A local mill has red oak, soft maple, and green ash. I'm familiar with red oak, but not so much the other two, especially "green ash". The "green ash" is the type - it's not "freshly cut".
Couple things: Local mills always have green (freshly cut) lumber, but not all of them have kiln-dried lumber, which is what you want for furniture or other finished products. The three species you mentioned are common species, especially here in the East. Red oak has a grainy appearance (ring-porous) and a pinkish cast. Soft maple is a nice diffuse- porous hardwood that is easy to work and sometimes dramatically figured. Green ash is a utility wood, as far as I am concerned -- not much to look at, very ring porous. I use it for firewood. All three are suitable for interior woodworking, flooring, etc., but not for anything outdoors, e.g., deck furniture, decking, siding, etc., because they rot easily.
Any tips on what to look for in a stack of lumber?
I'm not sure where you're going with this one. How much lumber do you need and for what? There are lots of things to look for: boards of the right length, width and thickness for your project(s); the right moisture content (kiln-dry, air-dry, green); the right grain pattern (flat sawn, rift sawn, quartersawn, or a mixture) for the appearance you want, especially with the ring-porous species. Then, there are the bad things to look for, like blue stain, sticker stain, powder-post beetle frass, etc., that would discourage you from buying that particular stack of lumber. Then there are the cost of the wood and the reputation and helpfulness of the seller.
Get more specific and we may be able to shed more light on this for you.
I live in an area of the country that is not really a timber producing area, but they're are a couple of guys doing urban salvage milling. both are great guys to do business, one in particular. Ellis has given some sound advice I would add that it can be a very rewarding relationship up have a good local mill that you do business with, but be prepared for a lot of lower quality wood to be mixed among the special heirloom boards and as a general rule I buy 2x what I need to allow for defects and waste. That said the guy I use always throws in an extra board or two.
Don't be deterred by the kiln drying bit. for the past 20 years I've used very little kiln dried wood.
Thanks for the comments and sorry for the wide-open questions. I do some woodworking -- have a nice shop, some decent tools like Jet cabinet saw, Jet 14 BS, Jet 6" jointer, and a centrally attached Jet DC that I plumbed to those tools with 6" s&d pipe. Not trying to impress anyone -- just giving some general background that may help.
I was not familiar with "green ash", but did some looking last eve. A board with uniform color seems could be used for furniture. It's about as hard or harder than red oak. I'm excited to go to a local mill -- small one albeit, and there are others around here. I found the $/bd-ft to be low, so it's changing my perspective on my projects where I had tended to go cheap, build with 2x pine, and regret.
The comment about planning for 2x the project bd-ft needed is good -- even 3x is now within reach. 2x would be great, as I'm sure there would be many "scraps" that will be great for jigs, etc. I'm in eastern KS, and these mills are saying they harvest locally. I have 20ac. or so of woods, but not much over 12" in diameter, and no good way (that I know of) to harvest. I get over to the KC woodworking shows each year. I guess I'm "dangerous" and just looking to gather in more info on working with local hardwoods -- picking from a stack, knowing what to look for, etc. From what I've read, I'm fine with air-dried. Some, like Michael Fortune (FWW write) even prefer it. It seems to make sense. Our humidity here in the summer can hover around 70-80% for weeks, so I guess I need to understand how to take air-dried lumber, acclimate in my shop (or house?) and then work.
I'm familiar with the machining process -- starting with a decent board -- joint face, joint edge, plane, rip, etc. What I'm not familiar with is selecting from a pile -- looking for defects -- avoiding contaminants, etc.
Just having materials here now ( we moved from CO 5 years ago), is opening up some new ideas. Maybe the spent jointer and planer blades will offset the wood costs, but at least I'll be making sawdust!
Soft maple that came from "red maple" is a fine wood. Works well, stains well. Green ash is one of the ash varieties and all the ashes look about the same after sawing. I like its looks. The picture is of an ash cabinet side. Ash can have more tendency to be difficult to plane than oak. Ash is not an easy wood to work.
"For sale, packages of beef ready to eat or freeze. $1.75/ lb" Compared to a grocery store prices this appears to be a steal. Whether it is or not depends on what grade of animal it came from- choice, good, cutters and caners. And, what part of the animal did it get cut from- tenderloin, leg, neck.... There is an analogy with logs and lumber. And then there is the issue of how was it sawed and dried, each offering a variety of ways to turn good lumber into bad.
