Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

Posts

Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

#1

Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Adding the facing 8

For rustic/country/ primitive style I would leave the dovetails exposed. But I want a more formal look to this piece so they will be covered up. Back a few steps there was step I did not describe. An 1/8” thick strip was sawed from what would become the front side of the board used to make the side panel. This strip was sawed off when this board was 1/16” thicker than the side thickness, leaving it 1/16” wider than the final case side thickness. This strip would become the facing to cover the dovetails. Grain match on the side between this facing strip and case side will therefore be well matched.

Note: The edges of wide boards are usually rift grain so grain matching is typically easy.

I use a 40T- 7 ½” very thin kerf Industrial quality blade for this operation. Well, in fact, I use the blade almost exclusively for woodworking, but we have discussed that all before. The goal is to be able to glue it back on and have the grain match on the side. With care one can get a “glue joint” rip with this blade, or at worse a tiny amount of sanding/planing will be required to get an “invisible” joint.

PIC1


There is a trick to installing this strip on the case side. It was sized to overhang the case side just 1/32” , to be trimmed after it was installed. Any slip during gluing it on can lead to disaster. To prevent it from skidding during installation, first drive a few fine gauge brads down the side and clip the heads off, leaving them sticking up 1/16”. The facing strip is then positioned to align the grain on the side as well as the overhang on the edge and given a bash with a hammer to set the brads into the strip. One now has indexing holes in the strip to reposition the strip on the case side after the glue is applied. It can’t skid when clamped.

PIC 2



PIC 3


The horizontal facing is cut from straight grained wood so as to not detract from the figured drawer fronts. The idea is to frame the drawers. These facing strips must be accurately fit and it is trivial to do so. Ideally they should be just a tiny bit long so that when captured between the vertical facing strips they will bow up slightly before gluing, as shown in the picture. How to make them such an accurate length? With a fine tooth hand saw, saw them about 1/16” too long and trim to length on a shooting board. Given that a few thousandths of an inch per pass can be taken off the ends with the plane the fit can be accurate.

PIC4


Note: If the front edge profile is other than flat, “darts” will be required at the intersection of the horizontal and vertical facing strips.

PIC5




In days past I would then sand and scrape the facing strips to smooth them and get them to align at the intersections. The inevitable grain reversals made planing them too risky for me. No longer the case. With the plane cap iron set very close to the edge of the blade tip there is no risk of tear-out no matter how the grain is running. (See Article by Weaver in Articles Section of WoodCentral on setting up the cap iron, or stay tuned for the next edition of Popular Woodworking). I still can’t manage a large plane teetering on a board edge and keep it under control. However, this more narrow block plane is easier to keep flat on the edge to be planed.

Note: When I made this plane I made the mouth tight as directed by David Finck. With the mouth tight, an ineffective means of avoiding grain tear-out in my hands, the cap iron can not be set close or the shavings jam. With the “rediscovery” of the cap iron effect, and the encouragement of “Kees” and Weaver, I said screw it and opened up the mouth to enable the cap iron to be set close. Works great.

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

#2

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

Barry Irby

I have been thinking about this. When you posted the picture of the yellow pine sub top I wondered about the front edge and how you would treat it. When you mentioned you were going to add the strips to the front edges my thought was the smart move would have been to slice the strips off the front edges first so you could glue them back on and minimize the appearance. Apparently we think alike on that.

I like the appearance of the dovetails and think you should leave them visible to show off/celebrate them, but I see you point about the style influence.

As a suggestion, what do you think about leaving the horizontals Proud of the sides and trimming the tails off and then installing the Strips on the verticals? It would eliminate gluing the strip on the horizontals.

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

#3

Your suggestion

David Yoho

I don't know what Bill's thoughts on your suggestion will be but to me it seems like too many opportunities for gaps. The horizontal dividers would have to be trimmed perfectly to avoid this. Bill's method erases that.

When I read Bill's post I must admit to being put off a bit by his style descriptions of leaving the dovetails exposed. So, I guess I favor a primitive style. I don't see a need to ever cover those joints but that's just me. It's not about being boastful or saying - "Hey look what I did". I look at it as letting the joinery and the wood take the spotlight.

