learning to dislike yellow pine
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Short leaf pine is common into Virginia. It was a common secondary wood in Period furniture. Those making reproductions use it. I first encountered it in the Headley shop where they use it extensively for secondary wood. Many years ago I acquired a few boards as part of some lumber purchase long forgotten. I thought I would use it up in the chest of drawers I am building.

I have come to despise it. It doesn' t mark cleanly with a marking knife. The knifed line in the picture is a series of lines and dents. It hand saws roughly as the teeth bounce over the hard summer wood. The hard summer wood was rough on the chisel when chopping out dovetail waste. And finely it pares irregularly as shown in the picture. The bottom of this dovetail socket should be smooth and would be with poplar.
The boards I have likely came from one tree, so it may not be representative. But if it is, poplar provides a secondary wood that behaves better. That said, if you get poplar that has grown exposed (we call them field poplars) it isn't nice either. Ditto for Cucumber that can get mixed into poplar at the mill. But a deep woods poplar is well behaved.






