Wiping Varnish vs Danish Oil
don stephan
Recent gremlin led me to look through info on danish oil and wiping varnish to determine how they are alike and dissimilar.
I am applying them using a squeeze bottle of the finish and a clean piece of cotton rag. I'll wipe a wet coat over the entire surface, and immediately repeat. After 5-10 minutes I'll apply another double coat. If the applied finish is not already sticky I'll apply a third double coat, hoping to fully saturate all areas of the wood. 5-10 minutes after the last double coat I'll scrub dry with a clean paper towel, and repeat in another 5-10 minutes. If an open grain wood like oak or ash, or small cracks, I'll continue scrubbing dry any shiny spots where the finish is bleeding back out onto the surface. Even when using naptha, I allow 48 hours for the first coat to cure, and at least 24 hours for the second and third coats.
First, I learned that mineral spirits is not the only solvent than can be used for them. Substituting naptha for mineral spirits seems to reduce the working time and curing time. It could be very helpful to have some control especially over working time before either finish starts to become sticky.
I also learned that the ratio of ingredients in danish oil does not have to be equal thirds solvent, boiled linseed oil (BLO) and varnish. One of Jeff Jewitt's books published by Taunton suggests one part BLO, four parts varnish and four parts solvent. I have not been able to see any difference in appearance after one coat of either formula (using the same alkyd varnish), and after three coats only that the latter formula with less BLO seems to develop more sheen (again with the same alkyd varnish). There is not a noticeable difference in any film buildup. It is expected that the latter formula also will yield a harder finish.
Due to an unexpected dye migrating through three coats of (equal parts) danish oil, I've tried a wiping varnish using equal parts naptha and alkyd varnish. It took six or seven wiped coats to finally lock in the dye, and while the surface now has a higher sheen and slightly more film-like feel it isn't yet as thick as a 3 coat sprayed finish.
If wiping a finish onto a larger piece such as a blanket chest, I'd want to use a slower curing finish certainly for the first coat, perhaps 1:4:4 BLO:varnish:mineral spirits or even 1:1:1 of the same ingredients. For the following coats I'd probably stay with a danish oil formulation for greater working time. On perhaps the base of a hall table I'd try a faster curing danish oil formulation for all three coats, and for the top wiping varnish using mineral spirits instead of naptha for more working time.
I'm not opposed to a sprayed film finish - no question it is more efficient - but it does not have the same tactile sensation of danish oil or wiping varnish.
What other aspects of danish oil and wiping varnish oil am I yet to learn? Thanks for sharing.



