Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

track saw questions

Posts

track saw questions

#1

track saw questions

Jerry Gibbs

My friend has a Festool track saw and swears by it. He has other good equipment, for example a SawStop with sliding table. He makes finished cuts on sheet goods with the track saw and says it is his tool of choice for sheet goods if he had unlimited options. I am interested primarily because I can no longer throw around 4 x 8 sheets of 3/4 ply etc. I also have trouble holding rough cut bigger pieces of ply against the table saw fence to make a good finished cut.

Now that there are other options besides Festool, I have some questions. Has anybody seen a good review of the options- Grizzly, Dewalt etc? The other is do I need a track saw? Can I make finish cuts on sheet goods with a circular saw and straight edge? Thanks, Jerry

Re: track saw questions

#2

Re: track saw questions

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hi Gerry,

Seen the Festool demoed several times; very nice for sheet material.

For long rips I get results just as good with an 8+' straight edge and one of my circ's.

For long (4') cross cuts I can do as well provided I remember to change the blade to a fine plywood blade.

That said, I don't do enough with sheet material to justify the cost of the Festool (or a panel saw either), but if I did, I would certainly consider the investment.

Re: track saw questions

#3

payback

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When faced with a decision like yours I consider what something costs and how often I will use it. If you work a lot of sheet goods and have a woodworking budget similar to your friends the purchase of a handy means of breaking down sheet goods seems a practical choice. In my case I am not faced with the task of reducing a 4 x 8 sheet of something into pieces more than a very few times a year. I usually attack the sheet with a skill saw to make slightly over sized pieces ( I am not skilled with a skill saw) and then do finish cuts on them with the table saw, if a more refined cut is required. I find that a level clamped to a sheet of something makes a dandy straight edge for the skill saw. The task usually requires a helper to catch the cut-off.

A finish cut requites a proper blade whether the skill saw is used, or a track saw kind of device, or the table saw for that matter. One should not compare a skill saw with a dull framing blade to the more refined alternatives.

Re: track saw questions

#4

A.J. Hamler

Re: track saw questions

A.J. Hamler

As far as accuracy is concerned, Mark is right -- you can do the same thing with a straightedge. However, track saws have a number of benefits.

Because of the way the tracks are designed, you actually create the straightedge on your first cut, meaning that the track is always exactly on your cut line. This means total accuracy in setup, and the track minimizes or even eliminates splintering. Running the saw on the track is like sliding on butter-- very low friction. You also don't have to hold the saw against a straightedge, as it rides the track with no veering to the left of right. Depending on the smoothness of the surface of the material you're cutting, you often don't even need to clamp it down. Some track saws even include an adjustment with a detent for a scoring cut.

Well worth it for sheet goods.

A.J.

Re: track saw questions

#5

Re: track saw questions

Barry Irby

I don't have any of them and have never seen any of them, so I may not be the best person to answer your question. I did not sleep in a Holiday Inn last night but I did go over to You Tube and Amazon and look at the Festool a bit. (I suggest you do that too and spend more than the twenty minutes I spent. Read the product reviews on Amazon, specially the lower rated ones.)

I struggle with the same question you have. My shoulders are beginning to complain about the large sheets and more tot he point, I have a tiny shop. Its a one car garage, so putting a sheet of plywood through the table saw is a logistics nightmare. I have to move everything one way and then the other and literally open the garage door and let the sheet run out into the driveway. If I had space I might have bought a panel saw, but I don't even have space for Festool Tractsaw. I would still have to bring the sheet in, figure out where to lay it out, move everything that was in the way, set up the saw with the duct collector and THEN figure out how to break down the sheet.

So, the question to you is does the Any track saw really help you? Does it eliminate enough of the sheet handling to make it worth while? Perhaps you have enough room to bring your truck (?) close, slide the sheets out the back onto saw horses (?), break them down and then move the pieces further into the shop?

I have been solving this problem by have then "bust 'em down" at the home center on their panel saw. I use a skilsaw on them and on occasion, I use a straight edge along with the skilsaw.

