically provides a date marker, that when combined with a follow-on "Utility Patent Application" establishes the earliest date of invention. It only costs a tad over $100 to file on-line (there are penalties for not filing online). There is no set format so high-end CAD drawings aren't mandatory. I used one of the SketchUp stylistic line drawing formats but believe you may be able to submit scanned, carefully hand-drawn illustrations (check on that first). A PPA is reviewed by USPTO just to make sure the required elements (applicant sheet, description, drawings, fees) were submitted, but the content is NOT reviewed, unless there is a challenge to a subsequent Utility Patent Application that claims the earlier PPA date. A PPA is only valid for one year and can not be renewed. You can use "Patent Pending" during that year. If there is a delay (no overlap) in filing for a Utility Patent Application you can not claim the earlier date.

A Utility Patent Application costs only slightly over $2000+ in filing fees (see here: http://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/ac/qs/ope/fee010114.htm ). I say "only" because in addition to the filing fees and depending on the complexity of the item and application, patent attorney fees can run $10,000 - $20,000 or more. It is nearly impossible for an individual to file without using a patent attorney due to the language, negotiation process, etc. etc. Then, if you are lucky enough to have a patent issue, you must pay maintenance fees at various anniversaries to keep it in force: 3.5 yr ($400), 7.5 yr ($900), 11.5 ($1850) for a "micro-entity"; much more if you don't qualify as such. Oh, as others have said, a patent is only as good as the attorney you hire to defend it. USPTO does not take any action against anyone who infringes on your patent.

By the way, it is very doubtful any woodworking tool manufacturer will buy your's or anyone's design outright (too risky and costly for them, for what may turn out to be a pig in a poke) so licensing is the only realistic option. Since the licensee will be paying all costs to turn your idea into a manufactureable, retail-ready product, typical licensing fees for this type of stuff are only 0% to 5% of wholesale (upper range for items with REALLY good sales potential or those that are patented or likely patentable. Say your widget retails for $20 and wholesales for $10. At best, you will only receive .05 X $10 or $.50 (50 cents) for each item sold. Each product, each company, each licensing agreement are unique- some may want to limit your compensation to a certain total or to a certain period of time. Unless your widget is a high-dollar and high-volume item, it won't make you rich- extra beer money maybe.

My suggestions:

1. First, educate yourself on the patent and licensing processes- read Pressman's "Patent Pending in 24 Hours" or any of Pressman's books on the patenting process. They are available from Amazon or in the reference sections of some libraries. Read the World Intellectual Property Office (WIPO) training manual on Licensing Intellectual Property (available online).

2. Do an informal patent search to make sure your idea hasn't already been invented- use Google Patents for free. Check retail catalogs to see if anyone is currently marketing something similar. A sobering statistic- depending on which source you read, 95% - 99% of "all patented items" never make it to market!!!! (not because they aren't good ideas, but because they can't be economically manufactured.)

3. Build the best prototype possible to ensure it works like you want.

4. Prepare a well written and illustrated product information brouchure.

5. Go to Rockler's website- they have a product idea submission process.

6. FASTCAP likewise accepts new ideas- you can read about it on their website.

7. Try Lee Valley/Veritas.

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

#6

Before you do anything else

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

Before you discuss this with any company you need to be careful. This is an area where you really need to talk to a patent attorney. They will cost you something, but most will give you an opinion of whether you have the needed documentation so far to protect your idea. Stay away from the do it yourself patent companies. If you have not documented the development process and the fact you have already disclosed the existence to a company may have limited your rights. Your first step is to get a disclosure filed.

Lee

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

#7

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Having worked as an Engineer for near 40 years prior to my retirement, the above suggestions are quite good. The newest term for "stealing" ideas is "Benchmarking". Basically what this means is that a company (almost all large companies do this), take an existing invention apart, and decide what they can do to get around the existing patent protection. Our company existed for over 100 years but has now has been sold, had a full time patent attorney on staff in our branch, and several at the corporate level. If the group which included Manufacturing and Design Engineers and the Patent attorney determined the product was viable and profitable for our company, usually a way was found to get around the existing patent. Of course our company had the same issues with our patented designs so there were usually patent fights going on continuously!

I have designed many automated assembly and testing machines in my career, non were ever patented as the cost / benefit was not feasible. Most of my machines were covered up when visitors were taken through the plant and the machines were considered proprietary designs. This was due to the fact that if patented a design drawing would have to be submitted - once that was done, competitors could usually get around the patent and utilize at least the main (unique) features of the design.

In my opinion it would be impossible for an individual to protect a design patent as the funds are not available.

The other issue is that although you may have a great idea, you can't afford to conduct a market survey or determine a manufacturing cost analysis. This is routine for any company to determine the feasibility of investing in a new product.

While the return in money seems low when licensing a product, most of the time it is reasonable when you are aware of the costs incurred in bringing a product to market. Another point is that those interested in your invention already have an existing marketing team that can field the product to their existing retail customer base.

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

#8

MUST READ! *LINK*

Rick Christopherson

Alan said everything I would have said (if I wasn't so lazy this morning). The only thing I disagree with is the cost of a utility patent when you already have a PPA in place.

When you hear about patents costing tens of thousands of dollars, they are not for simple mechanical designs. Those high costs come from the complexity of the claims required, which is much more limited on simpler designs. Most importantly though, is if you take some time to write your own "claims", the attorney won't need as much time to rewrite them in more precise forms.

