Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Still fooling with new toy, Compressor

Posts

Still fooling with new toy, Compressor

#1

Still fooling with new toy, Compressor

Keith Newton

In an earlier post, I mention getting a new carry-around compressor, and wishing to make it quieter. I still don't have the new silencer/filters, but have modified the one which came on it.

If you press your lips together, and suck in hard against them, then quickly open them trying to make a popping sound, this is essentially what is part of the source of noise for lots of small compressors.

This new one has a single cylinder driven by a direct drive 3500 rpm motor, so it produces a pulsing implosion 3500 times a minute, or 58 per second. You can unscrew the filter, and place a finger over the hole, blocking all inflow to see how much noise goes away by eliminating that.

This one has an inclosed oil crank-case, so I'm not getting any noise from under the cylinder, which I think may be where most of the noise comes from most oilless compressors.

Anyway, I rolled up a old wool sock and stretched it over the stock filter, and was pretty happy with the noise reduction. I drained the tank, and ran a full cycle from empty to full pressure with and without the sock. It took about 15 seconds longer with the sock on the stock filter. It takes one minute without the sock.

I had already been thinking about drilling a few more holes in the cap of one of the new ones, still on the way, but then though, why wait? so drilled 3 additional holes in this stock filter.

This should cut the velocity of the air entering the top of the filter by 75%, and with the sock back on, the noise is even lower, and the cycle time is back to the one minute shutoff from empty time. I don't expect the new metal filter which is in rout to me will improve this any, but it is good to know, and I thought worth sharing.

Now, if some of you have one of those really loud oilless ones, besides doing this, I would be looking to see if there is an exhaust port for the underside of the cylinder that I'd be trying to muffle that end too.

Re: Still fooling with new toy, Compressor

#2

You need a Jun Air compressor

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I can't hear mine running in a quiet room. The only noise it makes is a whoosh when the pressure releases at the end of filling the tank.

Re: Still fooling with new toy, Compressor

#3

Finally!

John in NM

A use for old wool socks! :D :D :D

Let me know if you run out, I have lots :D

Re: Still fooling with new toy, Compressor

#4

Re: You need a Jun Air compressor

Keith Newton

Sheesh, That is out of my price range. Did you buy new, or find a deal on the aftermarket, and how big is yours? This is the first time I've looked at this brand, and didn't find much info about hp, and cfm.

Can you tell anything about how they managed to keep it so quiet? The ads claim ~45 Db, which is not something I can measure, or know how to relate to. Although I looked for an iPhone app this morning, and can get several options, but then, it really doesn't matter what the number is, so long as I'm satisfied.

Just to make it clear, I have managed to make this one much better, and I'm happy with it now.

Re: Still fooling with new toy, Compressor

#5

Re: You need a Jun Air compressor

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I got it used. It runs a trim nailer just fine and in a pinch I sprayed (slowly) daughters front door with it as an air source

Re: Still fooling with new toy, Compressor

#6

More improvements to Filter?Silencer *LINK*

Keith Newton

Well, one of the new metal filter/silencers that I ordered from Amazon came in today. While the body was metal, and the actual filter was a pleated paper, it may have been quieter than the stock, but sure had some other problems that I couldn't live with.

First thing I noticed, was that the 3/8' NPT nipple, wasn't 3/8" ID, but actually 1/32 over 1/4", or 9/32", as well as the hole in the cap where the air entered the filter. This was a long plastic tube, which extended almost all the way across the cap. Both of these elements reduced the inflow of air, adding 11 seconds to the run time from empty to shutoff, over what I got after my modifications.

I never got around to downloading the app to my phone to be able to measure decibels, but I'm satisfied that I greatly reduced the noise, and of course shortening the run time helps by just not having to listen to any noise for a longer duration.

Here are some time stats to compare. All of these were from empty to shutoff.

1. No filter 0:53

2. Stock filter base with no filter element. 0:53.2

3. New filter base, with and without filter 1:00

4.New filter with it's cap on, with long 1/4" ID tube 1:08.5

I already knew that adding a rolled up sock added 10 seconds, so skipped that.

5. I drilled out the ring in the bottom of pipe nipple,

And removed the small tube, drilled 3 more holes,

Added a rolled up sock over filter which silenced more. 0:57.5

So I made it quieter, and shortened run time with very little effort, or expense. The new filter is probably not any quieter than the stock one with the sock pre-filter/silencer.

If any of you are using a small loud compressor, just unscrew the filter, then stick your finger over the intake hole, will give you instant feedback for the noise that can be reduced by getting rid of this bad filter design.

One last note. The run time from when the pressure switch kicks in, to turning off was 0:12.6 seconds.


http://www.flickr.com/photos/7391658@N03/sets/72157640944872455/

Re: Still fooling with new toy, Compressor

#7

Re: More improvements to Filter?Silencer

Barry Irby

I will be checking mine. Thanks for the research.

One thought. Keep and eye on your sock filter. My compressor is in the shed next to my shop (out of ear shot but also out of sight and out of mind) and I forget about it. One day I looked at it and the filter was incredibly dirty and partially sucked into the machine. Don't ignore yours.

Re: Still fooling with new toy, Compressor

#8

That will be easier now.

Keith Newton

Since the sock is right by the handle, I can see it and blow it off, without even removing it. It will act as a pre-filter, which should make that little inside filter stay cleaner longer. Plus, now with 4 holes in the cap, I can see inside, and blow out through one of them, without taking the cap off.

This is the last I'm going to mention it. I can't believe there hasn't been any more discussion about it. Not one person after over 225 reading it has come back, and said they tried the sock, or even looked at their filter. This to me, is like buying a plane, and never sharpening the blade, because the manufacturer knows more about sharpening than you do.

Re: Still fooling with new toy, Compressor

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Tucked away...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...in the deep, dark recesses of my mind is this thread. My double-stack portable (barely) compressor has a filter arrangement very similar to yours, but since I don't use it that much, it's low on my priority list right now to quiet it down.

Jason

Re: Still fooling with new toy, Compressor

#10

Re: That will be easier now.

mdclor

My compressor is in a separate room so noise isn't an issue for me although I do appreciate your research. When I had an oilless compressor in the main shop, I would have been all over your solutions.