Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Shop roof ice dam problem.

Posts

Shop roof ice dam problem.

#1

Shop roof ice dam problem.

Keith Newton

Last night I had just finished clamping up a top, when suddenly my roof started leaking in 3 widely space places near the back. With about 1.5" of sleet on the roof, I was not anxious to go up there, but cautiously did.

My shop is an old Safeway store, #10, built in 1926~7, 50' Wide, X 100' long, with a torch-down roof, which slopes about 1.5" in 10'.

The framing consist of wooden trusses crossing the short span, with 2x10 roof joist 14' long between them, first decked with 1x6 ship lap pine, then 1/2" OSB over that. Then felt was nailed down, with the roof membrane torch melted onto the felt.

The problem, is that that over the last 85 years, the joist have started to sag between the trusses, and the last foot before the gutter has bricks all the way up under the deck. Then outside that is a band-joist, with fascia and gutter, with metal drip ledge out from under roof.

At some temperature level, my heat loss from shop melts the ice from the bottom, which slowly runs down to this last span, but then an ice-dam forms in the last foot of run. Like some of those terraced pools at Yellowstone, the ice will continue to grow and dam the water behind it, getting deeper and deeper until!!!!!!????

I would bet that some of you in the more Northern states have to deal with Ice-dams more often than we do down here, so I'm hoping for some recommendation for something to warm that last bit of roof, for now, but realizing that I probably need to rip up some deck and fix the sag, for a real fix.

Old pine becomes brash under the high heat of Summer attic temperatures, which adds to my worry.

Do any of you know of any product that you know are good. Our weather is supposed to stay freezing until the next system gets here, so that could add to the roof load.

Re: Shop roof ice dam problem.

#2

Re: Shop roof ice dam problem.

Barry Irby

1 You are possibly correct about the water/ice building up. It can become a self aggravating problem. The heavier it gets, the more the joists deflect and the heavier it gets......

There are heating cables available that you can lay on the roof to melts passages through the ice to Allow the water to drain off. I have never used them myself but I believe the theory is to run them perpendicular to the edge, creating "tunnels". I don't know the official name for the cables or where to buy them.

Re: Shop roof ice dam problem.

#3

Re: Shop roof ice dam problem.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Can you install a "Z" element heat string on top of the roof to melt the dam. Up here the dams form in the last 3' back from the gutter where the roof surface is coldest. On a shingle roof, the dams forces the water to back up under the layers. We therefore use ice/water shield 4' wide up from the edge of pitch to seal. Can you access the sagged section to jack and shim it? You're obviously looking at a roof-job next year.

Re: Shop roof ice dam problem.

#4

It's me again.....

Barry Irby

Your posts has a lot of facets to the question. Reading Marks response jogged some of my nearly dormant brain cells.

Ice damming is fairly well understood on residential roofs. Three or four things happen or are required. One thing is that shingle roofing is not "water proof". It sheds water and is dependent on the slope to cause the water to run off the edges before it finds a way around the shingles. (Thus when the dam forms, water wanders under the shingles and through the sub structure.) Two, poorly insulated ceilings let heat rise through the roof sheathing, melting the ice or snow above, letting the water drool down to the lower edge. Since the area above the outside wall and soffit are not insulated, there is no heat rising there and the drool refreezes, causing the dam. Mark mentioned Ice and water shield, a relatively recent addition. It is supposed to extend back beyond the soffit to an area above the insulation. It is supposed to be water proof. Thus if water ponds above it, it will prevent it from leaking into the heated space.

Your situation is different. The roofing on your flat (slightly sloped) must be water proof because the water will not run off the edge fast enough to prevent it leaking into ANY hole in the membrane.

You mentioned the joists had sagged. Mark mentioned straightening them or shimming them. There is some evidence that suggests that wood "relaxes" or sags with advancing age and this may be at the 75 to 100 year interval. In any event, my experience is that once the wood sags even for a few years, it acquires a "set" and will not straighten easily. If you try to jack up the center, it will just move up as a unit and not readily straighten. It will retain the "smile" and is just as difficult to straighten as it would have been to force the curve into it in the beginning. You could pull up the sheeting and Install a straight piece beside each joist, but that's a lot of work. Probably easier to fur it from the top.

The question becomes what exactly is the problem? If the membrane is waterproof how is it getting in? Where is the leak? It might be along the edge where the ice dam is causing it to back up under the edge detail drip flashing, then running back along the underside of the sheeting (which may be sloping the wrong way because of the sag in the joists.) If there are gutters, the heating cables may melt enough ice out of them to help.

Re: Shop roof ice dam problem.

#5

Update, and thanks Mark and Barry

Keith Newton

I got Ben over here to go up with me this morning. We took a few tools up, and broke back from the edge about 4' across the lower end, then salted the problem area. I have found two of the leaks, which was where it was running back from a wrinkle that had formed which crossed the drip ledge. I can take care of that with a heat gun or torch, and some sealant.

A few years ago, I installed a drain out in the lowest point of that sagging area, which works great for rain, but under this situation, the area around it just let the water close to it drain out of the bottom of the slush, then being aluminum, which is a great conductor, allowed the cold air from down the tube, suck away the attic heat, then froze solid around it.

The Sun is out and shining, and even though it is only 27º, I'm starting to get some melt, so maybe I'll be able to find and fix the other.

