Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

Posts

Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#1

Finally bought a small compressor.  *LINK*

Keith Newton

Got the little Rolair 2 hp, FC2002. I've been needing a small one to take out for the little quick installations, and was thinking I would buy their silent 1 hp one right up until I ordered this one. They look virtually the same, but didn't refer to this one as silent. However, I figured it would be a lot quieter than most of the small oilless ones, and it is, but not as quiet as I would like.

I think I will like it just fine, and I'm sure it will handle some larger nail guns. The only thing that seems like it would make it better, is that the intake filter is a thin plastic cap, about as substantial as the cap which comes on a can of spray paint. I'm thinking I could make it quieter by buying a steel housed filter to replace this one. Maybe even try to move up a size with a pipe adapter. Have any of you experimented with this and found ways to make your compressor quieter?

I can find an all metal filter, which also claims to be silencer of the same dimensions. Any engineers here? It seems to me that metal wouldn't resonate as bad, and I can't tell if the one I've linked to only has one intake hole, but I would think that if there were more, the volume and velocity of air rushing in would drop, and reduce the noise.


http://www.amazon.com/Interstate-Pneumatics-Compressor-Filter-Replacement/dp/B0079275UK/ref=pd_sim_sbs_hi_3

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#2

Re: Finally bought a small compressor.

Ralph Lipeles

Keith,

I have a 6' high, 5 or 6 HP compressor. I put it in a room next to the primary workshop and ran a line through the cieling to the workshop. This keeps things quiet for most of what I do without adding much complexity.

Ralph Lipeles

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#3

Well, You guys are no help.

Keith Newton

There are so many of those small but loud compressors out there, I would have figured everybody that owned one would have tried to find a way to silence them.

I have ordered two different brands of metal-housing silencer/filters to try out.

I'll try to remember to report back when they come in if they help.

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#4

Re: Finally bought a small compressor.

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Are you sure you need a compressor for these small installations? Here's an alternate approach:

http://www.talkfestool.com/vb/festool-tanos-all-things-systainer/2129-complete-pneumatic-gun-system-systainer.html

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#5

Ellis Walentine

Not much help here

Ellis Walentine

I've owned several small compressors and my Campbell Hausfeld, with the two side tanks, is the quietest I've had, which isn't saying much. I know they make mufflers for shop vacs, so I imagine someone has come up with something for compressors, but I have never seen one.

I've found that the oilless compressors are louder than the oil-filled ones, for what that's worth.

If you solve this one, let us know.

Ellis

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#6

Thanks Ellis and William,

Keith Newton

While I like the looks of that case with the Co2 tanks, I don't know if anybody locally stocks those, and I have to wonder how quickly they would empty whenever I need to use a framing gun.

Over the last two weeks when the weather was nice, I went over to replace a high deck on my sister's house. Rather than take my old Rolair MODEL#6820K17 with the two side by side tanks, which weighs 174#. I'm getting too old to be picking that thing up by myself anymore, to put in the back of my truck.

Ben brought his Pancake oilless. I don't like even being near one of those things outdoors, much less in a small room with one of those. When he is in the shop, I can borrow his, but he is off taking on jobs of his own a lot now.

A few years ago, I had a small battery powered one which was fine for brad or staple gun, but the batteries are shot.

While my new compressor is the same hp as the old roll around, the old one is quieter. It is a twin cylinder, with a much larger filter, which screws in with 3/4" NPT. While one cylinder is pulling in, the other is on the way up, so there is a constant inflow of air. The new one, spins a single cylinder at twice the speed, with a 3/8" intake, which has 1/4 the area of the other intake. But I think the worse part, is the pulsing of those virtual mini-implosions at a higher frequency.

Placing a finger of that one little 3/8" hole in this plastic filter gives me an idea of how quiet I should be able to make it. As it is, it seems to me that this plastic one acts somewhat like a speaker diaphragm.

As I stated above, I have two steel ones on the way. If they both only have one hole for intake air, I'm planning to drill a couple of more in one to try. And, when Sassy was a pup, she chewed a big hole in one of my thickest pairs of heavy hunting socks. I'm thinking that rolling it back onto itself about six times, slipped over the outside of that filter, will also deaden those pulses.

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#7

Re: Finally bought a small compressor.

Barry Irby

I looked at the CO-2 versions and had some misgivings. What am I to do if I get on a job and use up my Gas? I also thought they had discontinued those but I am not sure. I think Lowe's no longer carries them. and i think you get fairly large number of shots on small guns but ridiculously few on a framing nailer. An alternative might be to buy larger CO-2 tanks, but you would still need to calculate the cost per shot and it would only delay the inevitable.