The thing about both the PPA and the PA is that while they are being reviewed, no one can know what parts of your design are covered by the claims. This means a company will be less likely to try to skirt the claims because they don't know what those claims are.

I picked up "Patent Pending in 24 hours" at the library and it was very helpful.

As for approaching another company, a nondisclosure agreement is far more effective than a patent or patent application. It is far easier to defend and enforce.

If this is really a marketable product, consider being the manufacturer yourself and simply sell to these companies. I sell my Domino Guides (shown below for your reference) all over the world and have quite a few distributors. As a matter of fact, it is when I asked about a PPA at this very forum, one of those manufactures read my posting and offered up the advise of his own legal department to me. A couple years later he became one of my larger distributors.


img

http://www.dominoguide.com/

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

#9

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Thanks to Larry and Chris for adding to what I said.

Another note about Lee Valley/Veritas, they pay a % of what Lee Valley (the retail side) pays Veritas (the manufacturing side). They receive thousands of proposals a year. After a detailed review process, if they like your idea, they will classify it as an "active project" then may spend many months to over a year evaluating and developing it, only to decide in their final review that they will not marketing it for one reason or another. They look at various embodiments and applications, trying is some cases to attempt to turn a sow's ear into a silk purse. The final product may look totally different than what you submitted, but they pay you licensing fees in any case.

I think the real takeaways from our posts, are you need to spend time getting as smart as possible about this process and that it is rare that you will be able to avoid spending money on lawyers, prototypes, etc., etc. The patent process is really stacked against the little guy. FYI, one of the "We will help you patent your invention" TV commercials by "Invent Help" lauds an invention, the "Splash Wash" an inflatable water amusement for kids, that was eventually licensed by Whammo. They have been the target of law suites and FTC investigations. If you you see the commercial listen very carefully to the FTC mandated disclaimer at the end- "Results not typical, most inventions are not successful, etc. etc." or words to that effect. What they don't say is that they received non-reimbursable fees regardless! The same goes for USPTO patent filing and patent attorney fees- you get no money back if a patent doesn't issue.

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

#10

Oops

Rick Christopherson

It occurred to me that my previous title came across wrong. I meant that Alan's posting was a "must read", not mine.

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

#11

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

David C. Lykins

Well as usual you guys have provided me with a WEALTH of great information. And just so you'll know, I have read the book "Patent Pending in 24 Hours" and I also took a class on filing for patents when I lived in GA.

After reading all of your gracious replies, I have come to the conclusion that with my financial situation I can not really afford to get CAD drawings and file for the Provisional Patent. Therefore I'm just going to contact companies such as Rockler, Lee Valley, Incra etc. and see if they have any interest in the product. It's quite obvious from what I have educated my self on and what your replies indicate I would be signing a "Non Disclosure" with ANYONE interested in the product. However I did learn from you guys that the "Non Disclosure" holds more water than expected and that it's a document that would stand up in a court of law if necessary.

I would really love to manufacture the tool myself, or have someone manufacture the parts and assemble it myself as I unfortunately have tons of spare time. But again, I just don't believe I have the finances to be able to do so. The up side is that if I did manufacture/assemble it myself I have several friends that could help me build a website in order to market the tool. It's a REAL shame that it's so difficult to patent an idea and try to get it out to the world. I have another item that I've built for my RC Aircraft hobby, its a work stand that doubles as an stand to haul your planes to the flying field. Before I moved to Illinois a buddy and I manufactured about 50 of these stands in my wood working shop to take to the RC Swap meet in Perry GA. So I took the product from a prototype to creating, designing and writing an instructions manual, to manufacturing 50 kits. Every time I go to a new RC field to fly people ask me where I got it. And every time I sell one to someone they indicate how much they use it and like it. My point is that I believe there are MANY ideas or prototypes of tools, software, etc that will never get into the hands of the consumer because of the expense and difficulty of getting patents.

Thank you all so much for your willingness to share your thoughts and expertise. You have all been VERY helpful.

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

#12

Re: To patent or NOT to patent?

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

If you believe in your idea, don't give up until you have exhausted all options (or have exceeded your self-imposed spending limit). Also some designs that started out being manufactured by the designers are eventually licensed by companies. If the design isn't patented and a company copies it without a license they can't be sued for infringement but they may incur significant industry and customer backlash so they must consider that before they steal your idea. That doesn't bother some companies however.

Sometimes it can take awhile for a idea to catch on. Timing is hard to judge. In the real story about the Water Washer in the commercial I mentioned, the inventor had been turned down and thought he was done. He finally got a call from out of the blue a few years later. I don't know how much he made or makes, or whether it was a one-time payment or license, but I couldn't find his product on the Whammo website. Following the licensing examples in the WIPO manual, one of the terms I put in my contracts is that the design is mine again if the licensee doesn't bring it to market in a reasonable amount of time or if it they no longer manufacture and market it. Also, according to the WIPO manual EVERYTHING is negotiable. I just rejected a licensing agreement because I thought the terms were unsatisfactory.

To reiterate, you don't need CAD drawings for a PPA.

One thing I failed to mention that you may have read in Pressman's book, is that filing a PPA can have negative consequences. If you or your licensee doesn't follow the PPA with a Utility Patent Application you will lose the earlier filing date and the right to claim “patent pending” status during the lapse. You can still file a regular Utility Patent Application and acquire patent rights to your invention, as long as you did not publish information about it or offer it for sale before you filed the Utility Patent Application. If you did, it is now in the public domain so can not be patented.