Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Samantha's dresser Part 1

Posts

Samantha's dresser Part 1

#1

Samantha's dresser Part 1

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Samantha’s dresser Part 1

There was some interest expressed in the details of this project. Over the next few months as I build it I will post details of how it is built. These details may be of value to those that have not settled on a way to build case pieces. For those that have other approaches it will be an opportunity to compare and contrast.

When I began to build furniture for the house, case pieces- boxes with drawers and doors- were a common need. There are dozens of ways to build them. I never found a good book that provided a road map. A class in the Mack Headley and Sons shop did. Their approach, common to Period furniture from the Shenandoah valley, is relatively quick, robust, reliable, and easy to execute with mostly power tools. I will note where I deviate from their approach, and why.

Choosing the lumber for panels


I like to make sides and top from one thick plank resawed and book matched, or from one board, cut in the middle, and folded back on itself. The edges of wide boards are invariably rift grain and when folded back on itself a board can usually be nicely matched to yield an attractive pattern. In this picture I am diddling with the two pieces, testing orientations to get the best effect.


Next, glue them together. I can not over emphasize the need to have everything ready to go. A dry fit of the pieces is the way to ensure you are ready to glue. Note the scrap pieces between clamps and panel edge. There is more glue squeeze out on this panel than I consider ideal. It is most convenient to remove the panel from the clamps and scrape the glue off while the glue is still rubbery. If the glue is hard be careful removing it. Shearing it off can lift pieces of wood under the glue drops and this is very bad. I shave dry glue off with a cheap block plane reserved for this abuse.

I am very fond of the clamps shown. They are used commercially. Lee Valley now sells them or in bulk you can buy direct from factory. Our club has bought hundreds of them for members.


There are lots of ways of spreading glue. There are several goals to be achieved. Most critically, both edge faces need to be wet with glue to make a bond. Also critical, the surface of the glue must not begin to dry before joint assembly. And, it is desirable to not have gobs of glue squeezing out to be cleaned up later. To get both surfaces wet, quickly, to avoid drying in the winter low humidity shop environment, I deposit a thin layer of glue by running a thin track of glue from the bottle down each outside edge of one board and down the middle of the other(see picture). Then I push the boards together lightly and wiggle them to transfer glue between the surfaces. I raise the edge to see that I have glue largely on both surfaces and then proceed to tighten the clamps, starting in the center and working my way to each end while adjusting the alignment. Finally, I snug each clamp. After a minute or two I snug the clamps again. Sufficient pressure must be applied to squeeze out all the glue that can be squeezed out to yield a gap-free joint. The glue line in a well made joint can not be seen.

Re: Samantha's dresser Part 1

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Samantha's dresser Part 1

Clint Searl

I have no doubt that your approach to gluing up panels results in strong finished joints, but I offer these comments in contrast. The panels in question are never subjected to stresses that threaten the integrity of the joint. Therefore, only that amount of glue to mate and immobilize the two edges is necessary, and the less glue that must be compressed out of the joint, the less clamping pressure is needed.

I suggest a different approach that, in my experience, results in a functionally and aesthetically equivalent joint. Starting from an invisible gap-free dry fit, I run a thin bead of glue down the middle of one board's edge, smearing it across the edge with my finger. The objective is to avoid squeeze out when it's clamped. Using simple bar clamps that tend to bow if tightened too much, I space them alternately up and down no closer than 10"-12" apart, and pull them up enough to make the joint disappear. Any slight squeeze out is immediately wiped up with wet toweling.

Re: Samantha's dresser Part 1

#3

Ditto +

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I apply a swipe of paste wax to the faces on either side of the joint to prevent any glue staining. Glue sets. Clamps come off. Wax gets removed with a wipe of MS.

Re: Samantha's dresser Part 1

#4

In defense of glue slathering and a question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I developed my crude glue application habits when gluing gobs of panels. I used to be meticulous about applying glue and spreading glue. When quick trumped tidy I gravitated to the quickest way to get glue on a joint and wet each surface. Seconds to apply the glue and start clamping. The amount of squeeze out I get is about what I see in factory situations where they have metered spreaders.

