Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

danish oil question

Posts

danish oil question

#1

danish oil question

Rick Snyder

Hello,

this is a followup to Don Stephan's questions about danish oil. Can danish oil be applied to stained wood, as I stain most of the pieces I make or refinish. The pieces I refinish for people are always in real bad shape overall.

Thanks,

Rick

Re: danish oil question

#2

what is danish oil ?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...and how is it different from "wiping varnish"? I always thought they were one in the same?

Re: danish oil question

#3

Re: what is danish oil ?

don stephan

Sorry I didn't make clear in my question, my understanding is that the difference between wiping varnish and danish oil is that danish oil also contains boiled linseed oil, in addition to the thinner and varnish in wiping varnish.

Re: danish oil question

#4

Re: danish oil question

don stephan

Prior to my gremlin this fall I would have automatically said no problem putting danish oil over stains. I thought the same would be true of penetrating waterborne dyes, but found out different. You might query the maker of your stains and/or conduct some tests.

Re: danish oil question

#5

Time for a reappearance of M. Dresdner....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....to add some authority to this topic.

I expect that there are many formulations that get called Danish Oil and Wiping Varnish. I have heard mixtures of varnish and thinner called wiping varnish as well as mixtures of oil, varnish and thinner. I don't know what Dansih Oil is but I'll bet a company formulated product labeled Danish Oil is not the simple mixture described. (The simple mixture described might replicate it properties)

I think I recall M.D. interjecting that company formulated products called wiping varnish are not simple mixtures of other finishing products that can be replicated in the shop either. Mr. Flexner would probably tell us that neither name means much in the context of what chemicals are in the can.

Re: danish oil question

#6

Re: what is danish oil ?

John Pappas

Bob Flexner: "oil/varnish mixture is often sold as Danish oil".

page 56, Understanding Wood Finishing

Re: danish oil question

#7

Re: what is danish oil ?

Howard Acheson

"Danish Oil" had it's genesis in the product marketed by Watco as Danish Oil. It was marketed as a finish similar to that used on 1960's Scandinavian furniture. It was formulated as a linseed oil and a resin thinned for ease of application. Finisher's quickly became enamored with the finish because of its ease of application and consistent results. Finishers found that a mixture of equal parts of linseed oil, varnish and mineral spirits would duplicate the the finish the performance of the Watco product. It's a wipe-on, wipe-off product.

Wiping varnish is a generic name for a thinned varnish. While some over the counter products contain a smidgen of other chemicals, a 50/50 mixture of oil based varnish and mineral spirits produces an easy to apply wiping varnish. It's wiped on and NOT wiped off product.

Re: danish oil question

#8

Re: danish oil question

Howard Acheson

>>>> Can danish oil be applied to stained wood, as I stain most of the pieces I make or refinish.

What kind of stain are you referring to? Is it a pigment oil based stain like Minwax Wood Finish or are you referring to an oil, water, or alcohol dye stain?

In general you can apply a danish oil over any stain. There are some caveats when applying it over an oil based pigment stain.

Re: danish oil question

#9

Re: danish oil question reply to Howard A.

Rick Snyder

I use General finishes reg.oil base, gel type, and dye stains . I have used GF reg. water base stains before.

What are the caveats regarding stained wood?

Rick

Re: danish oil question

#10

My experience is...

David Yoho

I have used both a wiping varnish and a Danish oil (Watco) in the past over waterborne (Lockwood) dye without a problem.

I'm not sure how Watco would do over a pigmented stain such as Minwax because Minwax stain also seals the wood surface to a small degree. I would be concerned about the oil penetration and it not sitting on the surface.

Re: danish oil question

#11

Re: danish oil question

Brian Greene

The answer is yes you can apply Danish oil over stain. I make my own and use either linseed oil or tung oil depending on my requirements. Commercial versions or wiping varnishes are also ok. You should expect a little less penetration. Also, because of the problem of like chemicals bleeding, I have used a wash coat of shellac as a barrier with great success. This will further reduce penetration. Shellac also allows mixing water based and oil based products without adhesion problems. Good luck. Brian Greene in Ottawa.

Re: danish oil question

#12

Re: danish oil question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It's been my understanding that traditional varnishes contain a drying oil - linseed, tung, etc. - and that it's the proportion of oil to resin that determines whether a finish would be considered Danish oil or just plain varnish. One of the finishing authorities (can't recall whether Dresdner or Flexner), in one of his articles on the subject, called Danish oil and related finishes "long oil varnishes," meaning much more oil than in regular varnish.

But this is what I've been told, not what I know from my own chemical analysis of the finishes - a good thing, since I'm neither competent nor equipped to do such an analysis.

As to applying it over a stain - I thought most any stain will accept an oil-based finish once it has cured, with the one worry being whether there's silicone involved.

