Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Finishing crotch walnut

Posts

Finishing crotch walnut

#1

Finishing crotch walnut

matthew

Hi - I picked up some interesting pieces of crotch walnut - they will need a lot of sanding I think. I will be using a festool 125 and am wondering what grit I should sand to? I plan on cutting the pieces into fish shapes to hang on the wall and am considering a garnet or amber shellac. I have used shellac - but about 15 years ago! Would you please tell me what application you would recommend - and what cut to mix?

Thank you!

Re: Finishing crotch walnut

#2

Re: Finishing crotch walnut

matthew

....r maybe making a mix of the garnet and amber flakes? I am really looking for s finish to display the "depth" of the wood as opposed to a high gloss finish. I hope that makes sense!

Cheers,

Matthew

Re: Finishing crotch walnut

#3

Clint Searl

Spraycan poly or lacquer


Re: Finishing crotch walnut

#4

Re: Finishing crotch walnut

Stephen W. Schoene

Go to about 220 with the sander, but continue sanding by hand with 220 to remove the cross grain swirls from the sander. Depending how the crotch grain treats you you may want to go to 320 to minimize the appearance of sanding marks even further.

Re: Finishing crotch walnut

#5

professional recommendation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Alf Sharp, SAPFM Cartouche winner, advised me on a crotch finishing project.

water soluble dye, linseed oil and let thoroughly dry, shellac or lacquer (but varnish would do fine too. The dye establishes a color that will not fade like native walnut color, linseed oil to bring out depth of figure, top coat to add brightness. Attached is a picture of a mahogany crotch finished this way.

Re: Finishing crotch walnut

#6

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

it was sanded to either 180 or 220. I usually sand open pore woods to 180 but I can't recall on this piece.

Re: Finishing crotch walnut

#7

Re: professional recommendation

matthew

WOW - that is spectacular! Thank you.

Re: Finishing crotch walnut

#8

Re: professional recommendation

Jerry Gibbs

Can you be more specific re the color of the dye? Was it to color the heartwood or something lighter to enhance heartwood and sapwood. I have a large walnut crotch for a desk and I want to keep the heartwood from fading yet keep the contrast. Thanks. Jerry

Re: Finishing crotch walnut

#9

need clarification

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"yet keep the contrast".... The contrast in the heartwood or contrast between white sap and heartwood?

A problem with a crotch is that where the grain is standing on end it can take stain and/or oil so much that it becomes almost black. A wash coat of shellac followed by a light sanding with 220 will keep the dark areas from going too dark. I used a wash coat on the mahogany door, but not on walnut door shown below.

Pictured is a book matched walnut crotch door. It was sanded to 180, stained with burnt umber oil based stain (burnt umber pigment in linseed oil) and shellaced. You can judge the contrast on the door


Re: Finishing crotch walnut

#10

Re: need clarification

Jerry Gibbs

want to keep contrast between heartwood and sapwood. want to keep heartwood from washing out.

Re: Finishing crotch walnut

#12

Re: professional recommendation

Stephen W. Schoene

Keeping the color in walnut heartwood is tricky and probably not to be wholly desired. I say that because the only way to just keep the color is to stain it heavily with pigment in the initial color. But that's ugly and hides the interest in the walnut grain. But, you can achieve a bit of stability in color by judicious use of pigment only stain. The key word is judicious.

Re: Finishing crotch walnut

#13

You all be the judge of ugly

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


You made the claim, " But that's ugly and hides the interest in the walnut grain."

Picture: Walnut stained with burnt umber pigment in oil. I would agree that people that have not learned how to stain(sand) can wind up with ugly. Many do not judge the results I get ugly. Success depends on proper surface preparation.

Re: Finishing crotch walnut

#14

Re: professional recommendation

Stephen W. Schoene

It was only heavy stain that I argued was ugly because it obscured the walnut grain. That's not what you were doing, In fact I would assert that your method is exactly the judicious use of pigment that I recommended.

Definitely not ugly--I like it.

Re: Finishing crotch walnut

#15

Re: Finishing crotch walnut

gary peterson

i've planed down some walnut slabs for desk tops and found if using a heavy grit to start, 50 with belt sander, figured areas gets cut deeply and is darn hard to sand out...generally very hard. would suggest easing into figured areas.