About wet wipes? I have always feared that if I wet wiped yellow glue it would mostly spread it around to places that I would loose track of and it would return to bite me when I stained. Apparently a wet wipe does not wick the glue into the wood pores where it will be difficult to sand out?

Re: Samantha's dresser Part 1

#5

Clint Searl

Re: In defense of glue slathering and a question

Clint Searl

Perhaps with the amount of squeeze out in your picture, wet wiping might be problematic. I rarely get more than a spotty bit of glue to remove, initially by lifting with a putty knife or squared-off icing spatula, followed by wiping with a pretty wet towel, then damp and dry toweling. Final sanding or scraping removes any lingering glaze.

Re: Samantha's dresser Part 1

#6

Re: In defense of glue slathering and a question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

With the Miyagi Method, the squeeze will simply pop off when dry using a spatula.

Re: Samantha's dresser Part 1

#7

Re: In defense of glue slathering and a question

Barry Irby

I am not happy until I see some squeeze out. My eye site is not good enough to convince my self I have perfectly mated edges. I am trying to sell myself on the idea that if I missed by a thousandth here and there the glue will bridge the tiny gaps. (I know yellow glue does not bridge gaps, bot it does for me, so there.)

I usually let it dry until it reaches the leather stage a lift it off with an old dull chisel I have for the purpose. Then I let it fully cure and sand off any that escaped. The fully cured glue does not seem to clog the sand paper and does not smear.

I have not tried it, but the idea of adding whatever it is that shows up in a black light to the glue and then using a such a light to find the residue sounds like the best use I ever heard of for a black light. Unless you still miss some and put your piece of furniture in a room with a black light.

Re: Samantha's dresser Part 1

#8

Re: Samantha's dresser Part 1

Barry Irby

Bill, thanks for posting these step by step pics. I have made a resolution to make more furniture this year. Lately I tend to over think things and let the thinking stop the actual process.

What I am anxious to see is the internal details. The runners and blades or whatever you use or call them. I am making a chest right now and have invented my own set up, but I figure these problems were solved long ago. I want to see what you have gleaned and believe works well.

Re: Samantha's dresser Part 1

#9

best of all....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....will be if others with alternative ways of doing this or that tell what they do different to reliably accomplish the same goal.

Re: Samantha's dresser Part 1

#10

Re: Best tip ever...

Tom

"Therefore, only that amount of glue to mate and immobilize the two edges is necessary, and the less glue that must be compressed out of the joint, the less clamping pressure is needed."

I got in an old guitar book. The guy pointed out that one should snug a joint, leave it a short piece of time, then come back for the final crank down. How long, a minute, it is pretty obvious, but varies depending on the joint, glue thickness. This does two things. One has to crank a joint to push thick glue the distance of travel it needs to take to get out of the joint. With the two step, that issue doesn't come up, the first step moves the glue, the second step gets the pressure on. But as important is the fact that the parts are a lot less likely to skid, so they stay in alignment.

This is a process for butt joint, not say dovetails or M&T. But it goes far beyond panels. With guitars, for instance, there are dozen of joints, and the majority by far, are some kind of butt joint.

One thing I like in Bills' pic is he seems to be using round squeeze bottles with a flat tip glue bottle nozzle, that looks like a useful combo. I get about the same amount of squeeze out as Bill, though I apply differently. I will try his method. Normally I try to remove the glue when it is rubbery, or I scrape it and plane it. If there isn't any planing left to do, just light sanding or scraping, then I wouldn't want wax anywhere near it for fear of contamination of the finish.

Re: Samantha's dresser Part 1

#11

Re: best of all....

Barry Irby

On the dresser I am making, I cut sliding dovetails all the way across at each horizontal for a drawer. The case is walnut and I closely fitted pieces in the front and back. I made pieces about an eighth inch wider than the horizontal dividers between the drawers. I milled a dovetail on the back of each and they slide loosely in between the front and back. They are about a 1/4" short of the back and glued only at the front. They are Quarter Sawn White Oak with the rays up. They serve as slides for the drawers and kickers. Because they are slightly wider than the dividers they should keep the drawers from wearing into the dividers. They are loose to allow the sides to move.

Re: Samantha's dresser Part 1

#12

that makes a very heavy piece

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

stay tuned next week for a more traditional approach.