My Son is looking for a scroll saw for his girlfriend, and I just don't know enough to make a decent recommendation for him. A new DeWalt is probably too much, so something less costly would be in order. I just don't want to see them end up with a piece of junk when he could do better for a few dollars more. I thank you in advance for your wisdom, and your kind friendship in sharing it.
If it is to be used cutting out Christmas ornament shapes about anything will do. If it is to do intricate work, fret work, etc. then there will be a huge difference between a high quality saw and a cheap one, so much so that a cheap saw may simply not be up to the task. Personally, I would rather opt for a used good saw than a cheap new one.
I have an old craftsman from the early 1940's that I completely restored which works ok but the blade clamp system is awkward at best and the blade guides are terrible.
One of the shops I worked at had a Hegner made in the late 80's that was pretty decent but the blade clamps were the old style that required an Allen key. At the time it was one of the top rated scroll saws.
I teach part time in the fine art department at my local community college and we have two dewalts that replaced an older delta. The delta is a lower quality copy of the Hegner I wrote about above and it has more vibration than my 70+ year old craftsman. The newer delta looks to have quite a few improvements over the old one and maybe someone else will comment about how well they work.
The Dewalt is hands down by far the best of the lot. it is so superior I don't know where to start but suffice to say it is s Mercedes and all the others are Yugo's
I know you said the Dewalt isn't in the budget but I see students with zero wood working experience using tools for the first time every semester and the confifence and results they get off the Dewalt are impressive. If it were me I would at least try looking fit a used dewalt.
I'm going to jump in here, though I don't usually recommend specific brands. We did extensive testing of scroll saws when I was at American Woodworker magazine, and I have talked to many top craftspeople about the best saws and the best values. The Excalibur is regarded by most as the best saw and the DeWalt is the best value by far. Hegner still makes a great saw but they are very expensive and blade changing is awkward compared to the Excalibur.
If it were me, I'd bite the bullet and get a DeWalt if your son's girlfriend has more than a passing interest in this type of work.
Step up and get the DeWalt. You will appreciate the "big boy" features on an entry level scroll saw. Nothing more frustrating fiddling with the blade clamp every time you need to disconnect and to reconnect. If you are starting a serious scrolling career then get an Eclispe. I have approx. 15,000 hours on mine and it preforms like it was new.
Another advantage of the Excaliber is that the blade and arm tilt instead of the table. It doesn't make much difference if you are doing marquetry, inlay or intarsia, but if you want to make pierced chair backsplats (e.g., Chippendale, etc.) in which the you may have 7° or so of relief, all that weight wants to slide sideways off the tilted, vibrating table, reducing your accuracy significantly.
I have a cheap scroll saw, that I got many years ago. I don't recommend one of these cheap saws, whatever the brand that is on them. I don't use it much, but when I got it, I made a couple enhancements that improved its performance.
First, when I bolted it to the stand, I placed some mouse pads or wetsuit material between the saw and the stand. This significantly reduced the vibration.
Second, I replaced the mechanical air pump with an aquarium aeration pump, and wired it to the saw's power switch.
It still doesn't have quick release toolless blade holders, and I haven't found any to retrofit to it. I would not recommend any saw that does not have this feature. The blade holders that are operated with an allen wrench are just too inconvenient, unless all you are doing is cutting teddy bear and heart silhouettes out of white pine.
I will pass along your recommendations! I will suggest he checks Craig's List for a used DeWalt. The girlfriend is very crafty, and has had him cutting out shapes that she then decorates for Christmas.
I don't know where you are located, but my wife has a nice Dewalt available with the stand and another attachment that makes blade changes even easier. It is a great saw as others here have mentioned, but she upgraded to one of the very high end saws. moline at agwireless dot net