As for fixing the sagging joist, I think I have a good plan to take care of that whenever time and weather permits. I'm thinking of removing the last 8' of roof deck, then cutting the rise off from there back, even removing a layer of the top of the brick wall. While that is open, I can come back with a cross run of strong-back, then some braces which run back down to the bottom of the truss and brick wall, to compensate for the loss of joist height, although it may be a better idea to just rip it all out to the truss, and just replace the roof joist.

I put this roof on after the Jan 21 1999 tornado passed through and destroyed the previous one. While this has been a good roof, it is getting brittle. The heat of the Summer Sun, has caused some wrinkles, which should be pulled out when it is cold like this, but don't because of lost elasticity over that time. I don't think it will be long before I'll be having to replace this one. I'm liking the idea of another torch-down with the white granules imbedded in the top, unless there is some newer greatest product ever developed that beats it out.

Re: Shop roof ice dam problem.

#6

Re: Update, and thanks Mark and Barry

Barry Irby

Research the new roofing carefully. There have been several "Greatest New Roofing Since Sliced Bread" products that sort of went away after a very few years.

Most flat roofing is touted as lasting 20 years. It appears to me that it lasts about fifteen years and then it leaks. It gets patched and lasts about two more and then you are in the leak management phase. Having a pro walk your roof every fall may pay off for you now.

The product you call Torch Down may be Modified Bitumen Sheet which looks like roll roofing. Roll roofing looks like asphalt shingles in a three foot wide roll, but instead of last twenty or twenty five years, lasts abut ten. This is the low end of the spectrum. Torch Down or Modified sheet should last much longer, again the proverbial twenty years. The white granules should help. (They serve at least three functions, Block the UV off the sheet, reflect the heat, add weight to protect against blow off, and add abrasion resistance for light foot traffic.)

Two other possibilities are EPDM and PVC. EPDM looks like the rubber from an inner tube and has a long history. Probably benefits form being painted white or aluminum. The PVC is white. If it does not have a black second layer just under the surface It may also benefit fro and coat of aluminum paint, but I am not sure. Not as time tested here as the EPDM. UV is the death of the PVC and they claim they have magic sunblock in it now, but I am a skeptic. I am no longer anxious to be the first kid on my block.... Somebody else do the testing and let me know.

I have a friend that is much more knowledgeable than I am. When you are ready for a new roof, let me know and I will ask him. The installation workmanship is absolutely critical. Excellent material can not offset poor installation.

One more thing, As far as I know all of them age twice as fast under water as they do dry. The ponding accelerates the aging process and puts a strain on the membrane. When they fail, it a funnel and the entire puddle drains in.

Re: Shop roof ice dam problem.

#7

Re: Shop roof ice dam problem.

Kevin French

Keith the easiest way to deal with Ice Dams is to get a Roof Rake. It sounds like you're far enough south that you don't get a lot of snow. Simply use the roof rake to clear the snow off the roof for about 4-5' up after each storm, you won't get dams.

Re: Shop roof ice dam problem.

#8

One last tidbit I learned today.

Keith Newton

I think I mentioned earlier, my concern for the weight, not so much for what was there at the time, but if it progressed. While I have a good memory for numbers, and well aware that a cubic foot of water, which is 62.5#, and is the baseline for the term Specific Gravity, thus one , by which everything else is compared.

I should have known, or assumed that simply dividing its thickness into that, I could calculate the weight. While Ben and I were up there prying up some big sheets, I grabbed one to weigh when we came down.

Back down in the shop, I band-sawed it one foot square, and as it turned out, this piece was one inch thick, and weighed ~5#. If the 14' joist are on 24" centers each would carry 28 sq ft, so 140# extra load on each. That doesn't sound nearly as bad as I was expecting.

I think I can remember 5.2# for an inch foot of water, and a bit less due to the expansion into ice. Where I think it will be most useful for us woodworkers, is by simplifying the math , for example, if a wood has a specific gravity of .5, it would weigh about 2.5# per board ft.

Re: Shop roof ice dam problem.

#9

Re: One last tidbit I learned today.

Barry Irby

Keith, If the total build up is only an inch, you are right, its relatively insignificant. Unless the structure is already compromised or was poorly built and near its limits. Over a very long time (in human terms, scores of years, not geologic times) materials change. I mentioned the change in wood that seems to occur at something like 75 to a 100 years. Very old (historic) buildings suffer later changes. Seemingly weird things happen. Slate roofs will "Cascade", that is a bunch of slates will slide off. It comes from a couple of possibilities. With copper nails, the slates expand and contract with changes in temperature and file or saw their way through the shafts of the nails. With galvanized nails they rust after the sawing action files its way through the galvanizing. This is one of the reasons that as a Home Inspector I NEVER walk on a slate roof. (Its dangerous for me and I could also break slates and damage the roof.) I have never actually seen the slates turn loose and slide off, but I did inspect a house that had about six slates standing up in the gutters. the sellers swore they were "not there yesterday".

Where this applies to you is that you should consider the possibility that the nails in your building may have been compromised. If they have been there a while they may have rusted from condensation.

My point is there are some very slow long term decay processes that go on pretty much un-noticed. Be careful.

Re: Shop roof ice dam problem.

#10

Re: Shop roof ice dam problem.

Dave T

A temporary fix, safer than going at the ice dam with chisels or axes or power tools:

Get some snow melt (the white crystals) and panty hose or socks. Make some sausage, and lay them perpendicular to the dam....they'll melt down through and let the water out.