Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

Posts

? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#1

? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

Jerry Roberts

Does anyone out there in WC land had any trouble with T5 bulbs? I first bought mine early this year at HD . The bulbs went bad abd 4 months later. They were good enough to give me 2 more. Now, today, they are bad again. They are Philips (maybe that's the problem) and when they go bad there is a slight black ring around one end.I wouldn't complain but I initially paid $11 each so if good ol HD doesn't come thru again Ill buy something else .As good as I like T5s I cant afford to replace them every 4 months. Thanks for any info one might have and happy holidays. Jer

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#2

No issues here..

Tony-Memphis

I bought mine at Lowe's - GE I believe. I think my oldest is only 6 months old, so we' see. The model I buy at Lowe's is $7 or so. Forget the exact name, but they sure have made a difference. Need to finish updating the rest of my fixtures. Mine were T12, so I have to replace the ballasts. I'm not familiar with failure modes of these bulbs, but my impression was that they last for years. My T12's lasted 15 and are still working, just not as well.

Tony

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#3

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Phillips had at one time a reputation for high reliability in its products. Is the ballast compatible with T5 bulbs?

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#4

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

John McGaw

T5 tubes and ballasts both come in 'regular' and 'HO' varieties. So far as I know they can be physically fitted together but I suspect that using HO ballasts and plain bulbs might lead them to die pretty quickly. Any chance of a mixup?

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#5

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

Jerry Roberts

Thanks for the info John. I went right out to the shop and looked.They are marked with a (circle) E and a (circle)Hg. I bought the ballast and tubes from HD at the same time. There is a noticeable black ring on the end of the tubes. To me it means they are infact shot. Again.

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#6

What exactly do you have?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

HD sells T5 and T5 HO and they almost surely are not interchangeble as they differ in wattage by twice. However, if you are sure the lamp and fixture are the same, then I suspect the ballast.

I have T5 HO in the shop, from Home Depot and they have been fine for months. They should last years.

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#7

Some thoughts: *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

You can check a fluorescent tube by checking continuity between the pins on each end. Generally, you will find that a burned out tube will have no continuity at one or both ends. Tube failure is rarely due to any other issue. The blackening you see is often due to the filament in that end overheating and burning out. When this happens prematurely, you often didn't have the bulb in quite right, or you might have a loose wire somewhere. Less often it can be the result of a bad ballast.

You will NOT get continuity between opposite ends of a tube....this is normal.

Many issues with fluorescent fixtures can be traced to poor connections where the tube contacts the lamp holder. Inspect closely and ensure your tubes are nicely seated by rotating them back and forth a time or two.

Philips T5 tubes do not presently require a burn-in period as some other high efficiency tubes do. Make sure you check packaging and instructions for this information and comply for maximum life span.

Here is more info regarding rapid start, instant start, etc. that would be a good read to ensure you have the right variety for your purpose.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa<---mild manner facilities guy by day


Luxadd T-5 info

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#8

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

John McGaw

Probably the most important marking you could look at will be on the electronic ballast inside the fixture. If it is a 'HO' ballast it will need to be used with 'HO' tubes since it will be trying to force about twice as much current through the tubes as regular tubes are meant to handle. That would certainly explain short tube life. Just a WAG on my part but occasionally and quite by accident I've been right, despite what my ex might say.

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#9

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

Jay Lombardo

Standard T8 & T12 fluorescent tubes are bi-pin and don't function very well in the cold. HO or High Output tubes are typically single pin and go into the spring loaded ends, these are used outdoors in cold climates, or garages, sheds, workshops that tend to get cold. If you are not using these in a cold environment they offer no real advantage. T5 lamps I believe are all bi-pin and care has to be taken to match the proper T5 lamp HE, HO, etc. to the proper T5 electronic ballast. In commercial or large scale applications the T5's can offer significant savings but personally in residential or smaller scale applications I have found the T8's to be sufficient and economically better.

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#10

Re: What exactly do you have?

Jerry Roberts

Bill, I have a T5, rapid start, HO ballast. I checked Philips web site and couldn't find the exact tube type.(F28T5/835 ALTO ) but close. Most warranties were at least 30 months and more. So, Im gonna talk to the main Man at HD and see what he suggests.I sure have learned a lot from all the info Ive gotten here. Thanks a bunch guys!

Bill, I have a T5,HO, rapid start ballast. I checked the Philips web site and couldn't find the exact tube type but close. ItsF28T5/835 Alto. The warranty period on most tubes is at least 30 months and more. Im gonna talk to the main Man at HD and do what he suggests. Ive sure learned a lot from everyone at WC on this matter. Thanks a bunch guys. Jer

J

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#11

not so

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the T5 HO puts out twice the illumination as a conventional T5, T8 or T12. They are 50+ watts and efficient. This fact can be confirmed by looking on the lamp package for each variety.

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#12

Re: What exactly do you have?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I bought two T5HO fixtures several months ago. The lamps were sold separate. They clearly have "HO" in black lettering along with the other lamp information on one end of the lamp. If your lamps do not say HO, you have the wrong lamps for that fixture.

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#13

You have the wrong lamp

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

F28 is a 28 watt lamp. The HO fixture requires a 54 watt lamp. Its number will be F54........

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#14

Re: not so

John McGaw

I'll say that they are really bright. The local HD has a single 4-tube T5HO fixture on display. It is a 'high bay' light and has IIRC mirror-finish reflectors behind the bulbs and it is entirely too bright to look into and that isn't, in my experience, true of any other fluorescent fixture. I was considering buying one of these to put up in the central location of my shop above the Robland machine but unless I can get some sort of a wire cage to put over it I'm hesitating for fear of doing something stupid with it.

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#15

Of course not...oops!

Tony-Memphis

I am using T8's not T5's. Sorry.

Tony

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#16

Re: You have the wrong lamp

Jerry Roberts

Bill, I think you are correct.They are definatly not the same wattage. I was thinking about incandesant lights. The power company puts out zillions of wattage to the table lamp with a 60 watt bulb in it . That bulb will only put out 60 watts of power regardless of the input. That has to do with resistance of the filament winding.A fluorescent tube don't have any filaments. I e-mailed Philips Lighting about that same question and am waiting for a reply.If, in fact the tube wattage has to match the ballast wattage, and I feel it does, Ill either have to get a 28 w ballast and stay with the same tubes or vise-versa. WOW! Believe me, HD doesn't know they have to match cause they suggested I use the lower wattage lamps. Oh well, life is interesting. Jer

Re: ? on T-5 fluorescent bulbs

#17

there is no "thinking" about it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

T5HO fixture requires the T5HO lamps which are 54 watt. End of story. When you replace the 28 watt lamps you will experience twice the illumination.