Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

surface planning marks on walnut

Posts

surface planning marks on walnut

#1

surface planning marks on walnut

Jim Coats

I planed 9" wide walnut boards for a bookshelf on my delta 12" planer and got pauses while feeding planer about every 8 to 12" leaving straight line marks across the boards where pause occurred. question 1. how can I keep this from happening 2. Is there any solution to remove the marks outside of hand planing. I don't want to sand this walnut

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#2

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

Chuck in Mtl.

I would check the knives for sharpness, check the feed mechanism for slipping and also if the the cut is too deep.

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#3

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

del schisler

are the chip's and dust taken out with a vacuum? if not that will happen , walnut is dry and lot's of walnut dust , which make's the wood slip in the roller's, why not sand the walnut ? i sand all my wood that come's out of my planner , and i have a delta, vaccum , and the chip's and dust dont get caught in the shoot , check for the above good luck

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#4

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

Barry Irby

I had that problem with my Dewalt Planer. turned out there are two drive chains like bicycle chains and one of them had a frozen or sticky link in it. When that link would go across the sprockets it would cause the head to jump, leaving a line. I replaced the chains and the roller bushings that were slightly wallowed out. Not sure yours is built the same, but that worked for me.

And I would sand the wood anyway. Can't believe any planer leaves a proper surface for the finish. Or, maybe some of the guys on the Hand Tool forum can explain how to produce a good enough surface without sand paper.

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#5

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Why do you want/need to avoid sanding?

To answer one of your questions, keep pulling or pushing force on the lumber as it is feeding.

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#6

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

David Yoho

I've got the Delta 13" planer and it's done the same thing a few times on walnut and some other stuff. Two things I see that could be making that happen is the in-feed roller (even with dust collection) gathers dust and chips, which causes some slippage, or the stock is bowed a little.

For the first issue, I keep an old tooth brush handy and run it back and forth across the roller while it's running to clear the dust. This works but be careful.

For the second issue, I go back to the jointer and make a few passes to flatten the stock. If you are already at the desired thickness, you're too late for this.

Finally, if you're at your desired thickness and have those lines, you can remove them with a cabinet scraper because they're not deep. At least that's my experience with that.

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#7

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

Steve Jenkins

Make sure the bed is well waxed.

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#8

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

Steve Schoene

It certainly is desirable to tweak your planer to get the best results possible. Still, even with a machine set up very well, there isn't a planer that gives results so perfect that they don't need additional attention either by sanding or with a hand smooth plane if one aims for quality work.

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#9

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

paul in AZ

skipping and pausing are likely due to slipping feed rollers.

I periodically clean the rollers on mine with alcohol.

That and making sure that the bed is clean and slippy.

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#10

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

If you don't want to hand plane it and you don't want to sand it (whether the planer is skipping or not) the only other acceptable choice is scraping it to remove the scalloped surface and burnishing caused by the planer knives. Usually scraping does not leave a surface as acceptable as a properly tuned and wielded hand plane, or as sanding.

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#11

A perfectly prepared scraper...

Dick Coers

"Usually scraping does not leave a surface as acceptable as a properly tuned and wielded hand plane, or as sanding."

A well prepared scraper will leave a perfect finish. In fact you can use them to remove orange peel on clear finish, they do a great job. But as many have mentioned, mill marks are left by any thickness planer and always need to be removed. Plenty of good advice on what to do to the planer. I always keep hand pressure on the indeed side to assist the planer, then move to the out feed side to do the same.

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#12

Three Things To Do

Howard Acheson

1. Get your knives sharpened or buy new

2. Use alcohol to wipe and clean the feed rollers and the planer bed

3. Wax the planer bed with paste wax

If those don't work, keep slight feed pressure with your hand. Be sure to use a pusher board to keep pressure on the last couple of inches

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#13

Besides the other suggestions,

Keith Newton

As others have suggested, it always helps when you are more specific.

Was the Walnut rough when you started? How good was the milled surface, did it fluctuate in thickness, or was it straight? Had the board dried straight, or was it wavy.

If you had already surfaced the bottom side on jointer so it was straight, sometimes it good to hit a light pass on the top.

If your thickness increased after starting to feed, you may have gotten thicker than could pass under the rollers, so a quick crank up will get you past that problem. Then you can drop it down a tiny bit more than your first starting point, and you shouldn't see any evidence, assuming you have done what the others have suggested.

If you didn't have a good flat face down to start with, all bets are off, that is where you start.

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#14

Re: Besides the other suggestions,

gary peterson

The clean rollers, sharp knives, waxed tables, not too deep a cut esp if first three are there are all good. On the marks, skim cut the board with a minimalist depth of cut, you can generally come through without any stoppage

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#15

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

Jim Coats

Thanks to everyone who responded to my question. Votes are in and I think I will sand the walnut. I bought the stock rough cut and some was not real flat which was part to blame. The other suggestions were very good and next time I will certainly implement all the suggestions.

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#16

There is another way

Mark Hennebury

If you are looking for this:



You could use one of these:

http://youtu.be/eaClhzlpc_0

More info on the machines and how they work:

http://www.solidwoodmachinery.com/supersurfacers.htm

Re: surface planning marks on walnut

#17

Re: There is another way

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Or you could find a flea market Stanley #4, blueprint the sole and the frog, sharpen the iron, and set the chip breaker really close (just close enough that you weren't corrugating the shavings). ;^)