Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Did I screw this up?

Posts

Did I screw this up?

#1

Did I screw this up?

tom

Hi. I used to be a very regular poster here more than 10 years ago but a move and other life developments (i.e. having kids) have slowed me down. However, I have jumped back in and I could now really use some advice on a project.

I am building a bass guitar with my son from a kit (from Saga Instruments). When we were pattern routing the headstock (the thing at the end of the neck that holds the tuning pegs), after making a pattern out of 1/4" MDF and attaching it to the stock. The bit tore off a bunch of material that was to the right of the bit. The drawing shows the part that tore off. (please see the url for the drawing at the bottom of this post). The other photo shows the part that tore off. Prior to routing we roughed out the shape to about 1/4" on the scroll saw. We were routing from left to right. Using a 3/4" pattern routing bit. Makita router running at speed of about 3 (out of 6). We did a couple of practice runs on an old piece of pine that I salvaged from a pallet. So I figured that if it worked on this board, it would work on the actual headstock, which is one solid piece (not glued up as far as I can tell). I think it is beech or basswood or maybe some asian wood. About 5/8" thick.

Saga is sending a replacement neck (very responsive customer service, by the way).

I have not had much experience with pattern routing. Can you please tell me if I made a mistake or if we were just unlucky.

Thanks

Drawing: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1h6u0kbt7c6WkJDdW9WamZjNms/edit?usp=sharing

Photo:https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1h6u0kbt7c6Q2JMZFFLbkhBMkE/edit?usp=sharing

Re: Did I screw this up?

#2

yes

Mark Hennebury

It appears that you hit the toughest part going in the wrong direction;

There are several ways to approach this situation:

Sharper blade, Higher rpm, slower feed, more consistent feed, lighter cut, helical cutter, climb cutting or cutting from the other direction.

I would suggest that you should have come from the other direction for that part of the grain.

You could have put the template on the other side and the router would cut into the wood rather than lifting the wood.

Sometimes it is better to have a template that can be fixed on either side of the wood or a double template so that you can change sides and router direction to get the cleanest cut. The cleanest cut is had when the cutting edge is pushing the wood fibres into the wood not lifting them out. so on a piece like this where the grain changes as you progress around the template curves you would be best to work from both sides.

Many of furniture making shops used double shapers, with two spindles going in opposite directions to be able to switch cutting as they worked around the template, so that they would always have the cutter going in the best direction for the particular part of the grain.

You can minimize the problem when using one template on one side, by setting the template on the side of your wood to give the best direction of cut for the worst piece of grain.

Re: Did I screw this up?

#3

Re: Did I screw this up?

Dick Coers

I'd say your bit was dull, and you were taking off too much material in one pass. Bandsaw within 1/16" of the line if possible. Nothing more than 1/8". You can make passes with the bearing not on the pattern to try and sneak up on it. Companies are now making flush trim bits with bearings on the top and bottom. This lets you run the bits so it cuts down the grain. You run with the router on the pattern for one side, then on the wood for the opposite cut.

Re: Did I screw this up?

#4

Ellis Walentine

Couple other options

Ellis Walentine

A smaller diameter pattern bit, with more flutes, would be much less aggressive than a 3/4" bit. Failing that, I agree that you might want to rout from the other side on those "uphill" grain areas, and try to keep your scrollsaw cuts as close to the final shape as possible. (1/4" is huge.)

It is almost impossible to control the router to take a shallower bite because the cutting edges want to pull the bit quickly and violently into the uphill grain. With a smaller diameter bit, you could probably get away with climb cutting, or running the router in the "wrong" direction. This is a white-knuckle operation though and difficult to control or predict, especially freehand. I'd definitely practice on some similar hardwood to get the feel of it.

Ellis

Re: Did I screw this up?

#5

think of the router as a carving machine

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The router is a handy way of removing wood. With good lighting (which may involve making a transparent base for the machine if the stock base is opaque and obscures the bit), good support for the base, and a comfortable grip, the router can be used free-hand to nibble away at wood to be removed. An example will be given later in when I describe drawer building in the dress er building project.

