Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Half round table apron. Will this work?

Posts

Half round table apron. Will this work?

#1

Half round table apron.   Will this work?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hi.

I am making a small half round table. Roughly 10" radius.

I've started to make a form to bend 1/8" x 3" Cherry strips around. I'm going to glue up strips to come out with a roughly 3/4" x 3" apron. I haven't ripped out the strips yet. I also need to make the outer portion of the form so I can sandwich the apron between the two for the glue up.

Am I on the right track? Will this work?

Thanks


Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#2

Re: Half round table apron.   Will this work?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

don't forget that the radius of the caul will be larger than the form radius because of the strips in between.

I have never bent anything this tight. Try a 1/8" test strip and if there is a lot or resistance reduce the thickness a bit to add one or two additional strips to the assembly.

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#3

Re: Half round table apron.   Will this work?

Dustmaker Mike

I have never done it but if I where to try I would steam the strips first or at least get them good and wet before I tried to bend them this tight.

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#4

Re: Half round table apron.   Will this work?

Dick Coers

Make sure the cherry you resaw doesn't have grain running out the side of the board. 1/8" might just be too thick if you didn't plan in any spring back.

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#5

Re: Half round table apron.   Will this work?

Barry Irby

I have never used an inner and outer form. It may be better than what I was doing. I used an inner form and wrapped the wood around it. I used shackles to pull the layers up tight. The shackles were pieces of 2x2 with a bolt (or all thread) trough the top and bottom and used an impact driver of drill to pull them up tight with a deep well socket. I also let the pieces run long on both ends. In fact, you should make the form an inch or two too long on both sides and then still run the pieces long. Then cut the glued up piece back to size, using only the "sweet" part.

Using and inner and out form Might be better. When I have seen it done they lined both sides with Cork about an 1/8" thick and then cover them with plastic film or packing tape of at least wax them well to keep the glue form sticking to them. Cut notches in the backs of the cauls to give the clamps a grip.

Not sure you can bend 1/8" thick laminations that tight. Give it a try. I think a bit thinner might help. You could steam them or soak them in hot water. Also use very straight grained pieces to avoid run out and the grain splitting.

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#6

Re: Half round table apron.   Will this work?

don stephan

Given possibly varying thickness of strip and glue layers, not sure outer form is a good idea. You could wrap the glued assembly with clear plastic, add 3 or 4 unglued strips against the outside surface of the assembly, and then clamp all to the inner form. Generally I use plastic resin glue for laminations, due to its long open time. But keep temp above 70 deg F or the glue may not cure. A dry run will show if you need steps on inside form to hold clamps.

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#7

Re: Half round table apron.   Will this work?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I would do it the traditional way. Brick up the apron from a secondary wood, typically tulip poplar. Saw it to the shape and thickness you want, inside and out. Saw your cherry veneer to about 1/8" thick (only one layer) and plane it smooth, and thin it in the process to closer to 1/16" thick. Also smooth the outside surface of the apron. With a toothing plane, scrape the inside of the veneer and the outside of the apron. Apply hot hide glue with a brush to both surfaces of the veneer and the outer surface of the apron. Hammer the veneer in place (with a veneer hammer, which is really a squeegee).

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#8

Re: Half round table apron.   Will this work?

Jesse Cloud

Yes, it will work.

Good advice above! I am wary, too, about inner and outer forms. Hard to know exactly what radius you are going for.

Best to do the bend with the inside of the "U" shaped form shaping the show face of the apron. The exact radius of the inside of the apron

doesn't really matter.

There will be a somewhat unpredictable amount of springback on the workpiece, so don't do any joinery until you have the actual piece. Lay it on a piece of cardboard or mdf, trace the shape of the bent piece and make a life size drawing of the apron and legs assembly to discover joinery angles.

If you have a vacuum pump, thats the easiest way to "clamp" the glue up. Otherwise, make extra laminates from cheap wood to use as cauls, the hardwood cauls going vertically and lots of clamps!

One last thing, you can save a lot of time and effort buying lams directly from a veneer shop. I use Certainlywood. They have extra thick veneer for that purpose. Buy some nice quarter sawn cherry for the show face and the back and something cheaper for the core.

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#9

Re: Half round table apron.   Will this work?

David Yoho

Joe, lots of good responses here. For me, I would skip using the outside form and just use my short Bessey parallel clamps to clamp the lamination to the form. I slide a piece of wax paper in between the form and lamination to keep the glue from sticking it all together. This is a situation where I use liquid hide glue rather than yellow glue. It dries harder so it helps keep the lamination from springing back much, if any, after removing it from the form. Make sure your strips are longer than what you need so the lamination can be trimmed to the final length.

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#10

Re: Half round table apron.   Will this work?

