Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT Vinyl plank flooring questions

Posts

OT Vinyl plank flooring questions

#1

OT Vinyl plank flooring questions

Barry Irby

I have several rental houses and the tenants are often destructive to the carpet. A friend told me that his buddy used vinyl throughout his rentals and let the tenants provide their own area rugs. I have always treated carpet as a disposable but bought more expensive vinyl. Carpet is easy to replace but sheet vinyl not so much.

Been looking at the "vinyl plank flooring". There seems to be three or four variations. Some are very similar to the old block tile but the "blocks" are now rectangles. Some are rectangles about 6" by 36" with a lap joint edge and you pull paper off the lap and stick them together. The flooring is not adhered to the floor. There is another version that appears to be slightly thicker with but edges and it just loose lays in place.

I like the idea of the one that sticks the pieces together, but is not glued to the floor. It seems like it might be possible to replace individual (damaged) pieces.

I am very skeptical of the one that is completely loose laid. I can not imagine that it would hold up in a rental situation. I assume they would kick it out of place and at the very least get crude between and under them.

Does anyone have any experience with any of these?

Re: OT Vinyl plank flooring questions

#2

Re: OT Vinyl plank flooring questions

Keith Newton

Barry, I have only used the vinyl planks with the snap edge and ends in the bath of the cabin I helping my cousin with. As for as the product, I think it is good, and will last, but if you need to repair one out in the middle, that would be a real pain. You would have to take it back apart plank by plank until you got back where you needed. No way to just take one out in the middle.

Have you looked at the carpet squares? We put that down out in the Sun-room of our cabin. The rambunctious kids can get them to slip a little, but you could lock them down a little with some two-sided carpet tape, or spots of adhesive.

Re: OT Vinyl plank flooring questions

#3

JL

Re: OT Vinyl plank flooring questions

JL

We put the vinyl plank flooring in the lobby of the Playhouse - IMO, it was a big mistake. It scratches and you see the scratches in oblique lights. In a rental house w/ tenants and moving furniture - I just don't know. Yes - it is relatively easy to peel it up and replace - but you still have the question - where do you store the unused planks.

I like the color - I just don't like the scratches. I would consider something else.

Re: OT Vinyl plank flooring questions

#4

Re: OT Vinyl plank flooring questions

paul in AZ

I put vinyl planks in a summer cottage sunroom.

There is vinyl plank flooring and vinyl plank flooring. There ARE big differences brand to brand.

The click-together type is not always as easy to put together without gaps or tents as the brochures say.

When floated it will wear well but will never sound or feel as good as real wood.

Before buying one I used a torture test. Pounded with a hammer; scratched with a screw driver and most importantly immersed the sample in water overnight. Most brands are really tough.

One to avoid was the current US manufactured Pergo. This swelled and delaminated in water. A friend had a kitchen floor ruined when the dishwasher ran over. They may have improved.

Re: OT Vinyl plank flooring questions

#5

Re: OT Vinyl plank flooring questions

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"...and at the very least get crude between and under them..."

Hey, as long as they're consenting adults, what's the issue?

Oh, I bet you meant crud.

Not sure what the current vinyl plank is like. Our son laid some for us in our back entryway, and the sun has caused the planks to shrink, leaving gaps between; of course, he was maybe 18 or 19 at the time he did it, and he's 37 now, so maybe that's not too bad.