Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Golden Rectangle

Posts

Golden Rectangle

#1

Golden Rectangle

John Pappas

In another thread the subject of Golden Rectangles was raised and, in that particular thread, it was generally dismissed as "useless" in furniture design.

A couple of comments. I personally find the concept useful. Not having any natural design ability, I have found it to be effective in helping me design pieces that were pleasantly proportioned. A second point is that much of the furniture in early times incorporated the golden rectangle. These period pieces have stood the test of time, and are often copied and duplicated.

It is not a guidline to be taken as absolute, not necessarily used in every piece of furniture, but certainly a useful tool to have in the toolkit.

Re: Golden Rectangle

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Golden Rectangle

Clint Searl

I doubt that there was much intentional use of the GM in historical design. Rather, it just may be that an aspect ratio between 1 and 2 is pleasing to the eye, with something around 1.5 being most so.

Re: Golden Rectangle

#3

Re: Golden Rectangle

Stephen W. Schoene

While the golden ratio may not have been used much in period furniture, other complicated systems of proportion were quite clearly used. In particular the classical column orders seem to be quite common. Mack Headley Master of the Cabinetmakers Shop has written and spoken quite a bit about that. Notice too, if not used in furniture design why did Chippendale make careful proportioned drawing of those orders in his Directory.

Re: Golden Rectangle

#4

Re: Golden Rectangle

Dick Coers

I disagree Clint. The greeks could not have designed all those structural elements by chance. It would be impossible to go by eye on structures that big. Unless, the same aliens that designed and oversaw the pyramids did those too.

Re: Golden Rectangle

#5

Re: Golden Rectangle

David Churnega

I am no expert on the "golden rectangle" but isn't it based on the slope of the pyramids. That ratio was certainly used, not by chance.

Re: Golden Rectangle

#6

Re: Golden Rectangle

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My original point was not whether it was used in pyramids but whether it was useful for designing a dining room table or a place to store your socks. I never found it a useful size ratio for anything I ever built. The small side usually would become impractically too big using this "rule".

Some furniture is made to be an art form. It may well be that this ratio can be employed to good effect when the place to store your socks doesn't have to fit next to the bed and under the window. The point to be made is that the practical application of the furniture trumps the requirement to use this ratio in design. The piece can looks just fine in some other ratio. However, if the shoe fits, wear it.

Re: Golden Rectangle

#7

Re: Golden Rectangle

clay foster

I wanted to build a new dining table once, and thought I'd see how the golden mean would work for this. I drew up a lot of plans. They all looked hideous, and would have been very impractical.