Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

A response from Dr. Spalt....on Fungi

Posts

A response from Dr. Spalt....on Fungi

#1

A response from Dr. Spalt....on Fungi

Barry Irby

I wrote to Dr. Sara Robinson (Dr. Spalt) mentioned in a post recently by Ralph Lindberg on the Turning board asking her about the effects of spalting wood and the fungi one wood workers and the effect of rot fungi and whatever fungi that might be found on fecal matter in crawl spaces (I'm a Home Inspector and spend more than my fair share of time in dark dank crawl spaces where there is often mouse poop)

Her answer:

It's not the fungi you should be worried about, at least not the decay ones. Anything growing on wood and causing a fruiting body is a basidiomycete, and of no danger to you whatsoever. Even the molds that are growing on the surface of the wood are not much of a concern. They can cause allergic reactions in some people (just like a cat or dog might), but taking an antihistamine before doing an inspection would take care of that.

I would be infinitely concerned, however, about the fecal matter, and the fungi growing on that. A very VERY small percentage of fungi that grow on poo (or on soil with fecal matter) can have spores that affect the respiratory system of humans. I would suggest not doing inspections without a NIOSH 95 respirator (or higher, a 99 would be fantastic, but can be pricey - maybe business expense to deduct off your taxes?). The concern is compounded as you are a woodworker, and I'm guessing have not, for the majority of your woodworking career, utilized any type of respiratory protection. Wood dust is a major carcinogen as well as lung irritant. Years of exposure will have damaged your lungs and respiratory system, whether or not you have any symptoms right now. This could make you more sensitive to fungi as a whole, especially those (poo fungi), which have a very small chance of infecting your lungs.

Basically, take care of yourself from now on. Don't cut wood without your NIOSH respirator, and don't do inspections without one either. Your great-grandkids will thank you.

Sara C. Robinson

Assistant Professor, Anatomy of Renewable Materials

Department of Wood Science and Engineering

Oregon State University

119 Richardson Hall

Corvallis, OR 97331

I am having a hard time accepting how dangerous wood dust apparently is and wrote back to her, thanking her and asked again about the wood dust. She stressed it was a cumulative effect and that many lifelong wood workers don't show symptoms until in their sixty's. I was struck by the perceptive appearance of her comments, but it may just be that I fit the pattern. Many of us here are long time wood workers, never bothered with masks or other PPE, did not have dust collection, or Air Cleaners and are or approaching our sixty's. She sent a link to a PDF and I am posting it here. I have not read it, but I will.

http://ntp.niehs.nih.gov/ntp/roc/twelfth/profiles/WoodDust.pdf

Since many of us fit the stereotype, I thought it was worth posting on the Messages forum.

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....on Fungi

#2

Surprised

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

you, an experienced home inspector, didn't know about the issues with mouse poo and nesting areas.

Heavy-duty pathogens. Mask will help, but the infectious dust will permeate your clothing as well so you get to snort it in the car and drag it in when you get home. Consider coveralls and wash them after each use.

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....on Fungi

#3

Ellis Walentine

Wow, that report is damning

Ellis Walentine

Thanks for posting that report, Barry. I had the pleasure of sitting in at a lecture that Dr. Sara gave, and she didn't drop that bomb about wood dust being linked to nasal cancer. The evidence sounds pretty convincing. I'm glad that I use a NIOSH respirator for turning, but I think back over 40-odd years of unprotected (or inadequately protected) woodworking and construction of just about every conceivable variety. I guess it's too late to reverse a cumulative exposure, but I'm going to be more aware of dust exposure in the future.

Ellis

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....on Fungi

#4

Re: Wow, that report is dreaming

Tom in Toronto

I don't believe it! OK, of course it is true, but everything has to be taken with a chill pill. What species of wood; what exposure levels; what else where the people of that age doing; how many smoked, how many where around dangerous fires, possibly combat; what is a woodworker today? someone who works with a lot of bad glue in a MDF pant? etc...

I know the Gougeons (national treasures) who use both a ton of epoxy, and a ton of bad wood, never had problems with OSHA when they got their inspections. OK that is the good news. Tragically, Jan died rapidly after exposing a wall filled with mouse poo during a renovation of his florida retirement residence. You could call what they did in the shop university level woodworking in the sense that there were some degrees in that family, and they weren't working for someone else, but themselves. They took reasonable precautions.

Having expressed my skepticism, I do take significant precautions. I work with some dangerous materials, epoxy, fibers like glass and carbon. I use nasty woods, weld, etc... I have a dust collector, I would never use with anything other than dust. I have a racle helmet, with positive air pressure, and I have a quiet shop vac with a goretex hepa filter. I never do bad things inside the shop, and will put stuff off half a year if I need a weather window to do it safely outside. I live in the city much of the year, so there is stuff I won't even do outside.

