Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

Posts

Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#1

Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

charlie belden

Two California woodworkers, Sam Maloof and Ed Espinet Carpenter, independently came up with an idea that became a characteristic of The California Furniture Style - rounding over the edges of their pieces.

The logic for rounding over edges is

Crisp sharp edges of wooden furniture WILL get dinged over time. And the dings will become quite noticeable.

Chamfering edges reduces the visual impact of "wear and tear" but, because there are still parallel straight lines, the eye will catch and focus on interruptions to those straight lines - like dings.

If you round over the edges, the corners and edges of the parts that make up a piece, they become less defined, more ambiguous. So a ding in a rounded surface is less noticeable than a ding at a sharp corner, edge or a chamfered edge. And rounded edges are kinder on fingers, toes, knuckles, shins, and elbows, than are sharp corners and edges.

Yesterday, I took a friends daughter shopping for clothes - for her. (Guys don't shop for clothes - we hunt them, knowing exactly what our prey look like, where they are to be found - and we go there, GET them - and return home as quickly as possible. The exception of course is when we are looking at tools or wood)

While waiting outside the women's clothing store, I happened to see some tables in the window of the store next door. The tables each had one drawer in the apron. The pieces had straight crips edges and square corners - EXCEPT for the top edges and corners of the top AND the corners of the drawer. The drawer opening had crisp edges and corners, but the corners of the drawer had been noticeably rounded and the edges of the drawer as were rounded as well.

The contrast in edge treatments was interesting, the opposite of what I'm accustomed to seeing. Now I've seen OVERLAY draw faces with this rounded over thing. But I've never seen a flush mount drawer with this edge treatment. It's odd, but interesting. Not sure if it would work for stacked drawers, but has interesting possibilities for a row of side by side drawers.


What's YOUr reaction to this idea?

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#2

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Greene and Greene (also in SoCal) perfected this idea over a century ago.

https://www.google.com/search?q=greene+finger+joints&client=safari&hl=en&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ei=M8vmUrztC9LNsQSQn4L4Ag&ved=0CEMQsAQ&biw=1024&bih=672#facrc=_&imgrc=aLeVLHFcRFrJnM%253A%3Bla-0a1VysZzEKM%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.finewoodworking.com%252Fassets%252Fuploads%252Fposts%252F5380%252FNIK_20080224_0625.jpg%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.finewoodworking.com%252Fitem%252F5380%252Fgamble-house-entry-table%3B930%3B1200

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#4

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

charlie belden

William:

I'm familiar with the Greene & Greene rounded over edges on through tenons, table apron exposed splines and rounded over protruding dovetails and finger joints. And I knew they worked mainly in southern California, as did Sam Maloof. Ed Espinet Carpenter was a northern California woodworker from around Bolinas. When Maloof and Espinet Carpenter were developing their rounded over edges style, I don't think either was aware of the others' work (No Internet, no Google/Yahoo and 700 to 800 miles separating them - with NO freeways at the time and 50 mph was "high speed. A car trip from Bolinas to LA would be a two day trip - each way). Maloof may have seen some G&G pieces, but Espinet Carpenter probably hadn't.

Neither Maloof nor Espinet Carpenter were much for exposed joinery of A&C furniture. Both were into rounding over the edges and corners of the exploded elements of their pieces - not the joinery. Maloof, with his classic rockers, went out of his way to BLEND the joinery so as to create a continuous flowing set of curved surfaces.

The example of a look that I posted is not like G&G, A&C or Maloof or Espinet Carpenter styles. The Hard Edge drawer enclosure and the rounded edges and corners of a flush faced drawer is quite different. Whether it works aesthetically is subject to opinion. I like the idea of juxtaposing Hard and Soft in a piece of furniture, though this math or may not be the best example of the application of that idea.

I posted the image of a SketchUp 3D model I did just to throw out an idea I found for others to consider. What others do with it is obviously up to them.

Bill:

Not my cup of tea either, but the idea is interesting

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#5

Kneale Brownson

Kind of round peg in a square hole.

Kneale Brownson

Not pretty because it's an unfamiliar look. If the drawer opening were rounded similarly, it might look better.

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#6

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

BrianMonumentCO

Particular item shown reminds me unfavourably of a world war 2 block house or even a tiger tank.

Not in a good way on the tank.

The style needs to appear more fragile than it does.

The legs needs taper.

The top is the only part I almost like.

The drawer is too small the opening.

Looks kind of dwarfed by the rest of the monolithic construction.

