Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Drawer Sizing

Posts

Drawer Sizing

#1

Drawer Sizing

Brad Hall

It been a long while since I have been on wood central. I still see a lot of families names. Anyhow I need some help regarding how to dimension a drawer. I have two projects going on simultaneously. A dresser and a bench top tool chest. For both I finished the cabinets and drawer dividers. For both projects, the drawers will simply slide in and put of the cabinet. There are no drawer slides or runners underneath the drawers. Making up numbers here, but if drawer opening is 24" x 5", what should the drawer dimension be? Obviously a 24x5 size will not fit. Will knocking of 1/8 on each dimension work? Any rule of thumb rules for this?

Re: Drawer Sizing

#2

ahead of the game

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I should be into drawers in my "Samanths's dresser" build being described here. There are many ways to approach drawer building. If the drawer fits right, that is just tight enough, it will not rack when being closed. In fact my goal in drawer fitting is to be able to close the drawer by pushing on any corner of the front. Here is way guaranteed to yield a good fitting drawer.

Make the front just friction fit the opening. This is best done with a hand plane and shooting board, but can be done on the table saw if you are good at it. Dovetail in the sides and back making the sides about 1/16" less tall than the opening. Glue it up using construction where the bottom slides in from the back. Don't install the bottom yet. With a hand plane shave off the sides until it fits. A tiny bit less than 1/16" is about right for the size drawer you describe. A bit more if the shop is very dry, and a bit less if it is very humid. I have a 0.035" feeler gauge. When fitting I slide it around the openings and look for a loose fit of gauge between slidey parts.

Nothing will be more annoying than a sticking drawer. I will set drawers in a damp place for a week and check the fit to see that they will not ever bind in their life unless they get wet.

I shellac and wax drawers after fitting and wax the runners. Stay tuned.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#3

depends on where you live

Dick Coers

and what materials you are going to use. Baltic birch sides and you can fit them pretty snug. Make it from hardwoods and they will swell in the summer and lock into place if you fit them too tightly if built right now. Use quarter sawn and you can fit them more snug than flat sawn. Overlay front, no concern for expansion, but solid wood inset and it needs room. There are lots of expansion calculators on the web.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#4

More info needed

David Yoho

It would help to know what type of drawer you plan to use - inset or overlay and what material. An inset drawer, where the entire box fits into the opening flush with the front of the case, requires a closer fit than an overlay drawer where the drawer front is larger than the opening and stops it from sliding in all the way. Even then, you don't want to size an overlay so there's too much side to side "wiggle room".

As other responses have indicated, you have to allow for seasonal movement in the sizing. Since you are not using mechanical slides, which usually require 1/2" on either side, making the drawer box 1" less in width overall, I'd say you could try a side clearance of 1/8" on both sides and see how that works. As for depth, top to bottom of the opening, I try to make an inset drawer gap fairly uniform with what the side to side is but for an overlay allow a little more since it will not be seen when the drawer is closed.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#5

It is not this complicated

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Every chance I get I look at antique furniture drawers, which are typically inset. Drawers do not change in length so the length can be made as tight as the irregularities of the case will allow. A 5" height is not going to change much either. Typically I see drawers fit in the range of 1/32 to 1/16" total gap and that is what I shoot for. If anything binds it will likely be the height of the drawer sides. This dimension is easy to fix should it be a problem down the road. I certainly would not make the height clearance more than 1/16 for this small drawer if the shop is now dry.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#6

1/8" ?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Did you really mean to recommend 1/8" on BOTH sides? An 1/8" total is a sloppy drawer that may rack and bind when operating. Drawers don't change size along their length. In this dimension they can be fit as tight as the irregularities of the case will allow.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#7

Shrinkage/Expansion tables-nearly worthless

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is well to know where the data in these tables come from. The ones I know of are a result of averaging the shrinkage of numerous test specimens in drying from fully saturated to zero moisture content. The value reported is the average of this shrinkage between saturated and zero moisture content, averaged again for the number of test specimens. . Seldom reported is that the naturally occurring variations in the tree result in a 30% (from memory) variation in this value between trees of the same species. The tabulated values are useful for comparing stability of various species, but useless for predicting what a board in hand may do because....

1. Shrinkage is not linear between 30% and 0% moisture content.

2. Your board may differ substantially from the average board.

3. KD lumber becomes more stable as a result of the typical KD process.

Actual data:

As a result, I find actual stability is much better than these calculations predict. I have 3 test pieces that are cut-offs from panels. They contain the usual variation of grain orientation of flat to quartered. The humidity where they live varies from 40% in the winter to 65% in the summer. Reported are the extremes of sizes I have measured over the past 11 years.

Walnut 25 5/32" to 24 8/32" range 3/32"

Walnut 15 7/32 to 15 9/32" range 2/32"

Elm (reported to be very unstable) 11 42/64 to 11 45/64" range 3/64"

Had I made a 5" tall drawer from the elm it would have changed in height less than 1/32" from season to season. The drawer would not have changed at all in length.

Moral of story- fit length close to prevent racking when operating. Use judgement in fitting height taking into account where the drawer will live and under what conditions it was fit.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#8

Re: 1/8" ?

David Yoho

You're right, Bill. As I wrote my reply I was thinking a drawer the size mentioned should not have much to worry about and could be made pretty close to the opening dimensions. However, trying to provide an answer that will work isn't easy without knowing what wood he's using, weather it's dry or not, what his level of expertise is, or if he's got a way to trim it down should it be necessary.