There are way too many ways to get screwed buying lumber at a saw mill than can be readily listed. The inexperienced will not see many kinds of defects in rough lumber until it gets planed. It is guaranteed that you will pay more than market price for the mill would have sold the lumber into the market if they could have. The most important question to be answered is why is the mill willing to take time to sell a small quantity of lumber to in individual as opposed to sending the truckload off to market? Good reasons include- the current market for ash sucks, the mill only had a few logs of this species and it was not practical to take a partial load to market, the mill can get a bit more money selling small quantities retail to local customers. Not so good reasons- the lumber would not be marketable at the wholesale level because it was mis-cut, below grade, stained(especially worrisome in the case of maple).
Bottom line- you are not going to learn to buy lumber from a mill on a Forum. Go to mill. Talk to mill personnel and learn what you can. Buy a trial quantity. Learn from successes and mistakes. If the lumber is "log run" and has not been picked over expect to get a lot of "hamburg meat". If the logs were large and clean, log run may yield half or more of top grade lumber. If the logs were small or of poor quality it will all be "stew meat and hamburger" and yield only short of narrow clear cuttings.
I've been at the point now for a number of years where I prefer buying rough lumber and dressing it myself. Earlier on when I was starting out I bought my wood from a big local yard that was S2S (surfaced two sides). I soon began to realize the 4/4 stock had no room to fix bow or cup due to the 13/16 thickness. So if it moved or wasn't dead flat and I needed 3/4" stock, I was out of luck. And I paid more since someone else dressed it.
Now every project I start begins at the jointer and then the planer. I pay less for the rough stock and can dress 4/4 to more than 3/4" if needed. To me it's a win-win.
My first purchase was a few hundred bdft of oak and cherry from an individual in Minneapolis. I hauled it on the roof of a VW bug. I was lucky in that it turned out to be outstanding lumber in spite of the fact I didn't know what I was doing.
The next purchase was a few hundred bdft of log run walnut plus two veneer logs to be sawed. The largest log had a rotten center and I got little good lumber from it. Next I purchased two huge black gum logs to be sawed. Looked like beautiful lumber but it warped so much that it lifted the walnut stacked on top of it. Turned out to be useless lumber. A lesson learned.
The market for ash tanked and I bought a partial truck load. Sold some and used the last of it recently, many years later. Bought half of a huge cherry tree (1300 bdft). turned out outstanding. Kicked myself for not buying it all.
All this and some more led us to buy out a lumber yard and that's how we got into the lumber business.
In the end I have concluded that buying good lumber is a good investment. The gum and the veneer log are the only lumber we ever lost money on. Just start small until you learn how to recognize good lumber.
That said, we have sold lumber that I'll bet the buyer came to wish they didn't own. We had a source of #3 common KD and steamed walnut cheap. We sold thousands of bdft of it in 500 bdft packs for $1/bdft. I expect many bought it because it seemed cheap(speculators). This example provides an important lesson. If you are buying something that you don't know much about, deals too good to be true may not be such a good deal after all.
Understanding Wood? It has a lot of good information on how to recognize defects. Knots are obvious, Cup and bow, can be dealt with, but can indicate propensity to change shape after cutting. A band of large splinters and or a yellowish orange streak, along with wider annual rings, will likely be reaction wood, which should be cut into firewood, even though it looks clear.
Look at the end of the lumber, if the annual rings are flatter, from farther out from the pith is good, while small arcs of the rings means juvenile wood, which can lead to problems.
Twisted boards may indicate that the tree had a spiraling twist in the trunk. This may look like straight grain on the face, but on the edge, you may find that there is grain runout from one face, then out the other 8" or whatever on the other side. This can lead to problems with breakage later on, where strength is needed. This is hard to see in even textured woods like maple.
I could go on, but I don't have time to write a book just now, but you can find it all in the one I mentioned above. Judging from your question, If you only ever bought one book on woodworking, this should be your first. There is information that you can easily use now, then some you will look back to understand 20 years from now. It will also pay for itself, by preventing you from buying lumber that you should not have wasted your money on.
While the characteristics described are certainly real, they are rare in hardwood lumber. I have never worried about them when buying a stack of lumber. They are too hard to detect in a stack of lumber so in most cases one can't worry about them.
More probable problems:
Is it stacked well? If the lumber got stacked with a bow in the pile every board in the pile will be bowed and you can forget getting lumber straight enough for a table from it. I find it rare that a small mill stacks lumber well. If the lumber is going to be KD, the stacking is not so much a problem for the heat and moisture of the kiln will straighten it, if it gets restacked well in the kiln.
In the case of ash and maple, did it get put up on sticks quickly with good air circulation? If sawed in the summer and dead packed for any length of time the soft maple will be stained, and likely the ash too. Were the sticks dry? If not, there will be sticker stain.
