Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Wood shop plans/lighting

Posts

Wood shop plans/lighting

#1

Wood shop plans/lighting

Lee Ohmart

I'm building a 24 x 32 addition on a concrete slab attached to the back of my garage with 10' walls to house a wood shop. The 32 ft SE facing wall will have an Anderson Frenchwood double door and three 3'x6' windows, the 24 ft SW wall will have two 3'x6' windows side by side topped with a half round and the NW wall will have several 2'x3' fixed windows set up high. The walls and roof will be made with structural SIP panels with the roof held up by three 24 ft. 8"x8" hemlock trusses. My plan for general lighting is to run two 8" fluorescent fixtures between each the spaces produced by the truss arrangement parallel to the trusses for a total of 8 fixtures. The fixtures will be two-bulb Columbia CS Slimline with reflectors running T-8 Sylvania Octron 800 XP Ecologic bulbs (CRI-85 CT-5000K and 5795 mean Lumens. For task lighting I'm using Cooper Metalux 4 ft. fixtures with reflectors over my planer, jointer, mortise and sharpening area. The T-8 bulb choices in the Sylvania line are Octron 800 XPS Ecologic 3 (CT-81 CRI-6500K 2850 mean Lumens), Octron XP ECO (CT88 CRI 8000K 2518 mean Lumens) or the Octron XP Ecologic (CT-85 CRI-6500K mean Lumen 2708). The 6500K bulbs seem like a good choice but that 8000K bulb is tempting for my older (I'm 59) eyes. Anybody have any experience with a high output bulb like this?

Re: Wood shop plans/lighting

#2

JL

Re: Wood shop plans/lighting

JL

8000 K is the color temperature?

I have old, tired eyes myself - but IMO - that is probably too high of a color temperature. I really don't like anything more than the mid 5000 K range for my lighting. My thoughts are that 5500 K is about the color temperature of daylight at noon.

Re: Wood shop plans/lighting

#3

Re: Wood shop plans/lighting

Lee Ohmart

Yes, 8000K is what is listed in the specs. They call it a Skylight bulb. My thought it would be like working in sunlight and I'd have to use sunglasses and wear sunblock but I'd love to see what it looks like.

Re: Wood shop plans/lighting

#4

color temperature and seeing detail

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You may find the Article I wrote for the Articles section useful.

As important as your light fixtures is the reflectivity of the shop walls, ceiling and floor. They all need to be light colored to reflect light back to the work area. It will gain you 50 ft candles in a task area.

My brother in law is a lighting engineer. He says that color temperature has no proven effect on ability to see detail. Lumens is the correct metric for this consideration. However, color temperature can have a psychological effect. Personally I like the daylight color in my windowless shop.

Any large lighting store will have a computer program to help you plan lighting.

I think you are way overlit. Task lighting at the planer and jointer? There is nothing going on here that would demand over 50 ft candle. For true task lighting, for example splitting a scribe line with a dovetail saw, may require up to 200 ft candles (outside shady day is 500) on the task, 50 ft candles background and no shadows. My experience has shown that a lot of diddling is required to get this kind of task lighting in a windowless shop.

Whatever you do you will be redoing part of it as needs develop, you gain experience and needs change. Make the wiring flexible.

If you need task lighting power the T5HO lamps should be considered.

Re: Wood shop plans/lighting

#5

Re: Wood shop plans/lighting

mdclor

I would suggest placing the light strips closer to the side walls. Typically, the tools are against a wall and having the lights where you suggest will have you working in your shadow much of the time. You might consider having the fixtures 3-5 feet from the walls. That might reduce your need for task lighting to some extent. FWIW

Re: Wood shop plans/lighting

#6

You may not like the 6500K look

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

A couple years ago, I helped my oldest son set up the electrical and lighting in his garage shop. He went with the daylight T8 tubes (6500K) at the suggestion of a friend. That turned out to be the most unappealing, harshest light I've ever seen. Made everything look very odd. He pulled all the tubes and exchanged them for normal cool white (4100K) tubes. Just sayin....

Re: Wood shop plans/lighting

#7

Re: Wood shop plans/lighting

Tony - Memphis

Well, color is subjective and even the temperature designation varies from mfr. to mfr. I have been replacing my old T12's with new T8's. I tried the GE bulbs at Lowes that are labeled as noon day sun at 5000k. I like them. They put out plenty of light and the color is acceptable. I have a more "warm" set of bulbs in a fixture right over my bench. It is pretty amazing how much color difference there is. Sounds like some nice new diggs! Enjoy the new shop! I've been thrilled with the new ballasts/bulbs in my shop. I didn't realize how dark it was in there!

Tony

Re: Wood shop plans/lighting

#8

Re: I do like the 6500K

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have changed most of my bulbs to these, I am sure Bill is correct, but I certainly seem to have less trouble seeing details in the "bluer" light spectrum. I am 72 and have really overdone my lighting so I can see easily everywhere in my shop. What I did was install 4 switches at the entrance door which control 3 banks of duplex outlets on the ceiling and 1 that controls 6 porcelain fixtures (this is a 3 way that has the other switch beside the garage door). I have (as I remember, too cold to go out to look even though the shop is warm), 24 four foot t-8 fixtures and 6 Halogen 100 watt bulbs in the porcelain fixtures. Each switched line is on a separate breaker. I can if I wish save some power by utilizing only the fixtures I need - but seldom do leave any off, power is cheap enough in this area that it doesn't seem to have much effect on my bill. I also have a couple of duplex outlets near the wall that are currently not utilized so can add more if I wish. My son, who is in his forties says it seems like daylight in the shop to him, but I don't feel I have too much light for me! Remember one thing - cost and effort to install extra outlets and lighting is very cheap and easy while building, it is several times harder and more expensive to add when the shop is finished.