Two things that bothered me about the Festool (beyond the price) were that there were complaints about the smaller version being under powered and it came with a 55" track. You would have to by a second section to get enough to rip a sheet of plywood. The larger version came with a 75" track but would be heavier. This is based on ten minutes on Amazon. Perhaps there are sets available that would include two 55" tracks and the splicer piece.

What I would do is make two straight edges for my skilsaw. One about 55" and one about twice that. The base would be a piece of plywood and the straight edge a nice piece of hardwood attached to it. Then you just run your saw done it and saw off the protruding plywood parallel tot he straight edge. That shows you where the cut is and makes it easy to line up and helps with splintering. Having two takes out the fiddle factor of having to switch back and forth.

I would also look at setting these up for a router. (I did and I like it.) Wish some friend of mine had the Festool setup so I could go play with it and see how bad off I am.

Re: track saw questions

#6

Re: track saw questions

John in NM

The thing I like best about a track saw is that you mark your sheet, put the track up to the mark and cut it. All you have to keep straight is which side of the mark you want to cut on. Before I had a track saw, I used to have to do this by marking the sheet, subtracting the width of the saw base, and then marking where the guide went. I seem to remember that the saw base wasn't a nice roundish measurement either.

The few times I bought MDF for making some bending forms, I was definitely glad to have the track saw. Put saw horses in the driveway and cut the sheets down right behind the truck :D

Can't help you much with brands, I've only used the Festool.

I typically make two cuts to rip a 8' sheet, it's not hard to line up with the stopped cut once you've moved the track. If I were doing it daily I'd get a longer rail. A friend of mine tried the rail joining thingy and didn't like it.

Re: track saw questions

#7

Re: track saw questions *LINK*

Keith Newton

Here is a link to the Griz by a Festool owner that you should watch. I think he does a fair review. The only two things that left me wondering about, was that I could not hear the vacuum running when he was making the cut, which might explain why the chips were ejected out from the center of the blade, rather than picked up out the vac hose.

Also, the splintering, is more likely from the cheap blade choice, maybe not set parallel to the track edge. Not being there in the shop beside him, to check the setup out, only makes my critique speculation.

One thing that has me wondering about the Festool, is how many amps do you need to for the power supply. I'm betting the combination of saw and vacuum would throw a 15 amp breaker, and wondering if even a 20 amp is big enough?

Back to you and your shop, I'm wondering if woodworking was ever your profession, or something you picked up after retiring? In my shop, where I have used helpers over the last 40 years, it sometimes is harder to untrain older workers of their bad habits than it is to train a good young beginner on the TS.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PcfiKe1PkXU

Re: track saw questions

#8

Re: track saw questions

AZ in Colorado Springs

I made a pair of guides as Barry described for my Skilsaw. One is 8' long and one is 5' long (an 8' guide is too long for crosscutting a sheet of plywood or ripping shorter pieces -- you then must support the guide, as well as the work piece).

After making the first cut, the edge of the guide is right where the blade will be, so setting it up for a cut is a breeze.

Be sure that the base piece is wide enough that you have a place for clamping. So you start with a piece of plywood maybe 12" or 15" wide, attach a 1x4 straightedge about 3" from one edge, then run your circ saw on the wide side to finish building the guide. That 3" space allows you someplace to put a clamp and not interfere with the movement of the circ saw.

Re: track saw questions

#9

Re: track saw questions

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

I have a guide fence I made by gluing a 1x3 to a scrap of 1/4" plywood and then cutting the plywood with my circular saw riding against the 1x3. Now I just line the plywood edge up with the mark I want to cut to and clamp the 1x3 to the work. Accuracy I'd spot on, quality of cut suffers because i'm using a cheap fast cutting blade.

Robin

Re: track saw questions

#10

Well that is a clever solution`

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I see an application for router fences too.

Re: track saw questions

#11

Re: track saw questions

Keith Newton

Robin, I have done this before too, but what I do mostly, is just to mark a line down the middle of the sheet, then just freehand it. But then, I think I am better than most with a circular saw. In good light and body position, I can leave half of a fine pencil line, which doesn't require much to clean up with a block plane.