That is my view from saddle.

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#7

Clint Searl

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

Clint Searl

I think the rationale you attribute to Maloof and the other guy is wrong, or dubious at best. Maybe they did it just because they liked it and it set them apart; who knows. The picture of the mix-mash design included is junk design and execution.

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#8

That "Style"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

was endemic to Art Nouveau furniture and craft that started in Europe in the late 1800's. Sam didn't invent it. It ain't and never was "California Style", but craft literature of the day was widely circulated in magazines and catalogs, so even remote areas of the Wild West would have been exposed to the design principals employed.

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#9

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The pictured example is somebody's attempt at "lemonade." :D

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#10

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

charlie belden

To clarify, the illustration I provided was just to show a rounded corners and edges flush mount drawer in a straight edged, square corners drawer opening. It was not intended to be an example of good furniture design. It was done in SketchUp in about 45 minutes, 30 minutes of which was figuring out how to do the drawer's rounded corners and edges - in 3D. The other 15 minutes was for doing the table top and legs and getting the shadows set to show that the object is in 3D.

SO - ignore the table top and its edge profile and the rectangular legs and their proportions relative to the rest - and just look at the drawer in the context of its drawer opening.

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#11

Re: Another Round Peg in Square Hole Example

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

This one is from circa 1810. Of course, it is done with veneer, and the actual drawer and door front shapes conform as closely as practical to the shape of the opening.

If we are concerned with structure, rounding thetops and bottoms of the drawers will cause additional, undesirable wear on the insides of the runners and kickers (drawer guides). It is better to spread the wear over a pair of flat parallel surfaces.

Of course, in the case of the Greene & Greene DRAWER I showed earlier, the wear occurs on the very hard ebony runners screwed to the top of the drawer.

A feature of the Sam Maloof chairs that I really appreciate is the interplay between the rounded corners and other corners that are very sharply defined. If you've ever sat in a Maloof chair, you will appreciate that contrast even more, as you realize that the curves and edges are designed to fit your body very comfortably. You do not tactilely encounter the edges, but they are definitely visible and therefore enhance the curves of the design.

No internet, no freeways, etc., didn't stop furniture makers in the Colonies, even on the edge of the frontier, from reproducing designs from the latest edition of Thomas Chippendale's Director all the way back in the 18th century.


img

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#12

Fat drawer sides?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would involve making the drawer sides thicker. This round peg in a square hole is not an attractive option from inside or outside the drawer. But, I find most Studio Furniture art projects unattractive so I am no measure of whether it will sell in CA. When it comes to modern furniture. novelty often trumps attractive. Apparently novelty sells.

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#13

reproduction or rediscovery?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think some elements of furniture design as so natural that they would be discovered whether the latest edition of Thomas Chippendale's Directory was available to them or not. The problem for the 21th century furniture designer is that most of what is worth discovering has been. It will take the availability of new materials or new construction methods (for example CNC) to open up a new frontier.

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#14

Novelty Do Sell

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Evidence the craze for log-section (stump) end tables last year in urban markets. It was THE post modern THING to have in the yuppie urbanite living room, and 18x18 bolts were going for several hundred a piece in New York, checks and all. After Sandy took down a 120' forest oak in front of my house, I figured I had a good $20Gs worth of "furniture" just waiting to be cut and schlepped into the City.

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#15

Re: Another Round Peg in Square Hole Example

Barry Irby

I had the pleasure of meeting Sam Maloof at Highland hardware. Traveled there to attend his seminar. This was back before he died. I am glad I did.

He comment of the edged that you mentioned on his chairs. He described them as "hard edges" and "soft edges" and they were very intentional.

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#16

PPS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Art Nouveau, of course, morphed into Art Deco which, in turn, morphed into Danish Modern that, unfortunately, seems to have devolved into . . IKEA. :D

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#17

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

BrianMonumentCO

Within the context of the drawer opening.

I think that a round drawer in a square opening is defective.

It looks like a drawer was taken from another piece of furniture and slapped into this square drawer opening table.

In a flush drawer face situation, if the opening is square I expect to see no gaps ie a square drawer. If the opening is rounded I expect to see no gaps hence a rounded drawer.

Bottom line the gaps in the corners are unsightly.

My 2 cents worth.

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#18

Re: That "Style" *LINK*

charlie belden

Mark:

I'm an Art Nouveau Nut and I made the pilgrimage to Prague to visit the Mucha museum and be surrounded by Art Nouveau - on the currency, architecture, furniture, silverware, door pulls - everywhere. My other Art Nouveau hero is Rene Lalique, initially for his jewelry, but he did AN designs for just about everything - before he got into glass.