Yes, 1/8" on each side of an inset drawer is too much (1/4" total) but would and does work for an overlay. I have two dressers with a total of 11 drawers that slide in and out as if they had mechanical slides with no problem. If his concern is about the depth (5"?), then 1/8" to 1/4" shorter shouldn't be out of the question. Although given a width of 24", a drawer in a dresser filled with clothing would benefit from a closer fit depth-wise to prevent it from tilting downward so much when open.

Building them to the close tolerances you mention, while it's what one would want to shoot for, may be daunting to some. Worse case scenario, he might make a prototype with whatever measurements he is comfortable trying and see how it fits and go from there.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#9

Sure, it's not complicated for you...

Dick Coers

but the guy is asking basic questions. He needs some basic knowledge and rules of wood expansion, or he would not be asking. What if he was deciding to make the drawers from either flat sawn sycamore, or baltic birch plywood? He needs to understand, consider the rules, then make a judgement based on what the conditions are at his location. Your rules of expansion, based on where you live, may or may not work for him.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#10

PS- drawer length

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the length of a drawer will, like the width, not change at all because it is long grain. However, the case sides may vary some. I make drawers about 1/4" shorter than the opening.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#11

The essentials

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Ok. Long grain does not change length with humidity changes. Hence the only two dimensions that need to be of concern from changing seasonally, or if the piece is moved, are the case side and the drawer height. If 1/4", maybe 3/8 on a very long drawer, is allowed for the drawer length clearance to accommodate case side movement the piece can be moved from LA to AZ with no worry. This leaves drawer height as the ONLY dimension that needs to be considered for seasonal change.

On a piddly 5" tall drawer a crack on the front that looks good (1/16" or a tad less) will work for a drawer made out of Baltic birch or sycamore. I would be sure it was the full 1/16" if I was building in AZ and moving to LA. It would be slightly less if building in intermediate humidity.

Chances are the internal framing and drawer runners will not be so precise that sizing the drawer off the front opening will always be accurate. I initially size everything off the front drawer opening and then fit the sides and back as needed to the internal openings by hand planing.

The bottom line is what you see will be the reveals around the drawer if it is inset. These "cracks" need to look good.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#12

Re: The essentials

Dick Coers

On inset drawers, if the front is flush with the sides, I will also bevel the bottom of the drawer face to mimic the side and top clearance. In Illinois, I will set the gap around the drawer face at a tight nickel in the dead of winter and a dime in the summer.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#13

Re: Drawer Sizing

Tom in Toronto

For a lot of folks this is woodworking season. So particularly with a hand plane, you can just shoot your drawers in and check them every so often as the season advances, if they seem a little tight, you can take a tad off. That way, you have some real info about what works for you when you hit mid summer. I'm saying start at a sensible place. Watch it as the season goes on. If you start way too tight, you can have a moist zephyr come through the shop and lock your drawers up until December.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#14

Re: Shrinkage/Expansion tables-nearly worthless

Tom in Toronto

"KD lumber becomes more stable as a result of the typical KD process."

More stable than what? Air dried? More stable at ambient than the wood would have been if it was way the heck wet before drying. I am not anticipating many sensible ways to go with this.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#15

Re: Drawer Sizing

Dick Coers

Here's my anecdotal story to back that up. A friend and my son's Godfather, built a white oak desk during the winter. He built the writing board by running the boards from front to back. He didn't use the writing boards much and didn't discover that they were getting tight. In the spring, he found that the joint between the side and front rail was cracking. It actually expanded enough that it broke the joint. He had to wait till the following late fall to be able to get it apart to repair. Steve passed away over 15 years ago, still miss him.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#16

Re: Shrinkage/Expansion tables-nearly worthless

Sgian Dubh

""KD lumber becomes more stable as a result of the typical KD process."

More stable than what? Air dried?

... I am not anticipating many sensible ways to go with this."

I'm trying to puzzle out what that final comment meant, but yes, kiln dried stuff is more stable than air dried stuff because of a form of hysteresis. Wood cells that have shrunk and distorted due to drying are generally unable to return to exactly the pre-existing state they were in prior to drying. What this means for example is, that in the same varying conditions of service, wood kiln dried to say 8% MC will be somewhat more stable than wood air dried to 20% MC, e.g., it will show a smaller range of expansion and contraction than the air dried wood.

Perhaps only tangentially related to the paragraph above, but it's interesting that old dry wood which has been through many seasonal cycles of adsorbing and desorbing moisture becomes less hygroscopic with time, and less responsive to variations in temperature and relative humidity. Research points to changes in wood’s microstructure, essentially chemical in nature leading to hygroscopic and dimensional ageing of wood resulting in a loss of response of wood in relation to hygrothermal changes. Slainte.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#17

Thank you for your patient response

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Mine ran out a long time ago arguing this topic. For what it is worth, and not that I have any expectation of a conversion, work to support this claim was done in the Wood Science department at VA Tech and reported in one of the department publications. But I doubt that the results of a scientific inquiry will have much impact on the air dried committed.

Re: Drawer Sizing

#18

Re: Thank you for your patient response

Sgian Dubh

Bill, I'm not aware there's anything really requiring patience on this issue. I simply posted the information: people can do whatever they want with it after that. To me it's perfectly okay to make your artefact with whatever you want, kiln dried or air dried, although there are times when using air dried wood for a project would be inappropriate, and vice versa. For instance, why would anyone use freshly kiln dried wood at, say 7% MC, to make a garden gate? And who but a numpty, or someone that's inexperienced, would make a chest of drawers destined for a house out of wood that's only ever been air dried to 20% MC? Slainte.