Re: danish oil question

#13

Re: danish oil question

Sgian Dubh

Don, my understanding is that Danish oil, and their derivatives such as teak oil are essentially a form of varnish made of pretty much the same stuff, i.e., boiled linseed oil (and/or perhaps tung oil) a resin of some sort and white (mineral) spirits: there may be some other ingredients as hinted at by this link to Rustins Danish oil, e.g., driers of one sort or another: http://www.rustins.eu/ProdData/Danish%20Oil%20PDS.pdf

As to applying wiping finishes over dye or stain, or for that matter a brushed on finish or something French polished, the biggest problem seems to be getting the first coat on without lifting the underlying colouring material. There does quite often seem to be a tendency for the finish product going over the top of the dye and/or stain to cause the colourant to redissolve somewhat, mix in with the finish and then get spread around, sometimes leading to patchiness.

I think there are two things going on. Either the dye or stain hasn't dried fully, or it's built up a bit of thickness on top of the wood because it's perhaps not been wiped off after application. Letting the dye or stain dry fully and then wiping over with a clean dry rag prior to polishing will sometimes cause the rag to pick up dry colourant causing it to change colour.

The second thing that seems to happen sometimes is that there is too much working of the applied finish over the colourant, especially on the first coat. If the first coat, of whatever the hand applied finish is, is got on quickly without too much wiping, working it around or brushing this seems to be a positive, because once this first coat is on and has sealed the surface, then subsequent applications generally go okay.

I don't think any of the above provide definitive solutions to the dye or grain lifting problem people experience from time to time, but experimenting a bit along the lines suggested might help. Slainte.

Re: danish oil question

#14

Ellis Walentine

Major difference

Ellis Walentine

Danish oil must be wiped off after it has soaked in; wiping varnish is left on the surface to dry. This is because of the unreacted long oil(s) in the Danish oil finish. Wiping varnish dries to a film; Danish oil dries in the wood, not on it, so it doesn't build to the level of protection that a wiping varnish (or other film finish) does, particularly resistance to water and abrasion. It sure looks nice though and it couldn't be easier to apply, but it is a terrible value, as it has a very high percentage of thinner in it and you end up wiping most of it off.

Ellis

Re: danish oil question

#15

Ellis Walentine

Mike will be here on January 9

Ellis Walentine

As many of you know, I was Michael Dresdner's editor for several years and we have remained friends. He used to host a Sunday night finishing chat on our AOL channel and later here on WoodCentral.

I have invited Michael to host a chat here in our WoodCentral Chat Room on January 9, and he has graciously accepted my invitation. I will be posting an announcement soon. Meanwhile, start saving up your finishing questions, and mark your calendars.

Ellis

Re: danish oil question

#16

Re: danish oil question

Howard Acheson

In a thumbnail description, varnish is made by mixing a drying oil with a resin and then heating them together until they combine and form a new compound called varnish. A thinner is then added to make the product more brush able.

Varnish manufacturers will vary the amount of oil and resin to customize the resulting varnish. A higher proportion of resin to oil will make for a harder varnish. Increasing the amount of oil in the mixture will result in a more flexible, softer varnish. Varnishes made with a higher percentage of oil are called "long oil varnishes". Spar varnishes are long oil varnishes so they can flex with the changes in temperatures and moisture content of the wood. The finish will remain adhered as the wood underneath expands and contracts. Adding more oil to the original mixture after is has become varnish does not fit the normal description of a "long oil varnish".

Finally, a "wiping varnish" is nothing more than a standard varnish that has been thinned by the addition of a thinner. A 50/50 mixture is the most common ratio but it can vary depending on what the finisher wants to accomplish. The thing to keep in mind that thinning the varnish does not change the components of the varnish. It's just thinner and will take more applications to obtain a similar film thickness. Wiping varnish is wiped on and NOT wiped off.

Re: danish oil question

#18

I would only accept the advice of the manufacturer

Dick Coers

And the results of a test piece. I can't stress the test piece enough. Many times, woodworking that has taken months to do, is messed up when the craftsman slathers on some combination of finishes from several manufacturers. Finish advice given on an internet forum is no more accurate than legal advice from the same place.

Re: danish oil question

#19

There are exceptions, one is particularly relevant

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Manufacturer recommendations will be limited by laws and liability fears..

Many solvent based finishes have directions to not thin. This instruction has nothing to do with application or performance and everything to do with VOC regulations(like varnish contributes any meaningful VOC). To meet VOC these products are formulated with less solvent than in days past. Without thinning or heating I can't get modern oil based paint and varnish to perfectly level and/or release bubbles.

As an example, there have been many posts on Forums about the issue of bubbles not releasing from urethane floor varnish. Thin it some and the bubbles release and the varnish levels glass smooth.

