On Torsion Boxes, Yet Again
John McGaw
There have been numerous discussions about the benefits and possible pitfalls of torsion boxes over the years. A recent one touched upon using foam as a filler material rather than the traditional wood ribs and stretcher approach. I did an experiment with a foam-cored mantel 'slab' for my downstairs remodel. I needed a 90" X 9" shelf for the mantel over the brick fireplace and, there being no good structure to mount it, a lightweight fake would be best.
What I made used 2-1/2" X 3/4" poplar stock exactly as it came from the rack at the local borg, selecting the straightest (yeah, right) pieces I could find. These were cut to size, rabbeted 1/4" deep to suit cheap plywood and 3/8" wide on both sides. A 90X9 box was biscuited together and glued up with mitered corners. I then glued hardwood plywood which the borg sells for floor underlayment into one side's rabbets using regular yellow glue, added nearly every clamp I had and then dried it overnight.
I had some big slabs of semi-rigid packing foam which my kitchen sink was shipped in and, while not nearly so rigid or strong as normal insulation foam, I figured that it would do and it had the great benefit of being free. The foam was a bit thick to fit into the proposed space so I ran it through my thickness planer and then cut it to width and length to fit the recess in the box perfectly. The foam was glued into the box using West System epoxy, mostly to the plywood but as best I could to the box sides too. I smeared some more epoxy onto the top of the sandwich, added yellow glue to the rabbet and then added the other plywood skin and then clamped again overnight.
Some of the seams weren't quite perfect so I filled everything with auto body filler to make sure that I would have the look of a perfect slab. After a lot of sanding I did a minor roundover on all exposed corners and edges.
So, how strong is a foam torsion box? Supporting the box between sawhorses at the very ends I took the plunge and sat in the middle. Not only didn't I plunge, the deflection was nearly undetectable, certainly < 1/4" so I can say that a 90" X 9" X 2-1/2" torsion box with 1/4" plywood skins can easily support a 195-pound dead load and would certainly be up to much more. This isn't too shabby considering that the whole assembly weighs just over 13 pounds and was made with cheap or free materials.
I still need to design and make some corbels before I can install it but I'm certain that it will last longer than I will and will hold up whatever little things it might need to.





