Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

Posts

Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#1

Completely OT  If you were buying/Renting a home?

Barry Irby

Would you be put off by the presence of a Radon Mitigation system? I tend to not be threatened by the things like lead based paint, mold, or Radon, etc. I am wondering if the rest of the world is more concerned? In one day an investor carried me to two houses as a Home Inspector and both had Radon Mitigation Systems. I told him what the systems were and how they worked and advised him to get testing for radon done. (I see very few of these systems and to see two in a day was amazing.)

My question is what would your reaction be if you were considering buying or renting such a house. Would it be a deal killer for you?

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#2

Re: Completely OT  If you were buying/Renting a ho

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My reaction would be that someone was suckered into a boondoggle. If it added to the rent I would go elsewhere.

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#3

Re: Completely OT  If you were buying/Renting a ho

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I would probably add passing a radon test to the terms before buying the house to insure that the mitigation system is actually working.

Lee

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#4

Re: Completely OT  If you were buying/Renting a ho

AZ in Colorado Springs

Our home has radon mitigation in the basement. And that's exactly what happened -- we got the results of a good test at closing. We repeat the test every few years. Come to think of it, it's time to go that again.

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#5

It's a big deal around here

Dick Coers

Radon is a big deal with home sales around here. If there is a mitigation system, the house may just sell more easily. We had lots of small underground coal mines around here in the day, so I think the two might just go together.

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#6

Agree...

John in NM

The methodology in applying data collected in underground mines to predict conditions in a residential setting is shaky, to put it politely.

All the more ironic to me, is that "radon mitigation" means "ventilation" in bureaucracy speak :D

However, I wouldn't worry about purchasing a house with such a system. I might do some research first, to see how it affects the ability to re-sell the house. As Dick points out, some buyers may see it as a benefit. I doubt I would pay more for one though.

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#7

Re: Completely OT  If you were buying/Renting a ho

BrianMonumentCO

It is not a big deal.

I would as others have said get a test done.

The need for mitigation has to with how easily the radon builds up in that particular structure.

A well sealed lower level would tend to have higher build ups.

If radon gas is present.

But most important is does your area have radon as a problem.

By that I mean many homes have radon gas problems.

Not just many homes have been mitigated.

IIRC radon gas causes a form of cancer. So it is not to be trifled with.

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#8

Re: Agree...

BrianMonumentCO

Yet the average radon mitigation system that I have seen are all about moving radon gas that collects under the foundation up through pipes out through the roof. So it is form of ventilation.

On the other hand if the gas is allowed to build up under the foundation it will make its way into the basement.

Where it can lead to various forms of cancer if IIRC.

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#9

Re: Completely OT  If you were buying/Renting a ho

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

If I saw a radon mitigation system installed on a house I was looking to buy I would assume it has a radon problem. In the current buyers market I would walk away and find a home with out a radon problem.

I should add that on the west coast radon problems are rare.

Robin

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#10

Radon Cancer Hazard

Bill Howatt

This is from Health Canada's site on radon exposure. The point is also made that there are variations in levels regardless of which general exposure area you live in and the only way to know the level in your house is to test your house.

Q. How can radon affect my health?



A. Radon gas and radon progeny in the air can be breathed into the lungs where they breakdown further and emit ""alpha particles"". Alpha particles release small bursts of energy which are absorbed by nearby lung tissue. This results in lung cell death or damage. When lung cells are damaged, they have the potential to result in cancer when they reproduce.

The only known health risk associated with exposure to high levels of radon in indoor air is an increased lifetime risk of developing lung cancer. The risk from radon exposure is long term and depends on the level of radon, how long a person is exposed and their smoking habits. If you are a smoker and are exposed to elevated levels of radon your risk of developing lung cancer increases significantly.

On average, 16% of lung cancer deaths are attributable to radon exposure in Canada. In 2006, an estimated 1,900 lung cancer deaths in Canada were due to radon exposure. Radon is the 2nd leading cause of lung cancer, after smoking.

Other than lung cancer, there is no evidence that radon exposure causes other harmful health effects such as any other form of cancer, respiratory diseases such as asthma, or symptoms such as persistent coughing or headaches.

Q. I am a smoker. Does radon affect me more than a non-smoker?

A. Yes. The risk from radon exposure for a smoker (including those exposed to second hand smoke) is much greater than for a non-smoker. For example, if you are a lifelong smoker but are not exposed to radon, your risk of getting lung cancer is one in ten. If you add exposure to a high level of radon, your risk becomes one in three. On the other hand, if you are a non-smoker, your lifetime lung cancer risk at the same high radon level is only one in twenty.

Bill

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#11

Re: Agree...

John in NM

The cancer link is the part that comes from studying the health of underground miners :D

As I remember, the link is much stronger for smokers (or rather, underground miners who smoke :D )

Whether the link is applicable to residential environs is open to debate - and if purchasing some kind of mitigation system helps a person sleep soundly, I sure wouldn't tell them not to do it. Sleep is important.

However, consumers should be wary of anyone performing radon tests who sells radon mitigation systems and anyone selling "instant" or effectively instant tests. Concentrations of any trace gas in a dynamic environment will need to be an average over a significant period of time to be accurate. I would imagine that a 24 hour day is a bare minimum, and 10 days would be better. One could argue that seasonal variations could require a year long test for a truly representative figure.