OTOH, back in the day, we used to run nailers on the construction site with nitrogen bottles. I had a regulator that dropped the presure down to whatever and we could staple off about 100 sheets of plywood on a single large bottle for about $15. I thought, even then that 15 cents a sheet was cheap. No noise, no maintenance, nothing to steal. They were outlawed because of the danger of passing the enormous tank pressure to the gun and blowing the head off if the regulator failed. I'm guessing co-2 does not generate that much pressure. ????

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#8

Simple, Cheap, Easy solution.....

Barry Irby

Shooters muffs.

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#9

Re: Thanks Ellis and William,

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

A couple other posibilities you might explore: On both festoolownersgroup.com and talkfestool.com there are threads in the Systainer sections describing other compressors that have been installed in Systainers. In most cases, I think the driving force is the portability, not the noise. My impression is that a Systainer, by itself, doesn't dampen a lot of sound, since they are ABS plastic, mostly less than 1/8" thick. There are foam inserts that there should still be some room for that would help the noise level. Both Festool/Tanos and FastCap (Kaizen) sell foam that should help.

I found one of the compressor products (commercially available in Europe, but not the U.S.) very interesting, in that the pressure gauges, controls and hose connectors were brought out to the front of the Systainer.

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#10

Re: Simple, Cheap, Easy solution.....

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I should get a pair that will fit my shop dog. :^) She's afraid of the P-C pancake compressor in the shop, and usually won't go in. Yesterday, instead of helping out, she went off into the woods and found something to roll in.

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#11

Re: Simple, Cheap, Easy solution.....

Keith Newton

Hey William, The rolled up sock idea came to me after ordering that new filter/silencer. Then it occurred to me to try it with this stock filter. It made enough difference, that I probably would not have ordered a new one, had I tried this first.

OTO, I think that a lot of the noise of the oilless compressors like yours, comes from the underside of the piston blasting that equal volume of air of the cylinder in and back out on each stroke unmuffled.

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#12

2 Hoses?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

This may be an "Internet Mythe" but if you've got the hose, try it.

As the story goes, most of the noise comes from the compressor intake through filter which, as usual, is on the compressor, so you disconnect the filter, attach an air hose and run it outside, then put your filter on the end of the hose with a threaded coupling so all the intake noise is contained and muffled by the rubber hose.

Hey, if it works, let us know. ;)

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#13

When I installed...

McKay

I would use two or three hoses and put the compressor far, far away in a distant galaxy...(I digress). Why not put the thing somewhere away from the action?

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#14

This is not my shop compressor.

Keith Newton

This is just for small projects when I don't want to haul one up a flight of stairs, or up and elevator into a condo, when I need to install something.

I like to listen to the radio, or music while i work, and don't like to miss something or have to run away when the phone rings. Life is too short to have to listen to a loud compressor.

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#15

Re: Simple, Cheap, Easy solution.....

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I need to get it out from under my bench, and put it in a box stuffed with foam. The problem is I sometimes need to haul it out of the shop and put it away again when I'm done, and it's a little too big to fit in a systainer. I should put it up in the loft with the dust collector, which is amazingly quiet up there.

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#16

William, maybe this is what you need... *LINK*

Keith Newton

This is what I started to get, but changed my mind while I was placing my order.

I don't think I can get this one down to this level, but just putting that rolled up sock around my filter helped a lot, and I think I can still get it down some more.

Who knows, maybe if you got one of these, your dog will love you again, and quit punishing you. ha


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AkiakH-raAQ

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#17

Re: William, maybe this is what you need...

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I recognized my PC at the start of the video. The dog didn't get up and run off, probably only because of the miniscule iPad speaker. My next door neighbor also has one, and she runs away from that one as well. Our local handyman/carpenter also has one, and if he fires it up a block away, she panics.

Mine was hard to say "no" to, as it was a reconditioned unit, and I got a significant employee discount. But, maybe it is time to consider trading it in.

My wife was so impressed by the Rolair JC10 that she asked me to send her the link to the review.

Re: Finally bought a small compressor. *LINK*

#18

Hey, Alrighty then, Your good to go..

Keith Newton

Just tell here that with what you can sell yours for, and here credit card, you'll put and end to the noise. Not only will it make your dog happier, peace with the significant other ought to be worth the difference. Yesser, we got us a plan. ha