However, almost all of the time, my cabinet parts will be cut to 23.5" for the finished part size, which would allow for even a sloppy first cut. Then I can go to the TS, still using the factory edge to the fence, would normally saw to 23.75, then turn it around and rip to the finished size. I try to not use the factory edge, not just because it would likely have damage, but because the sanding of the face, usually leaves a little thinner veneer, due to bending of the platen from pressure outside of the edge.

If a craftsman can't get a good cut from their TS after roughly busting the parts down, or having too little room in the shop, then I would think it is time for the track saw.

Re: track saw questions

#12

track saw questions - another option

Mike Johnson

I have used the EZ track saw system for several years and really love it. I have no interest in the company, but this has been tool that has done what it promised. Here's one link to information about it: http://www.amazon.com/Tracksaw-System-108-SMARTBASE-eurekazone/dp/B0099PP05M.

The table that is offered as part of the system works great and stores flat between uses. It's worth the extra money.

Re: track saw questions

#13

the 1x3 has to be dead straight

Dick Coers

I usually rip a piece of 3/4 ply for the guide. It is not as susceptible to moisture changes and stays straighter. I've made jigs like that for sawing, routing, and made a similar T-square fixture for the biscuit joiner.

Re: track saw questions

#14

Re: track saw questions

BilWil

I have had 3 track saws. They get damaged if you use them on a job site and aren't the only one using it. I now have the Mafell and will buy another if this one is damaged. It is less subject to damage and is easier to use.

Re: track saw questions

#15

Re: track saw questions

don stephan

There may be additional features of the Festool saw that would help justify the cost. I love the ability to make a smooth, plumb and safe plunge cut when needed, the saw and track can cut a stack of veneer extremely clean, and the saw depth is very easy to set, for added safety.

Re: track saw questions

#16

Some data

Jesse Cloud

First, some data to clarify some of the above points....

Festool track saw have a wide variety of blades available, fine crosscut, rip, metal cutting, laminate cutting, etc.

Festool sells two tracks saws: the TS55 with a 55 cm cutting depth and the TS 75 with a 75 mm cutting depth. As would be expected the 75 is more powerful and heaver. Personally, I find the 55 works fine up to about 8/4 hardwood, then the 75 is needed. Personally, I would feel safer breaking down anything thicker than 8/4 on a bandsaw rather than a track saw.

The TS 55 comes with a track that is about 55 inches long, you can upgrade to longer tracks for the difference between the two tracks' cost. Over the years, I have accumulated a number of different sizes.

On the issue of amperage, I run the TS55 and the vacuum plugged into a single 15 amp 120v receptacle and have never tripped a breaker. I also run much higher amperage routers in the same situation with no problem.

Now some personal experience... like Barry, I am a bit too old to be slinging around sheet goods. Maybe unlike Barry, most of the places I buy sheet goods seldom have a working panel saw. So I bought the Festool to break down sheet goods. I set up sawhorses in the driveway in front of the garage/shop, back up the pickup (loaded with sheet goods) and simply slide the sheet onto the horses, then cut to order with the track saw. I quickly found that I can easily get precise cuts on the sawhorses and there is no need for further refinement on the table saw. I often think about selling my table saw, but there is one application where it beats the track saw - making the same cut a few dozen times. But I don't have a production shop so that is not a big attraction.

The other big advantage to the Festool track saw is that it really does collect dust. The straw that broke my camels back was one time when I had to break down several sheets of mdf with a circular saw. It was not pretty or healthy and I had to spend a long time cleaning up the shop. After I got the TS55, I cut a similar number of mdf sheets and had about 3 tablespoons of dust on the floor.

I do a lot of veneer work. The track saw is a no brainer for veneer work. With the right blade, you can cut a stack of veneer so smooth no jointing is needed. If you do veneer work, you know we are talking about a huge time saving there.

The Wood Whisperer has a pretty good video comparing the Festool and the Grizzly track saws. He found the Festool better, but the Grizzly was cheaper and might be good enough for some users, especially if you intend to refine the cuts later on a table saw.