Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Just Wondering . . .

Posts

Just Wondering . . .

#1

Just Wondering . . .

charlie belden

Why are drawer handles and pulls on "all wood constuction" furniture (no metal glides or guides), usually centered on the drawer face, rather than closer to the bottom of the drawer - where gravity and friction are acting resisting opening the drawer?

Is it just a matter of aesthetics over riding function?

What would a piece of everyday furniture look like if it were designed and built by a physicist who would be using the finished piece?

And thanks to Gallagher "What would a chair look like - if our knees bent the other way (think Ostritch)?".

Just wondering.

Re: Just Wondering . . .

#2

Re: Just Wondering . . .

paulsv

Interesting question. One bit of personal experience with this. I made a pair of night-stand tables for a bedroom, and made them with "hidden" drawers- the drawer front just looked like the rail on the front of the stand, and you opened it by pulling on the bottom of the drawer front, which you accessed by a cut-out in the case bottom. The drawers were pretty closely fit, and they would sometimes rack and be hard to open and close. At my wife's request, I put drawer pulls on the center of the drawer front, and they operated much better. So it might have something to do with the racking of the drawer in its opening, and a centered knob might allow a straighter pull?

Re: Just Wondering . . .

#3

Re: Just Wondering . . .

Tom in Toronto

An ostrich's knees bend the same way as ours do. If you go to the grocery store, they sell thighs and drumsticks for poultry. The part we actually see when the animal is strutting around is mostly the drumstick. In profile the thigh lies against the body. The joint between the thigh and the drumstick is the knee, and it faces forward normally. The highly visible joint we see halfway between the underline of the body, and the ground is the ankle, and it faces aft, as is does on the horse or dog What looks like the lower leg is all foot. The animals are standing around on their toes, like a supermodel on very high heels.

Any chair is likely to still look weird.

You have a point about pulls. I would imagine the main pull in that case is a desire for symmetry. I think i have used danish modern type drawers with a low pull cut into the low edge of the drawer, but I am not sure. It could be one of those things where historically the main people making drawers are men, and the main group using them are women. So there could be a real problem but we would see less of it than the person doing all the laundry and straightening up the house. You end up in the same place as when my wife vacuumed while carrying a child on the hip. So a 45 pound woman, a 20 pound vac, and a 45 pound child. That would be like me doing chores with my wife and the kid on my hip, how often do you see that? Or more realistically like the folks who figured a Great wheel was an efficient way to spin wool while walking 20 miles a day.

Or the other way of looking at it is that we had a lot less stuff even when I was a kid in the 60s. Let alone the 1760s. I wonder at times why they bothered with cabinetry at all.

Re: Just Wondering . . .

#4

Ellis Walentine

Aesthetics vs function?

Ellis Walentine

I position (and choose, for that matter) door and drawer pulls for aesthetic reasons first, and then modify my expectations if there's a functional reason not to do it that way. High, low, center -- the location of pulls doesn't matter to me so much as their visual relationship to the rest of the piece (or the room, in the case of a kitchen or bathroom).


In my kitchen, there were a few different things that played into the decision of where to put the knobs. Roughly, my rationale would have gone like this: below center on drawers, not attractive or somehow troubling visually; centered on drawers, not thrilling; above center, positive, able to line things up with the knobs on the doors as well, which I wanted to be centered on the stile/rail joint for visual and functional reasons.

With modern drawer slide hardware, or well-made conventional drawers, the issue shouldn't be a functional one.

Ellis

Re: Just Wondering . . .

#5

Well

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

There may, indeed, be a slight mechanical advantage to a handle placed closer to the plane of the glides, but I suspect the advantage is lost by the increased distance to raise the hand and arm up and over the drawer rim. The "style" was tried in some 50's and 60's minimalist furniture (and lots of kitchen drawer & door fronts) that didn't use pulls at all in favor of "finger indents" or reverse profiles on the bottoms and edge of overlay doors and drawers.

Re: Just Wondering . . .

#6

what is centered....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

With regard to Period furniture....

It is the center of the pull structure or form that is usually centered not the hinge point. For a round knob the bolt will usually be centered, or higher on a tall drawer. For a complex back plate shape with a bail the screws will often be higher than center.

As far as the physics, many drawers are located below the elbows so pulling on them will lift, however slightly, the drawer no matter the location of the pull or knob. I suppose this lifting reduces the friction some measurable amount. Lowering the knob would reduce it some tiny amount more but I doubt it would be noticed. The physics is so irrelevant that looks/balance becomes the overriding factor in the decision.

When locating a bail type pull it is held on the drawer and moved about until the "center of visual mass", to coin a term, looks centered or at least looks best. This procedure usually leads to pull screws above center.

Re: Just Wondering . . .

#7

I agree with Ellis, +

Keith Newton

The same drilling jig can be used for everything, making that go faster.

Also, on a stack of drawers, which the bottom one is usually about 12 T. Keeping it near the top edge, requires less bending distance to reach that pull.