Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Wood Filler Question

Posts

Wood Filler Question

#1

Wood Filler Question

Paul Woolson

Hello all. I'm looking for a wood filler (for voids/knots/cracks) that will accept oil as a finish. I need it to be hard as this is for a walnut floor. We want a "lived in" look so we're hoping to just oil it.

Any thoughts? Thanks, Paul

Re: Wood Filler Question

#2

JL

Re: Wood Filler Question

JL

Many of your wood filler will take an oil finish - but you would have to test to see what was acceptable to you.

Minwax woodfiller has worked for me. PC-Woody wood epoxy paste has also worked.

I have made my own "blend" of sawdust and 2 part epoxy and that has worked reasonably well - you can notice the knot or void.

It all depends on if you want to disguise the knot or void or highlight it.

Re: Wood Filler Question

#3

Re: Wood Filler Question

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Another option just occurred to me. When I helped my son trim out his house (interior) a few years ago, we used White oak with shellac finish. We had a few knots missing in otherwise beautiful boards. On one trim piece, I filled the missing knot hole with 2 part epoxy - prior to filling, I stained the underlying wood with India Ink and left the epoxy clear. After sanding and finishing, my son and his wife liked the piece so well they used it over the double doorway between the kitchen and living room. If you wish you can add artist oil paints to epoxy when mixing. Might try some on scrap to see if it would look like what you want. The Epoxy certainly should be hard enough to resist wear as well as the wood floor.

Re: Wood Filler Question

#4

Re: Wood Filler Question

don stephan

Not sure what you mean by "accept oil." Most fillers I've used are much denser than wood, so linseed oil, danish oil, and wiping varnishes will show a higher sheen on the filler than on the surrounding wood. But they won't cause the oil finish to fail on the surrounding wood.

Re: Wood Filler Question

#5

Re: Wood Filler Question

Rob Sandow

The best wood filler is really some sawdust and wood chips from whatever wood you are working with, mixed with some oil based varnish.

Re: Wood Filler Question

#6

Re: Wood Filler Question

John Lucas

I use sort of the same procedure for filling gaps in knots. I mix the color in the epoxy but I leave it smokey instead of a solid color. It then picks up some of the color of the surrounding wood.

Re: Wood Filler Question

#7

Re: Wood Filler Question

John in NM

I would use epoxy, probably tinted black. The 2 hour stuff from West System or similar (Lee Valley carries smallish kits) is a lot harder than 5 minute epoxy. You can also get longer cure epoxies from hobby vendors who specialize in RC planes, I believe that's harder than 5 minute also.

I would advise you not to oil the floor, it will start looking dry within the year and require re-coating even to keep the matte worn look you want. Leave it a couple or three years and it will look like a tired old cutting board :D

My wife once finished a floor with a gallon of Waterlox I had in the shop while I was out of town, and even though it's a bit more of a film finish than a straight oil, the results ended up being as I described - and with the price of the stuff, I wasn't exactly happy about wasting it, but that's another story :D I would go with satin poly and just let it get the dings and dents that floors get.

Re: Wood Filler Question

#8

Rob, and JL, I have a question

Keith Newton

It sounds to me that "sawdust" in epoxy would just look like a particle board plug, and that planer or jointer shavings would just up it to OSB. Could you post some pics showing a good example of a sawdust filler?

I certainly will use dust from my sanding bag, sometimes mixing two colors, so I can dow a swirl or streaks, but when it really counts, I inlay a carefully chosen solid plug.

Re: Wood Filler Question

#9

Re: Wood Filler Question

Paul Woolson

Thanks all. Epoxy/sawdust was my first thought, as I've used it many times before. My concern is that the sheen of the oil will be different on the epoxy vs. bare wood. Will test on scrap and see how it works.