Hand tools are a huge part of my strategy. I also have my own methods for working with glass and epoxy, so that I never have to sand it. Same thing with drywall, I have a zero sanding approach to that. Not sure how toxic it is, but sanding it is like abortions, hard to see the upside if there was any way to have avoided them.

What I do think people need to consider very seriously is that there are people out there like Derek, who seem to spend the time in the shop that one would expect a pro to spend. And the shop is usually small with little air turn over. So your home shop almost certainly doesn't pass an OSHA inspection. That is a reason for concern, but not the drivel about what wage slaves are living with. The good and bad news is that you are on your own. Nothing anyone says really tells your story, but you can't take any comfort from that either.

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....on Fungi

#5

Dad and an arborist's observation

Tom Dunlap

My Dad died several years ago from pulmonary complications. Smoking for years but quitting years ago still had an effect. Working in a machine shop for some years probably didn't help. He did a LOT of turning later in life. Most of the time with only a 'bra cup' respirator. No matter what my Mom/brother/me said he was reluctant to use a good respirator for too long. Those tiny particles, no matter where they come from are NOT compatible with how lungs function. I'm convinced that wood dust, heck, any dust in too large a does isn't healthy.

There are decay fungii that grow in composted/decaying wood chips and rotten trees that, I've been told by plant pathologists, are NOT healthy for treeworkers. They can't be any better for woodworkers either. I take the pathologists at their word too.

Risk is a matter of degree. The Dr's advice about fecal nasties puts them higher on the 'avoidance' scale.

Dr. Alex Shigo said: It's all about doseage.

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....on Fungi

#6

Yeah, and since I'm now over 61....

Dick Coers

and been working wood for over 40 years. Oh, oh. I remember how I used to tell people that my diet and lifestyle wasn't doing me harm. Then at 55 I went on disability from extreme fatigue issues. Finally found a great doctor that got me off gluten and other food sensitivities, and on natural thyroid that really works for me. Now waiting for the boot to drop on inhaling the dust!

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....on Fungi

#7

Re: Wow, that report is dreaming

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Everyone is warning about wood dust, fungi spores and carcinogens, but no one mentions the possibility of contracting an infection from hantavirus in the mouse poo.

Hemorrhagic Fevers, including Four Corners Virus or Sin Nombre, are a real and potentially fatal concern, and a lot surer and quicker killers than any cumulative exposures (including silicosis, which we also have not mentioned yet, which can originate with sanding drywall, fiberglass, or maybe even some woods with a high silica content).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hantavirus

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....on Fungi

#8

Re: Dad and an arborist's observation

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Wow, the reports of dangers of wood dust seem to follow a roller coaster. Mathias Wandel (Wood Gears) included some emails he received from a Dr in his section on a DIY dust collector that would have everyone believe just the opposite about wood dust, and that it is not nearly as dangerous as many claim!

Here is a question- what about Mesquite, especially if covered with dust?

According to an article in the New Yorker (part of which was in a Social Reader link in today's Washington Post), there is a little-researched and little-known disease called valley fever (or "cocci"), which people can get when they inhale a fungus named Coccidioides immitis, found in dirt and dust. Two-thirds of cases occur in Arizona, where "in 2012, valley fever was the second-most-reported disease."

Every year, there are about 150,000 cases of a disease whose impact in the deserts of the American Southwest "is equal to the impact of polio... before the vaccine," John Galgiani, an infectious-disease physician told Dana Goodyear.

Reported cases have increased tenfold between 1998 and 2011, "and in the most severe cases," Goodyear writes in The New Yorker, there is "no cure."

The fungus infects the lungs, but can also spread to the skin, bones, liver, brain, heart, and the membranes that protect the brain and spinal cord. It can be severely debilitating and even deadly. Spores can also travel to faraway places in shipping containers and even donated organs. One Michigan man Goodyear talks to fell sick after buying a used car from Phoenix. Working with the spores in a lab also poses a major hazard. Goodyear notes that "a group of obstetrics students got [valley fever], though their classroom was two stories above the cocci lab."

Just another thing to worry about!

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....on Fungi

#9

Mesquite...

John in NM

If it gave you Valley Fever, I would have had it already :D You can get lots of problems from breathing mesquite dust, Valley Fever is not among them.

The fungus spores that cause it are everywhere in the soil and in the air when the wind blows. So is silica. The vast majority of people do not end up with health problems as a result, and an unlucky few do.