Tom in Toronto

I don't see that bending that tight a radius without steam, and a backing strip. Plus it will spring back and leave you with a flatter shape. I make more of a C shaped form where the rate of change tightens around the ends of the form, so the with springback it remains fairly semi circular. I have done this kind of thing making fenders for bikes. Initially I used the rim of a wheel for the form, but it was way too flat at the ends.

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#11

Rick L

Re: Band clamp...

Rick L

I would not build an outer form. A band or strap clamp would be a better way and a lot simpler. I have done many that way.

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#12

now there is a learning curve to climb

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you need a table in the next year suggest proceeding as you planned with bent laminations.

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#13

what glue?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What glue is going to stick (and cure) to wet wood in a form?

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#14

Re: what glue?

David Yoho

How about polyurethane glue, which I would never use, but you asked!

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#15

Re: what glue?

Barry Irby

This Post has elicited an amazing amount of information. Sort of overwhelming in that it has mixed together at least three different approaches.

If you want to glue wet laminations you could use urethane glue (Gorilla Glue being the most heavily advertised). It will work, but it foams and tends to blow the layers apart without heavy and very thorough clamping. I don't like the glue, but I have used it successfully. Sort of nasty to work with and your hands end up looking like Gorilla hands, hence the name. Wear gloves.

A second choice would be to clamp the wet laminations into the form without glue and let them dry. Perhaps a day or two. You can dry them more thoroughly after taking them out of the form. Remove them and separate them and put a clamp or something across the ends to keep them from straightening. Then you can glue them with whatever glue you like.

Springback has been mentioned several items. Almost no matter what you do there will be some springback. Thinner and more laminations and more rigid glue will reduce it and may nearly eliminate it. OTOH, unless you are building an exact copy of something or something that requires an exact curve, it may not mater much. Follow the suggestion we made about making the form in the shape of a C and letting the lamination run long so you can cut off the part at the ends that does not curve and go with what you get.

I tried using a band clamp. Thought it was genius idea. Was not a complete answer for me. Since the wood was not "perfect" and had varying resistance to bending along its length and in various plies, I got ripples and bubbles where there was space between the layers. If you use this method I would suggest a band top and bottom and them have all the clamps you own handy to chase the blisters and bubbles out the ends. Be careful, when I tried this the layers were slippery with glue and as I tightened the bands they escaped rather violently and it could have been painful. Perhaps you should start by clamping the center of the stack to the form with a clamp.

I have a vacuum press and I doubt it would do this. Not a lot of experience, but I would have to give it a try.

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#16

Re: Half round table apron.   Will this work?

Jesse Cloud

One more thing..... ok, maybe two. or three...

Instead of plywood, try mdf for your forms. No voids and much easier to true and sand. Plenty strong.

BTW, if you look at traditional "half round" tables, they are seldom truly half of a circle, usually a flatter, gentler curve.

For what its worth, I just use Titebond 3 glue. Never had a problem. Yeah there will be some springback, but just see what you get and design your joinery from there.

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#17

It will work, if...

John in NM

1. Your cauls are sized for the radius of the inner form + total lamination thickness.

2. Your cauls are sections rather than a full semi-circle.

3. You use thinner wood. Last time I did much of this I bought 1/16" cherry veneer from Certainly Wood, it will bend that tight, 1/8" probably won't. I did the inside lams with poplar and only the visible faces with cherry (said company carries both in that thickness).

4. You have enough F-style clamps. The jobs I did were curved top door frames for a paying client, so I ended up with 10 new Wetzlers (that should tell you how long ago this was :D - 12 years). One clamp per caul was all I used, but if the cauls are wide or the clamps light, you may need more per caul.

I used Weldwood plastic resin glue, applied to both faces with a foam roller of appropriate width - roller is just the ticket for speed and even application. Zero springback on a 36" diameter semi-circle. Jesse gets great results from Tightbond as well, so I would use whatever is easiest to get.

I remember Ellis had some pictures of crazy curved glue ups, perhaps he'll post them again (those will give us all another bout of clamp envy :D )

All that said, I also really like the block lay up method that William mentions above. I've had better luck cutting tenons on pieces made that way. Harder to get a tenon sized just so if it's laminated, one cheek cut always seem to fall on a glue line :D Next time I make a laminated part that will need a tenon, I may size the mortise to it rather than it to the mortise. Or just block it up :D

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#18

Re: Half round table apron.   Will this work?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Wow! Thanks everybody for so much information and advice.

I like the idea of getting veneer already cut instead of resawing.

I'm going to rethink some of what I was going to do based on some of your suggestions.

Thanks again.

Joe

Re: Half round table apron. Will this work?

#19

Rick L

Re: Pre bend tip...

Rick L

http://buildyourguitar.com/resources/tips/bending.htm

The heated pipe technique will minimize spring back as well. Two Merle band clamps are all you need.

http://www.mlcswoodworking.com/shopsite_sc/store/html/smarthtml/pages/merle_clamp.html