If I was faced with your routing task I would spin up the router to max rpm and nibble away at the waster in small areas. While in general it is best to go counter clockwise with a pattern bit, it is often essential to not take a heavy cut where the bit would be lifting a vulnerable section of grain. Using the router as a "carving tool" these vulnerable grain areas can be nibbled at in any direction, as dictated by the grain. When the nibbling is complete, then, the router bit bearing can be run against the pattern for a final clean up pass around the pattern. The bottom line of it, as a first pass I rarely would run the bit all around the pattern with the bearing rubbing . Nibble first.

Re: Did I screw this up?

#6

Try this bit *LINK*

Keith Newton

And cut closer to the line to begin with.

The burning indicates a dull bit, and or moving too slow. There was no reason to slow your rpm on a 3/4" bit.

I was thinking of suggesting you climb cut, but I don't think you are ready for that.

If your router will accept 1/2" bits, always buy those over 1/4" because they are at least 4 times stiffer, and less prone to flexing under load, which causes chatter.


http://www.rockler.com/freud-top-and-bottom-bearing-flush-trim-router-bits?utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_term=&utm_content=pla&utm_campaign=PL&gclid=CPr1kcfCj7wCFVQV7AodDx0A9g

Re: Did I screw this up?

#7

Another option

Merle

I personally don't like to use a router in applications like this; it is too hard for me to control and feel comfortable that I can guarantee a successful outcome. Therefore, I have resorted to using a flat spokeshave. It can be used with either a pushing or pulling motion. I would use a rasp to get into tight corners. It might be a good excuse to buy a new tool. :)

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=49142&cat=1,50230

Re: Did I screw this up?

#8

Re: Did I screw this up?

tom

Thanks for the GREAT information. This is (still) and awesome forum. My plan now, based on your posts is

1. Use a top & bottom flush trim bit

2. When routing the vulnerable section that tore out before, flip the work piece so that the router is running in the opposite direction of travel from before (opposite of the direction of travel arrow in the drawing (URL below))

3. Before I do any of this, make sure that there is not more than 1/8 to 1/16" of material to be routed away (sneak up on the pattern using the scroll saw, router, or even a sander).

4. Run the router at a high speed.

5. Use a sharp/new bit.

Does this sound about right. (Or do you recommend that we should just forget about the router and shape with a scroll saw and sanders.)

Thanks

Drawing: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1h6u0kbt7c6WkJDdW9WamZjNms/edit?usp=sharing

Re: Did I screw this up?

#9

That sounds good

Keith Newton

If you get the bit i recommended, make your first cut from the bottom of the round, back toward where it broke off before, with the router base on the back side. Then you can get all of the top, around to the far right side. By doing it first, you don't have to worry about snagging on that short-grain spot when you come down that slope again.

Then flip it and set the router for the bearing over to ride down the grain on the part you had already done in your picture last, and the little quarter circle on the lower half of the end in your drawing. This should hove your blade cutting down the slope of the grain all the way around.

I would like to know which router you were using, and was your bit one with a 1/4" shank?

Re: Did I screw this up?

#10

Re: That sounds good

tom

Keith

Thanks for the info. I was using a Makita router (Do you need to know the model? It was a $200 dollar-ish when I got it 10-12 yrs ago). The bit was 1/2 shank.

To make sure I understand: I will put the pattern on the back. Rout from the "circle" which is to the right of the drawing first. Then I will flip the pattern onto the front and rout the longer straight line that is currently at the bottom of the drawing. (The other curve an straight line are come factory cut).

Tom

Re: Did I screw this up?

#11

Re: That sounds good

Keith Newton

Well, the power was what I was wondering about. While some people worry about a router overpowering them, I think an underpowered router may be more dangerous than more. And of course, if the motor doesn't have enough HP to take a large enough chip, leads to the burning like shown in your photo.

This of course can be from timidity on your part though, even with a sharp bit. The point I'm wanting to make, is that if you have plenty of power, but can't hear any reduction of rpm's while making the cut, you are probably going too slow. But, then your bit may have just been bad dull.

Re: Did I screw this up?

#12

Ellis Walentine

If you have both kinds of bit...

Ellis Walentine

... the pattern and the flush trim, you don't need to flip the pattern to the front, which could introduce some errors of alignment anyhow.

Ellis

Re: Did I screw this up?

