Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

need stud finder

Posts

need stud finder

#1

need stud finder

kevin

Any suggestions on a stud finder?

I had an old Ryobi that was sufficient. It seems to have died. I read the FWW/FHB article that suggested the Bosch GMS120 or Zircon i520.

But when I read the reviews the Bosch is not overwhelmingly positive. It seems 1/3 or so are quite negative, notably for wood studs (which is 90% of what I need).

If the Bosch was as advertised I was prepared to pay the $59, but the cast of negative reviews has me thinking the i520 or another.. maybe even the good old magnetic nail/screw finder.

Re: need stud finder

#2

Re: need stud finder

Larry

A Small Nail & Hammer

Re: need stud finder

#3

Re: need stud finder

Mike foster

I've never been totally satisfied with any electronic stud finder and my current house is an old Vermont farmhouse with plaster walls. The electronic stud finders are almost useless in that situation. I recently came across a magnetic stud finder that is now my go to. Although the older magnetic one I had would work, I would rate it on par with the electronic ones. The new one I found is fitted with a rare earth magnet an will hang on the wall when you find a screw or nail. I love it and it is all I use now

Re: need stud finder

#4

New type of stud finder *LINK*

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

A new stud finder from Dewalt will identify what type of material is located behind the wall. It's not a cheap date, but it seems to work well. Take a look at the product video at the link below.

Lee


img

Dewalt Stud Finder

Re: need stud finder

#5

Re: New type of stud finder

Bryan Cowing

don't buy one with LCD screen, very hard to see. I have an expensive one collecting dust >( . I like the cheap ones with the red lights. :)

Re: need stud finder

#6

fool proof stud finder

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't know where I got it but I have a plastic handle thingy with a spring loaded needle in it. One jabs it into the drywall and if there is a stud beneath it stops after 1/2". It leaves a tiny hole which I have not found to be a problem.

Re: need stud finder

#7

Re: need stud finder

Brian in SLO

I too have an electronic version that never really worked very well. Instead I have resorted to just a good strong rare earth magnet. Works great and it's MUCH cheaper than any of the electronic variety that may or may not work.

Re: need stud finder

#8

Franklin 710 for $50

Ronster

I've owned a few different types, but I'm not a pro. Bought this unit a few months ago and really like it.

Re: need stud finder

#9

Rare earth magnets are the best...

Dick Coers

Just slide the magnets around on the wall and when it sticks, you have a nail or screw under it. I've seen ideas of putting the magnet on a string and swinging it around on the wall, but if you use a magnet of any size, it just about hops over to the screw.

Re: need stud finder

#10

Re: fool proof stud finder

Richard McComas

You probably got it from Garret Wade

http://www.garrettwade.com/stud-finder/p/25T23.01/

Re: need stud finder

#11

Re: Rare earth magnets are the best...

kevin

Just kick me.

I had just bought 20 rare earth magnets from Lee Valley to complete an order - thinking I'd surely have some use for them someday. Now I did get the smaller ones, but they can pull each other around on a 1-1/4" thick pine tabletop. Finding a screw in drywall should be easy enough. A couple and a level should give me a pretty good idea of center. Knowing exact center would be handy, but not sure they e-finders are much assurance of that.

Re: need stud finder

#12

Re: Rare earth magnets are the best...

Barry Irby

I had an ancient electronic stud finder. (Zircon?) Probably thirty years old, it worked OK. Lost it and went to buy another. The reviews on Amazon were so bad I did not buy one.

I have used rare earth magnets. Very handy when trying to cut a hole in oak flooring. Just slide it along the joint and it will stop on top of the nails. You can role them down the joints and they will stop over the nail. I made a bunch of patches in an oak floor for my cousin. I am sure the magnets saved me many router bits and saw blades.

They would work well on drywall as well.

I have used a hammer and a nail about a thousand times.

I bet a thermographic camera would work well.

Re: need stud finder

#13

We use the Franklin stud finders daily.  The BEST!

Scott in Montana

We have tried them on the job and the Franklin 710 simply works as described. Horizontally, vertically, multiple studs, studs with a small (1/2") gap between them....... it accurately shows them all. The best work tool we bought last year.

Scott in Montana

Re: need stud finder

#14

Re: Rare earth magnets are the best...

kevin

That is kinda where I am. I was about to buy the Bosch GMS 120, then read the online reviews, and it seemed to be getting too many negatives. My old Ryobi did an admirable job. Hate to see it die. Cheap and worked. The Bosch seemed like a nice toy. But not thinking I can get by with the RE magnets. I was hoping to get a solid reading on the exact location of the studs, but maybe that's just not realistic.

Re: need stud finder

#15

Re: Only problem with magnets...

Tom

is they don't alert you to stuff like electrical wires. And of course you may find a screw that is anywhere on a stud liked jammed between two where several are paired. No biggie, I use mags also.

Re: need stud finder

#16

Re: Only problem with magnets...

Tom

Oh, I also often hang rare earth things above the kid's reach, on the surface of the walls in order to avoid kids playing with them and getting hurt or wreaking media, etc...

Re: need stud finder

#17

Re: fool proof stud finder

Tom

Is it good at finding electrical also? :)

I used to drill for studs, my dad used a knuckle and a drill, but I start to take it on the chin if I drill a bunch of holes, with good reason to believe there is a stud under each. I can't take the reproach.

Re: need stud finder

#18

Re: Only problem with magnets...

kevin

right.. in some case (lag screwing) it's nice to get close to the center of that stud..