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

#4

Re: Your suggestion

Barry Irby

I was thinking about the opportunity to screw this up. If the strip you had for the fronts of the verticals could be ripped off while the sides were a bit thicker and thus the strips were wider than the finished thickness it would make re-installing them a bit easier, whether you are doing this the way Bills suggests or what I was I was suggesting. I was thinking of cutting the horizontals by laying a straight edge up the front aligned with the inner edge of the vertical. Set a chisel along the edge and chopping the dovetail. You would be cutting about an 1/8" deep. Then "lift" the tail off. We are dealing with purposefully chosen straight grained wood. Seems like it would be fairly easy. There is surely a way to do this with a router.

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

#5

Dovetails...to see or not to see, that is the ques

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Dovetails get attention. So the decision becomes whether, for the piece being constructed, do you want dove tails there to get attention. In my case the drawer dividers and cock beading on the drawers is intended to plainly frame what I hope will be some nice crotch veneer for the drawer fronts. I don't want attention to wander from the drawer front.

In Connecticut Valley Furniture , a book that contains nothing but the best of this Period furniture, there are some fine pieces with exposed dovetails. Over time these joints have become more visible and they don't, to my eye, enhance the overall look of the piece. Exposed dovetails are less common in the Chester Co. furniture, a style I prefer.

Exposed joinery becomes a design element in much "studio furniture". There is not but 1 piece in a 100 of this style that I find attractive and this opinion probably affects my view of exposing joinery when it could be otherwise hidden.

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

#6

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I takes longer to apply the glue than it does to fit a horizontal strip and the result is a perfect fit. If by some remote chance it is not a perfect fit you are out 3 cents of walnut to make another. I always cut a few extra anyway.

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

#7

an edited addition

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For rustic/country/ primitive/*contemporary* style I would leave the dovetails exposed. I am speaking of what I think exposed dovetails would do to this otherwise simple piece, depending on the other details it featured. Exposed dovetails certainly don't take a magnificent block front featured in the Conn. Valley book in any of these directions for the carving and shaping sets and dominates the style.

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

#8

Some of the finest...

Paul in NJ

period furniture built in the USA had exposed dovetails. The Townsend and Goddard desks, block fronts, dressing tables, etc. had exposed dovetails. The Boston bombe' furniture too. It varied from region to region and maker to maker. You could almost argue that it was to cover sloppy but adequate joinery, sort of the like overcuts and such on drawer dovetail joinery.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

#9

Re: Dovetails...to see or not to see, that is the

David Yoho

Bill I get what you're saying. In the case of this dresser, with the drawer details mentioned, I don't think the eye would wander from your figured drawer fronts. At least mine wouldn't!

When I built the walnut chest-on-chest, dresser, and lingerie chest in our bedroom I left the dovetail joints exposed on the dividers. The lingerie chest has inset drawers and the other two have overlay. Funny thing is, I don't instantly notice any of the dovetails because they seem to just blend in. The drawer fronts on the lingerie chest are lacewood but on the others just plain walnut. Whenever someone sees the trio for the first time, they seldom comment about the dovetails. I never know whether they noticed them or not.

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

#10

Re: Dovetails...to see or not to see, that is the

Jesse Cloud

I seldom show dovetails.

I generally try to follow design advice that, I think, came from Michael Fortune, to limit the attention grabbing features of a piece to no more than two or three.

I think a piece works best when the details work together, like Maloof's sense of a soft line parallel to and reinforcing the curve formed by a hard edge.

Just my style, but looking back on past work, I'm happiest with my simplest pieces.

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

#11

Design elements- how many

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was smitten by a desk I saw made by a Krenov student. But there was something about it that bothered me. I showed it to my artist friend and she immediately began to point to design features and comment "what is that all about". All tolled there were 11 design features on this desk. I suppose the student had learned about all these design elements in some class and thought his final project should pull out all the stops and include as many as the desk could accommodate. I didn't know about the design element number "rule of thumb" but I stripped many from the design when I made a similar desk. It is not the "tour de force" of the original but I think it looks better.

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

#12

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks for posting these updates/tutorial Bill.

I don't understand how you can get so much done so fast...

Re: Samantha's dresser8- Installing the facing

#13

Keep in mind.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

what I am showing is A way of doing "it", not THE way. It would good for others to opine on their ways.

I'm fretting over what to use for veneer so you won't see any progress for a while. It seems that my lumber is always 1/2" too short.