I'd forgotten all about that "seeps through the foundation" nonsense.... I guess the EPA went with that (I haven't paid any attention to this in 20 years). The most plausible theory that I remember was that it came dissolved in tap water - in most places, tap water is ground water - of course they can't fix that one, so it would never be chosen by the EPA (yes, I'm a cynic when it comes to the overlap of science and public policy :D )

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#12

Re: Agree...

BrianMonumentCO

Tthe radon seeping through foundation nonsense is very real.

If you get water in your basement that same path could be followed by the radon gas.

IIRC radon gas dissolves in water.

At any rate, whether one believes that it can cause cancer or not, it is radioactive and has been linked to cancer. If the basement level is tested and shows the high level of radon and one has mitigated and the tests show a low level/none of radon then the mitigation worked. And the house is safe to live in (radon wise). Not a boondoggle as others have suggested.

When I lived in New Hampshire, I saw several homes that had been mitigated.

My house did not test positive for radon.

I was told that radon is prevalent in areas with large underground granite formations near the house foundation.

Not sure about all that coal miners radon cancer tests. But I would bet that coal miners develop cancer from a whole batch of other causes as well.

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#13

This has been interesting....

Barry Irby

I actually used to do Radon testing. I "know" a lot about it. At least I know what I was taught by the EPA back in the day in the official classes. If you live in a house with a high level of radon for a long time and stay mostly indoors your chances of getting lung cancer were stated to be 9 in a 1000. If you smoke (They did not say how much) your chances are 135 in a 1000. So its second but a pretty poor second. It like saying I finished the race in 9 seconds and you finished second, two minutes and 6 seconds later.

I still think a lot of it is blown way out of proportion, but it gives the EPA a whole new territory. (all of Indoors)

I am trying to figure out if the "average" person would React to a "radon" house by simply saying "NO WAY! I'm outa here." Or would they just ask for a test and go with that. Or would they be mostly unconcerned. Part of me can't figure out why anyone would buy or rent anything that already had a radon problem But then, they do, everyday.

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#14

Been there, done that

Grant in Iowa

Here in Eastern Iowa, Radon testing, for better or worse is here to stay. process goes something like this:

Homeowner has no idea about anything related to Radon puts his/ her home on market and gets an offer demanding a radon test as a condition of the offer. Homeowner agrees thinking "I have never seen radon myself", or some similar thought process. Test is done, house fails (something like 25-30% of homes have over the allowable level in my area). Buyer demands a mitigation system is put in by owner at a cost of around $900 to $1200. House is retested and passes and is sold.

My previous home had excessive radon, and information suggests that the ground water that was constantly coming in to the sump had a lot to do with it. We lived there 7 years and #1 son lived in the basement (where radon often enters and collects) for a significant part of that time. As a teenager, he spent a good deal of time in his room.

In many counties in Iowa it is now law to have the test done before before a sale. One way out is to have a system installed already. Once the realtor and buyer are watching, it is too late to do it yourself.

So, Go rent a core drill, and install your own system, routing the 4" pipe up through some living space (like a closet), and through the attic. This routing is so the system can use natural convection to create a small vacuum under the slab of your home, thereby venting the baddies for free. Many pros take the easy way out through the rim joist and up the side of the house, but this approach means a blower will be required to create the required vacuum. Study up online before doing this as there are significant details one must adhere to.

If you have a sump pit, you can also add a cover and attach your piping there, since the 4" drain tile is embedded in the rock beneath your slab. Route the pipe outside as stated above and you are pretty much good.

My father died of lung cancer that spread throughout his body. You can cry about government over reach all you want. Educate yourself first is all I ask. Society pays the HUGE bills cancer victims rack up in their final days in the form of higher insurance premiums. Radon is a known cancer cause. We built a new home and installed the system for around $120 or so during construction. Money well spent. Thinking about the 9 in 1000 chance my family now has of developing lung cancer due to the house we lived in is not a laughing matter or one to scoff at.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#15

Map of Radon prone areas (NM) *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

It depends on where you live as to the risks of radon in the ground. In my area, the risk is high. We have had kids live in basement bedrooms in a home that later failed a radon test. Makes one wonder what the future will hold for them.

Follow link to a map


Radon map of USA

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#16

Never mentioned coal miners...

John in NM

That was Dick's post :D

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#17

Re: This has been interesting....

BrianMonumentCO

On the other hand if you know that your house has a high radon level by testing and you don't disclose.....well you know what could happen.

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#18

Re: Completely OT  If you were buying/Renting a ho

Stuart Johnson

To me it would be a non event.

1. If there is a radon problem the Radon Mitigation system should handle it. This is assuming the system was properly installed and actually works.

2. If the seller was ripped off and there is no radon problem the system has no meaning.

I would want a radon test done.

Re: Completely OT If you were buying/Renting a home?

#19

Re: Completely OT  If you were buying/Renting a ho

John McGaw

If I lived in a radon-prone area, I'd accept that remediation had been done for some reason and would be willing to accept it was done correctly after I checked it over (blower[s] running, cracks sealed?) and after a test and report were done. I'd be far more hesitant about a house in a flood-prone area or, shudder, a mobile home in Oklahoma.