#13

worrisome

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

this pattern flipping is not necessary. My fear would be not getting it realigned precisely and the top and bottom cuts not line up. Of course the area of transition could be rasped or spoke shaved into submission if it was off a bit. But, I would avoid the possibility and just nibble away at the waste free hand in small areas until I got to where the bearing engaged with the pattern. I carve waste away routinely with the router uneventfully. I would use a smaller bit, probably 1/2" with 1/2" shank to avoid vibration.

Re: Did I screw this up?

#14

Another Option....

Barry Irby

You could cut this piece as close as you can to size with a jig saw or bandsaw then Sand it to the exact size with a drum sander. You could double stick tape the pattern onto it or use hot melt glue and then any drum sander you might have. And You can buy drums that have a bearing on them similar to the bearing on pattern bits. Actually, since the shape is not a precise requirement, you could draw the pattern on it, band saw it and sand it to the line.

This might be a tad slow, but fairly safe in the sense of not splintering the work piece, but you might ruin the piece by sanding it to death. Since its a one off speed is not of the essence.

Re: Did I screw this up?

#15

Re: Robo Sanders.

Tom in Toronto

"1. Use a top & bottom flush trim bit"

YOU can also use a robo sander which is basically one or another form of a bearing guided sanding drum. With a coarse sleeve it would rip through this without any worries about burning, etc... Often the drums are 2" so that would probably be a little thick, but I have a 1" one.

"2. When routing the vulnerable section that tore out before, flip the work piece so that the router is running in the opposite direction of travel from before (opposite of the direction of travel arrow in the drawing (URL below))"

That is basically good advice, though you do need to read all the grain and be sure you are cutting with it not only in that one place.

"3. Before I do any of this, make sure that there is not more than 1/8 to 1/16" of material to be routed away (sneak up on the pattern using the scroll saw, router, or even a sander)."

Right, though sometimes too little causes problems also, you want a health but small amount. And fees i also and issue, how fast.

"4. Run the router at a high speed."

I don't know about that, you want to run it at the right speed, for the bit diameter. You want a decent surface speed. I have a bandsaw book that is over an inch thick with speeds for everything, including cutting donuts. Most of us don't refer to a book. If you have some maple you could experiment with some speeds, that create shavings, not dust, cut with control, and don't burn.

"5. Use a sharp/new bit."

I used to buy the idea that you can't have razor sharp router bits, until I got one with my TR12 router, it shaved hair.

Re: Did I screw this up?

#16

Re: Did I screw this up?

Paul Woolson

I do this for a living (guitars) and my $.02 says that you are over thinking this. There is no need to pattern cut a headstock unless you have something totally custom that you need to be repeated exactly right every time. I'd use your template to draw the pattern on the headstock then hit it with your scroll saw followed by rasps, files, sandpaper on sticks, etc.

You probably could have had it done in the time it took you to post the original question.

I would also recommend gluing back the chipped out piece and use that as a practice neck. Continue with everything and do it all twice (once on each neck). The bad news is that the hard part is yet to come with all the setup, etc. and you'll want some practice doing it all.

Good luck!

Re: Did I screw this up?

#17

Re: Did I screw this up?

Barry Irby

You said to glue the piece back on and use it as a practice piece. This thought occurred to me, but I failed to suggest it. It dawned on me that it might go back on nearly perfectly, but no body wants a guitar with a glue line in it, even though in this location it would have no effect other than appearance.

My son thinks he is a wood worker, because he grew up in a house that has a workshop. I suppose it is genetic. He assumes he got the wood worker gene. He started building a guitar. Went through my stash of wood and picked the finest pieces he could find. Sawed them up. Used a heat pipe to bend them. Found some mahogany and built a neck out of it. Insisted I had to return the table saw for him. (not) Then quit. Was unwilling to make a practice piece. Wanted to hunt down world class materials and do a once off. With me paying for the materials. I think a practice run is a good idea.

Re: Did I screw this up?

#18

Re: Did I screw this up?

Tom in Toronto

I didn't want to bring up the whole glue it back together thing, since they had already dispatched a replacement for it, which obviously drives up everyone else's costs.

I probably would have fixed it, then I would have found a way to cover the fracture line, like just using veneer caps that are commonly found on guitars, particularly the acoustic ones I make.

I would also not pattern rout it, I would just cut it out and clean it up. I make more complicated heads than that, and all being one offs I do them without tooling, unless I just want to try the tooling. But then I have no idea what your tools or methods of work are since you are asking this kind of question.