I'm helping my son build a table for his equipment/computers. I am looking for suggestion on a fairly durable, non-spray type, finishing product. Any suggestions? I have some General Finishes water based poly I've used before, but looking for other suggestions.
If it's only durability that matters, and if spraying is out, a water-borne polyurethane is probably a good choice. High-end floor finishers use catalyzed water-borne polyurethane all the time, and that has to stand up to foot traffic. I don't have comparative abrasion-resistance data for the various products out there, but I'd say any of them would be acceptable if not superior for this application. Oil-based polyurethanes are another option.
I agree with what Ellis said. Either water-borne polyurethane or oil-based would be fine. It's a matter of what you are comfortable with. Some water-borne polyurethanes can look cold. If that's a problem you're trying to avoid, then use the oil-based.
Moving desktop computers around on a table top is going to abrade of scratch the surface. I made a computer work bench for a semi-pro computer technician and we used Formica. It's held up well.
I don't think any brush on or spray on finish will prove durable for someone who works on computers. At the very least, a mat covering would provide protection.
The most overlooked information on water based poly is the cure time. Check with General since we don't know exactly what material you are using, but some full cure times to full hardness may be weeks after you apply it. I can't find anything on their website about curing time. Remember, they also have professional finishes if you are not using them.
A solvent based urethane will be durable. It will be scuff resistant and moisture resistant enough that it can be washed as needed. When faced with this problem I visit the stores and see if I can dent with a finger nail the test piece they usually have on display. The better finishes will not dent much or any.
For better brushing, thin it 1 part solvent to about 3 parts (depending on temperature) varnish. Thin enough that it flows and levels quickly. Test on a test board. Coat, let cure, sand smooth, coat again. then rub out with 4/0 steel wool and wax.
>>>> Behlen's Rock Hard - if he isn't going to be moving it around.
Have you tried the new Behlen's Rockhard? In the past year they have changed their formulation to a poly resin product. It's no longer a non-poly finish.
Thanks for all the replies. I have two different General Finishes water based poly products: High Performance that I've used on cabinets before, and Enduro Var. I think for this table, I'll go with the Enduro Var as its a bit more durable, according to their web site.