Is the pile covered? Rain can percolate a pile and initiate mold deep within. Sun can severely check where ever it hits. Oak stacked in the direct summer heat will check, case harden and maybe even honeycomb.
Is it sawed well? Small mills are noted for sawing lumber undersized, tapered, oversized lumber(more a problem if kiln drying). Poorly sawed lumber doesn't stack well which leads to bowed lumber piles.
If the lumber has darkened from weather exposure you will not be able to see many kinds of defects that will become apparent when it is planed. This darkening can be only "skin deep" and will plane away.
A stack of log run narrow boards (8" and less) means the lumber was sawed from small trees. It will likely be low grade.
The most important thing to know is why does the mill have these piles of lumber for sale? Is the lumber low grade lumber for sale to farmers to be used for farm construction projects(common around here). At the other extreme, the mill keeps some good lumber on hand to sell to woodworkers(very rare). Does the mill have a clue what quality of wood is required to build furniture? Does the mill know how to grade lumber and know the grade that is in the pile?
Hey Bill, I don't follow what the "high nails" means? While I agree with what you were driving at when choosing whole stacks, I didn't think that was what Kevin was asking about. He stated" looking to gather in more info on working with local hardwoods -- picking from a stack, knowing what to look for, etc".
And I would bet that most of the readers on this forum pick from their suppliers stacks, if they allow it. I know I certainly do. Being a custom maker, I hardly ever buy whole packs, because almost every job is from a different wood, and even in a shop as large as mine, I don't want to fill it up with stored lumber.
I gathered that Kevin was probably buying from someone with a small band mill. Having one myself, I often am offered free urban trees, which I often take. The things that I very briefly mentioned that you dismissed as "rare in hardwood lumber" are a lot more common than you think.
Even when buying exotics from my larger suppliers, I see and choose excluding the lumber with those traits mentioned in my earlier post.
Kevin, one little tip that may be useful to you, is to take a block plane with you when you go back to the mill. Sometimes just taking a couple of quick strokes down on the end will give you a good idea what is under all that damaged cells from the saw cut.
Not sure where this expression came from, maybe nautical and referring to deck nails. It refers to looking for the few nails among the many that stick up and need to be dealt with , ie what is most important.
Appearance and structural defects like knots, rot, wane, stain and worm holes as well as drying issues like case hardening, checks, cup, twist, and bow are going to be "higher nails" on my list than rare growth issues of reaction wood etc. which are going to be nearly impossible to distinguish in a weathered pile.
My biggest concerns would be stain on the maple and ash and the results of a 100 degree sunny day in Kansas on fresh sawed oak , after I got by generally looking at the stack to asses what sort of logs it came from and how it was dried..
Some of the best sawed lumber I have bought came from a well run WoodMiser mill. These mills can be accurate and leave a smooth surface that can in cases be cleaned up with a 1/16" planer pass. That said, few that own these mills know how to saw, and dry, lumber for fine woodworking.
Eastern KS produces some dandy walnut. Top grade should be about $2.50 at mill green, about $1 for #2 common. KD about $0.75 higher. Walnut logs vary widely in grade so hard to say what log run lumber would be worth. I pay about $2 for top grade saw logs here. Veneer logs can be much higher.
Unlike oak, walnut is easy to dry. If you get it under a roof where the heat accumulates in the summer the hot KS sun will leave it KD by next fall.
"Would those grades also apply to oak, ash, etc?" Not sure of the question.
If you are asking whether there are grade standards for other species the answer is yes. The price differential between top grade and lesser grades is typically greater for common species where the supply of top grade lumber is greater.
You may be interested in an Article I have in the Articles section titled "Where hardwood lumber comes from".
A common problem with small band mills is that their owner does not know how to tease the best lumber from a log by properly orienting the log on the carriage to begin with and turning the cant as it is sawed to concentrate defects in some boards and clear lumber in others. This turning is efficient on a circle saw mill and carriage, and much less so on a small band mill. Hence, their "log run" lumber is lower grade(less clear) than it could be. But the "proof is in the pudding". If the sawed lumber looks good buy some and learn from the experience.
The two most useful pieces of advice I can offer are- if the lumber is all narrow it likely came from small logs. Avoid it. And, the only people that work air dried lumber are those than don't have a handy means of reliably drying it. Take with a grain of salt the rationalizations of why air dried is "better".
As hot and dry as it gets in KS you can rig even a crude solar kiln which could be as simple as the loft of a barn or garage and dry lumber to less than 10% moisture content in the summer months. Then it will be ready to do what ever you want to do with it, whenever you need some. (If you have a heated unhumidified space in the winter lumber will dry to less than 10% MC also.