Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

The Practice of Woodworking

Posts

The Practice of Woodworking

#1

The Practice of Woodworking

don stephan

Recently there were some strong positions taken in a discussion on spring joints.

A careful rereading this morning of the triggering Q&A in Popular Woodworking did not find a recommendation regarding spring joints, just an explanation. The editor is to be commended because it wasn't even revealed if he uses spring joints.

In my opinion, too many how-to materials today do not address the characteristics of wood and thus do the readers a great disservice.

By itself, being able to follow directions and feed wood through a machine makes one a materials handler, not a woodworker.

The article presented a great opportunity to look at what characteristics of hide glue (popular in earlier times) may allow the use of fewer clamps than other glues, but unfortunately the response did not make this distinction. A generalized suggestion that spring joints might allow fewer clamps is not helpful.

To me, this and other forums are most helpful when information is presented that allows us to understand the characteristics and limitations of working with wood in its different forms. That's why I'm looking forward to Richard Jones' wood technology book as a companion to Bruce Hoadley's Understanding Wood.

Re: The Practice of Woodworking

#2

Re: The Practice of Woodworking

Barry Irby

I have used spring joints. (I thought they were SPRUNG joints, but who knew) Sometimes when I run long material over my jointer I get joints that appear sprung. The knowledge that sprung joints were used in ancient times was reassuring and let me glue up such joints with confidence and not to worry about the last few thousandths in the quest for "straightness".

To me, it seems that what we should learn form those who went before us as craftsmen is what they did that worked both in the design sense and in the technical sense of what survived the test of time and serviceability. Why was particular species of wood used? Why was it sawn in a certain fashion? How was it dried? What joints continued to function?

The question of how they did it is interesting but may not be as important, or is it. Do we value a piece of furniture because it was HAND CRAFTED more than an identical piece that had machines involved in the construction? Where is the limit? Can the craftsman use modern factory made tools or must he hand forge his own. OK to fell the tree with a chainsaw or must it be felled with an ax? I assume people like Chippendale were modernizing their shops as fast as they could and that if he were to walk into a modern shop he would say, OK, now we can really move this along.

Re: The Practice of Woodworking

#3

Re: The Practice of Woodworking

Chuck Bender

Don,

Thank you.

Having read the other thread, I am still unsure whether it is in favor or opposed to spring joints. My explanation was both condemned and supported in the same post. Frankly, I couldn't understand all the fuss considering all I did was answer a question asking me to define a spring joint. I neither decried nor advocated its use. The answer I gave was based on basic wood structure theory (that I learned in school and through independent study) plus over 30 years experience as a full-time professional furniture maker where that theory was applied daily.

Personally, I use them if I can and if it makes sense. I do not particularly create them solely with hand tools and any suggestion that they can only be created that way is incorrect.

As to the application of a spring joint in regards to hide glue versus other glues, I have never treated them differently. For years I worked solely with hide glue and, other than the open time, used the same procedures as with PVA glue. I have, personally, found no difference in the number of clamps required whether using hide (the hot stuff not that liquid stuff), white, yellow, casein resin or urea-formaldehyde resin glues when used in conjunction with a spring joint. I hope this helps clear up any confusion cause by the ambiguity.

Re: The Practice of Woodworking

#4

Re: The Practice of Woodworking

les winter

Where can if find more information on this book?

thank you.

Les

Re: The Practice of Woodworking

#5

Re: The Practice of Woodworking

Tom

"The question of how they did it is interesting but may not be as important, or is it. Do we value a piece of furniture because it was HAND CRAFTED more than an identical piece that had machines involved in the construction?"

Even way back "then" there were machines involved. Hand made tends to be an amateur perspective, because: most stuff isn't; people consider a hand opening the CNC machine box to entitle them to call the end product hand made; hand made really doesn't define anything including difficulty of making, etc...

However it has value to some buyers, and to some makers, so there is no way to resolve the issue.

"Where is the limit? Can the craftsman use modern factory made tools or must he hand forge his own. OK to fell the tree with a chainsaw or must it be felled with an ax?"

It is a vague concept, but all it would take is some kind of standard, like fair trade or, organic. Absolutely not perfect standards, but the perfect is the enemy of the good. The US has this tendency towards an orthodoxy of conservatism combined with a radical inability to agree on any standard. One can laugh.

"I assume people like Chippendale were modernizing their shops as fast as they could and that if he were to walk into a modern shop he would say, OK, now we can really move this along. "

I doubt it, or they would have ended up inventing IKEA. One thing is clear, the means available influence the aesthetic outcome. The moment time and motion became popular machine tools lost their filigree. There was no production reason, it just fell out of style. Mass production infects the modern way of thinking to such an extent, that we are incapable of recognizing the past, or the people in it.

Re: The Practice of Woodworking

#6

Re: The Practice of Woodworking

Tom

"By itself, being able to follow directions and feed wood through a machine makes one a materials handler, not a woodworker."

Maybe, but the breaking out stage, whatever tools I use for it, and it varies a lot depending on the condition of the wood, or it' size, is possibly the most woody part of the whole thing. Looking at the wood the grain, doing stuff to get the fiber, or figure aligned is probably the highest end stuff, compared to bagging out some hand made dovetails, or a hand planed finish.

"The article presented a great opportunity to look at what characteristics of hide glue (popular in earlier times) may allow the use of fewer clamps than other glues, but unfortunately the response did not make this distinction. A generalized suggestion that spring joints might allow fewer clamps is not helpful."

In my case hide glue means you can use no clamps, as you can with some PVA, and you may need dead flat surfaces, or not. But flat as a generality. Often with clamps, spring is useful to reduce the total number required, though it is open to question as to whether that is putting production ahead of result.