Re: danish oil question

#20

(like varnish contributes any meaningful VOC

Barry Irby

This has nothing to do with the topic other than a bit of perspective. I was listening to a show on NPR about Ethanol and other fuel substitutes and additives. (My listening was disjointed because I had to keep getting out of the car, once to put Ethanol in the tank.) The discussion was wide ranging and included college professors with titles or job descriptions that included the word Biofuel. (Couldn't possibly be an agenda there) If I understood what I heard, we (this country) produce something like a billion and a half gallons of Ethanol. I know its not the same thing as the thinner you might add to your finish. Not even sure Ethanol is a VOC, but somehow it makes thinning your finish in significant.

What the heck, You are going to inhale most of the fumes anyway. Then emit a few VOC's of your own.

(Back to the show, one odd factoid that came out of it was that if every car in the country got 1 more MPG it would offset the need for all the Ethanol.)

Re: danish oil question

#21

the morphing of ethanol

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When it began ethanol was a means of getting an oxygen containing molecule into gasoline which was required to modify combustion in the cylinders in some way I don't understand. (might have something to do with taking lead out). Then when it looked like we might run out of oil someone thought it was a good plan to use ethanol from corn as a bridge to more sustainable "biofuels". (the flaw in that plan that nobody addresses will be explained later). In the mean time farms and businesses spent billions to double capacity to grow the corn crop and the factories to convert it to fuel. In the mean time the environmentally motivated people have come to see that burning food is not such a good idea. However, a powerful lobby of corn farmers and ethanol fermenters is sustaining an ethanol fuel economy that makes little environmental or business sense. These people are going to do all they can to protect their billions of dollars of investment. Nobody is going to win the critical Iowa presidential primary unless they support corn to ethanol.

The flaw in other biofuels, presuming the science and engineering can be overcome and so far it has not, is that the farm or forest soil is not going to be happy at removing this waste and its nutrients permanently from the land. It is important when harvesting corn to let all the nutrients bound in the stalk return to the soil. Ditto for the popular case of switch grass. The bottom line is that you can not take from the land for ever and not give nutrients back either in the form of crop waste or fertilizer.

Re: danish oil question

#22

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Ethanol = higher octane

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Lead was originally used, ostensibly, to boost the octane rating (of course a company whose name rhymes with dew font may have unduly influenced lead's addition to the fuel supply since they were the holder of the patent on the lead compound used, or something like that).

Octane rating is simply a relative number to quantify the resistance to pre-ignition in the cylinder of the engine. With gasoline, you want the spark plug to ignite the air-fuel mixture, not the compression of the piston. Too low of an octane rating, and the pre-ignition will generate too much force on the piston surface (explosion while the piston is on the upstroke), resulting in damage. Ethanol helps raise the octane rating, but, like anything, introduces its own set of problems.

Ethanol also has that oxygen atom in it, so it's considered an oxygenate, and has been largely used to replace MTBE, which is considered too harmful. Both reduce the production of certain particularly nasty pollutants from internal combustion engines.

Jason

Re: danish oil question

#23

Re: Major difference

Howard Acheson

Yes Ellis, I had meant to include in my response that a "danish oil" is a penetrating finish and requires a thorough wiping after it has sat on the surface for 15-20 minutes. I noticed that omission when I re-read my post later. Unless I've missed something in the years I have worked this forum, there is no way to add or correct a posted message. By the time I noticed the omission, I felt that a new post would just add confusion rather than enlightenment.

Bottom line, a "thinned wiping varnish" is one that is wiped on and then allowed to dry. No wiping off after application. It is a film finish. An oil/varnish mixture "danish oil" is a wipe-on wipe-off application product intended to somewhat penetrate the surface of the wood. It leaves the look and feel of the natural wood without the build of a film finish like a wiping varnish.

BTW, what do I need to to to be a participant in the on-line discussion with Michael?

Re: danish oil question

#24

Re: danish oil question reply to Howard A.

Howard Acheson

Sorry Rick, I've been traveling for the past couple of days and I'm just catching up.

>>>> What are the caveats regarding stained wood?

Oil based and some water based pigment stains contain a resin which, when it dries adheres the pigment to the wood. It in effect seals the surface of the wood. Its the reason that Minwax Wood Finish claims that their product "seals" the wood. In most cases a single applcation followed by a wipe-off of all the excess stain will penetrate the surface of the stain and color the wood. Therefore the caveat is that one should only apply a single coat of stain and that the excess stain should be thorough wipe off after setting on the wood surface for 15-20 minuted. If the excess is not wiped off, the stain will not dry properly and any clear coat may not dry properly either.

Re: danish oil question

#25

Ellis Walentine

Editing and chatting

Ellis walentine

Hi Howard,

Registered users may edit posts within the first two hours after posting. You can delete your posts at any time. The selector for edit/delete is at the bottom of each of your posts.

To join the chat room, just click the chat room link in the red navigation panel and follow the bread crumbs. You will need the current version of Java, so if you hit a snag, you probably need to update your Java.

Email me any time you need help with any of this.

Ellis