Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

learning to dislike yellow pine

Posts

learning to dislike yellow pine

#1

learning to dislike yellow pine

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Short leaf pine is common into Virginia. It was a common secondary wood in Period furniture. Those making reproductions use it. I first encountered it in the Headley shop where they use it extensively for secondary wood. Many years ago I acquired a few boards as part of some lumber purchase long forgotten. I thought I would use it up in the chest of drawers I am building.



I have come to despise it. It doesn' t mark cleanly with a marking knife. The knifed line in the picture is a series of lines and dents. It hand saws roughly as the teeth bounce over the hard summer wood. The hard summer wood was rough on the chisel when chopping out dovetail waste. And finely it pares irregularly as shown in the picture. The bottom of this dovetail socket should be smooth and would be with poplar.

The boards I have likely came from one tree, so it may not be representative. But if it is, poplar provides a secondary wood that behaves better. That said, if you get poplar that has grown exposed (we call them field poplars) it isn't nice either. Ditto for Cucumber that can get mixed into poplar at the mill. But a deep woods poplar is well behaved.

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

#2

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

Joe Burke

I've often wondered how and why anyone would work with SYP by choice. I could see it being used out of convenience years ago, but not now. It's really tough to work in a lot of ways.

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

#3

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

David Yoho

I developed a dislike for the stuff long ago, and except for carpentry projects, have no use for it. I noticed during a tour of the cabinetmaker's shop in Colonial Williamsburg they used it quite a bit for secondary wood. I'll stick with poplar, myself.

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

#4

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I won't work with it except for construction, or to make birdhouses, and items of that ilk. I rarely use any "secondary" wood for my projects. I have quite a stash of Walnut, Cherry, White oak, etc. that I have purchased for less than $.50/bf at auctions in this area. Much of this was from Amish estate sales and was air dried for years. With other wood I have purchased from the local sawmill (kiln dried rough sawn) I have enough cutoff's etc. that may have stains or of poor appearance that I wouldn't use the material for face stock. I also have a fair amount of large boards / slabs of Popular although haven't used any for secondary use. (Bought a Large stack for about $5 at a local auction that had a few hundred BF). I also have some Hackberry, Locust, Red Elm, Sycamore etc. and occasionally use some for small projects -rarely for secondary use in furniture making. I have a room over my shop that is 30' long, 10' wide with knee walls that is stuffed with wood. So much in fact that I had to quit buying a couple years ago. Doubt I will ever resort to using pine!

I HATE to work with pine for the very reasons you cited. (IMHO it doesn't even make good firewood).

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

#5

Which leads to a question....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

why was short leaf pine used in Virginia and southern locations for secondary wood- drawers, framing and the like? All these locations had access to high quality poplar logs. The answer may be that it was dimensioned easier with hand planes, but that is a guess.

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Which leads to a question....

Jack Guzman from Maine

I like the wood but not for furniture. We don't see much of it in Maine except as pressure treated deck material. I've been in a forest in Alabama where it grew and the trees are beautiful. The bark is almost black. It is rot resistant,hard and has alot of tensile strength. Poplar is easily dented and rots quickly. I think it may have been a choice for drawer parts due to it's strength. That's just a wild guess though,I have no idea. I do carpentry and general repairs to local farm houses. If I had more access to it I would use it constantly. As it is now my building material of choice is white pine. Mainly because it is readily available. The same things made with SYP would last alot longer.---Jack

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

#7

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

Robert Fuller

I was not aware that cucumber was a wood species. I thought it was a variety of squash.

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

#8

Cucumbers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't have a clue why it is named such but a variety of Magnolia that grows in these parts is called Cucumber. It has a lovely spring blossom and wood that looks like poplar, but a bit harder. On the rare occasions that it gets logged and sawed it will be mingled in with poplar.

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

#9

It may be a different pine

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Shortleaf pine is native north as far as VA and maybe farther. It can be found scattered among our hardwood timber. It is nothing like Virginia pine, a forest weed. It is a fine looking tree when it has competed with hardwoods, growing straight and tall with no limbs for the first many feet. The wood may only be somewhat related to the plantation trees grown farther south. I don't know what kind of pine they are and what ever they are they have been selectively genetically "refined" for plantation growth. Our resident foresters can elaborate.

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

#10

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: It may be a different pine

Jack Guzman from Maine

I'm not sure what you mean. The trees I saw in Alabama may be a different species,I'm just going on what a local told me. As to the wood I'm calling southern yellow pine,the stuff you showed in your picture looks just like the SYP I have used.I'm no tree expert I just work with wood.---Jack

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

#11

Re: Magnolia acuminata

William Duffield


The Mountain Magnolia, M. acuminata, gets the name "cucumbertree" from the shape of it's fruiting body, which looks a bit like a small gherkin.

This one grows down the street from me, on the right-of-way of the old Caviar Railroad, definitely not in the mountains, more like 15 ft. elevation. I don't know if it is cultivated or natural here in West Jersey. The distribution map in The Sibley Guide to Trees shows sporadic natural occurrences within 50 miles, but none in Cumberland County.

If you found it mixed with tulip poplar, it could have been done unintentionally, as the mountain magnolia is the only magnolia with furrowed bark, but it still has a quite different appearance from Liriodendron bark. Looking at the leaves would immediately give it away, unless it was harvested in the winter.


img

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

#12

Re: It may be a different pine

William Duffield

Most of the plantation grown yellow pine in the Deep South are slash pine, Pinus elliottii, which grows much faster than longleaf or heart pine, Pinus palustris. I've seen it with growth rings 5/8" apart. It is mostly consumed by the pulp mills for making paper. OTOH, I have old growth longleaf pine flooring boards I've taken out of my house that have 32 growth rings to the inch.

Note also that there are two different (at least) yellow pine species that are called Shortleaf Pine in the southeast, with extensively overlapping ranges, P. echinata and P. taeda. The latter is more commonly called Loblolly Pine.

None of these grow in Maine, but all of them grow in Alabama. About the only yellow pines that do grow in Maine are Jack Pine, Pitch Pine, Red Pine and Scots Pine.

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

#13

Re: Which leads to a question....

William Duffield

I'm speculating here, but did they have access to tulip poplar? Often the population centers in the south were along the coastal plane, in very sandy soil, that had never had glacial deposits. When I drive down to Williamsburg, for example, I am struck by how much of the forests are almost exclusively pine. Maybe, the tulip poplar trees were mostly harvested before these lowland population centers developed a fine furniture building industry, and yellow pine was a lot closer at hand. Of course, that would not have been the case in Winchester, VA, or Salem, NC, but those areas have a quite different ecology than the coastal planes. Might be a good topic for someone's doctoral thesis. :)

Re: learning to dislike yellow pine

#14

Dale Lenz

Re: It may be a different pine

Dale Lenz

I would suspect the pine you are speaking of is the shortleaf pine. Most of the native pines here are shortleaf. Many of the plantation grown pines here in OK are loblolly pines. Shortleaf and loblolly are two different species, but are marketed as Southern Yellow Pine, along with slash, longleaf and sometime Virginia pines.

There are a few things between the trees that are noted and I must admit, I have forgotten most of those. One of the trees naturally prune better than the others. One thing for sure is the loblolly grows faster than the shortleaf (first 45 yrs. or so) and that is why we grow them in plantations.

I dislike sawing SYP because of the pitch build up on blades etc. Barbara Gill told me years ago to spray Pam, cooking spray on the blades etc. before sawing and it will reduce the pitch build up. Have a can of Pam in my shop.