Though I haven't confirmed it, I suspect that French Curves were developed during the AN period. With AN furniture, there are few straight lines and fewer hard edges, at least visible from the outside, with sweeping, sinuous and sensuous lines flowing around and into each other. The "California Style" had to do more with practicality than for artistic reasons - round over what in time would be rounded over through use.

Sam Maloof mentions the California Style in a YouTube video of an interview with him during a tour of his home. I believe in another YouTube video of an interview with Ed Espenet Carpenter (apologies for misspelling "Espenet" earlier) he talks about the rounded edges and corners of his piece and gives the same reason for initially rounding them as wear and tear would eventually produce.

If you want to see some work by a current master of AN furniture, check out Roger Heitzman's site (see link below). He's up in Scotts Valley, in the Santa Cruz Mountains, half way between Silly Cone Valley and Santa Cruz. He made a router based almost Rube Goldberg-esque 3D carving machine to enable him to carve one of his pieces. It was so complicated to set up and use, that several years later he'd forgotten how it worked and had to relearn how to use it (sound familiar to anyone?).




Roger Heitsman's site - incredible!

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#19

Re: Another Round Peg in Square Hole Example

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I met him as well, at a presentation he gave at the Smithsonian's Renwick Gallery. He was incredibly friendly, unassuming and generous, a real gentleman. That was when I first sat in one of his chairs. The second opportunity was at RISD, where they have two of his love seats that are not behind ropes. I haven't found an opportunity to try one of his rockers yet.

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#20

Re: Oops, Perhaps Small Misunderstanding

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I didn't mean to imply that the piece in the photo was a Chippendale design. It is not. The Gentleman's and Cabinet Maker's Director did not include that design, at least not with that type of decoration. The juxtaposition was an artifact of the reply tool, which puts the Optional Image URL at the bottom of the post.

On one hand, infinite variations on style, design, forms and details are possible. That's what makes it art. OTOH, it's all made from Carbon, Hydrogen, Oxygen, Nitrogen, Sulfur, etc., and increased entropy. I guess that makes it all just organic chemistry and thermodynamics.

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#21

A Name

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Charlie,

I believe his first name was "Arthur" not "Ed" ;)

Takes centuries to wear off the edges on hardwood furniture and the dents and dings show up just as much. What I'm hearing is good "marketing" which is fine but not necessarily the whole truth.

Cowabunga, Dude! :D

ppps: Make no mistake, I really like Sam's work; both his furniture and his merchandising ;)

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#22

Re: Another Round Peg in Square Hole Example

Barry Irby

I sat in one of his chairs for an hour or two. Very comfortable. The curves and edges were very tactile and invited your hands to explore. He did very little wood working during his Seminar, but he did cut out one of the arms for a chair. they had one he had done the last tiem he was there and he made the opposite one. He just looked at the older one and sawed out a new one on the band saw. He said not to do what he did and I don't think I would try, but he held it up off the table except at one point and turned it every which way but loose. When he was finished it was remarkable "sculpted" and there was very little work left to be done.

He told us that in the beginning when his chairs had become famous his clients were generally older and Sam had a two year backlog. His clients would say, Sam, hurry up and make my chair before I die. Late in his career they would say, Sam, hurry up and make my chair before YOU die.

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#23

Clint Searl

I represent that remark

Clint Searl

I've done a half-dozen hollow log side tables. This is from a couple months ago. Cleaned up, topped with a piece of inset glass, and patinated. The bar appearing across the glass is a reflection.

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#24

Well Then

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

they'll match the drapes.

But that's way too Park Avenue, Clint.

We're takin' fresh cut from the Dark Forest, All Natural and Organic, with nothing added, and the checks, cracks, moss, and lichens intact. Don't need no glass top either.

:D :D

Re: Odd Take on "California Style Furniture"

#25

Maloof was certainly also a master of marketing

charlie belden

It is, as you pointed out, Arthur not Ed - Espenet Carpenter

And yes, Sam Maloof was a master at marketing his work.

It's interesting that James Krenov, though every bit as good a craftsman as Maloof, was never a financial success with his furniture. It may be the differences in personality - Maloof was an outgoing, friendly, gregarious guy and a low key extrovert. Krenov, on the other hand, was somewhat of a curmudgeon, and in an earlier time, might have become a hermit