Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Any trim carpenters here?

Posts

Any trim carpenters here?

#1

Any trim carpenters here?

Alex Y

We are doing a kitchen remodel, and because of the size of the job, and LOML's unreasonable request that it be completed in our lifetime, we are having the work dome by a contractor. We have 10' ceilings, with a 4.5" multi-part crown and a picture molding below that. We are doing cabinets to the ceiling, and my inclination was to skip the picture mold on the cabinets. Rationale: I want the height, and I wonder about how it would have been treated traditionally. No-one is going to hang pictures in front of their cabinetry, so why have a picture molding there. (Of course, you could say the same about doors and windows, but there we are talking about what would be a small interruption, where here, half the wall space will be cabinetry, with the only breaks being one window and two doors.

The decorator feels strongly that the same molding treatment needs to go around the room (I didn't ask her about the chair rail ;) ), and the cabinet guy seemed to agree. Am I wrong to think that eliminating the picture mold would look fine?

Which would be more historically accurate (if cabinets to the ceiling were used historically)?

Re: Any trim carpenters here?

#2

Ellis Walentine

My take

Ellis Walentine

From a design standpoint, I would suggest maintaining the picture molding for visual continuity. From floor level, you won't know it is a picture molding. In fact, with a ten-foot ceiling, most kitchen designers would drop a soffit to a lower height -- say 8 ft. -- and stop the cabinets there. Unless you're planning to have a library ladder, you won't be able to access those top two feet of cabinets anyhow.

But, architecturally, I think the continuous line around the room will be the best-looking choice.

Ellis

Re: Any trim carpenters here?

#3

Re: My take

Alex Y

Whose side are you on anyway? ;)

Just kidding. Thanks for the input. Yes, we have soffits now. Top level cabinets will be only for infrequently used items, for which we will pull out a small step stool (a project for me) or a ladder. Things like Christmas china, punch bowls, etc.

Re: Any trim carpenters here?

#5

Re: what is picture molding?

John in NM

It is a rail hung below the crown molding from which you can hang pictures. Usually several inches or more below the crown molding. You have to be able to tolerate the long and visible picture wires if you plan to use it for the stated purpose.

I went to find you a picture on google images, using picture rail as the search term. Came up with a bunch of trains :D #@*&#(%$!!! Google!

Re: Any trim carpenters here?

#6

Re: what is picture molding?

Barry Irby

Bill, Using Google Images search for "Picture Molding". Google seems to think this is a request for pictures OF molding But if you look through a few of them you will find the picture molding discussed above. There were hangers or hooks made to hang on it and wire to attach to the pictures. I assume they thought this was a great way to hang pictures without holes in the walls. The wires are annoying to our modern eyes.

The elaborate version has crown molding with the hanger rail spaced below somewhere between an inch and may four or five inches. Sometimes the stripe of wall space is painted to match the wall or in a sometimes sharply contrasting color. I don't know, but this is probably a Victorian affectation. The simpler version is simply the rail molding spaced about a half inch below the ceiling.

As an aside, After one of my Home Inspections I had someone raise Cain with me, claiming I failed to tell them the house had "settled" and that they had stuffed many rolls f paper towels into the gap and caulked it. Pretty sure I was as baffled as they were.

Re: Any trim carpenters here?

#7

Re: Any trim carpenters here?

John McGaw

I don't know what I'd do in the case of cabinets. Or the ultra-high ceilings for that matter. I did a continuous run of picture moulding in the gallery/library room where it could be managed. The railing runs above the level(s) of the door trim (three doors, three different heights, don't even ask) but had the doors been of even height I might have run the moulding even with the tops of the trim. The moulding runs above the wall-to-wall bookshelves even though nothing will ever be hung there. Please forgive the quality of the quick snaps:


This worked for me although I wouldn't dream of telling anybody else to follow my alleged design sense. BTW, hanging 16-foot sections of whippy moulding single-handed is no fun job and I had to do some devious rigging to make it work.

Re: Any trim carpenters here?

#8

Re: what is picture molding?

John McGaw

Back in the days of real lathe and plaster walls covered with often-expensive wallpaper there was a lot to be said for picture rail and it is no coincidence that it began to fall out of favor when the old-style walls went away. Personally I like it for the flexibility if offers in an environment where artwork will be shuffled around a lot and walls begin to develop speckles and bumps from all of the nails coming and going.

Re: Any trim carpenters here?

#9

Re: what is picture molding?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

On our 1895 Queen Anne cottage, the picture molding is a good foot below the ceiling, and crowns are not common on these particular buildings, at least in this area. The wall above the picture molding, where there is no crown, is traditionally painted the same as the ceiling, and, if there's wallpaper, it stops at bottom of the picture molding. Not sure how the wall between picture molding and crown is treated, but I would incline toward painting it like the ceiling. But note that this is in rooms with ten foot ceilings, and the effect of the common paint color on upper wall and ceiling is to bring the ceiling down a bit visually. In a room with eight foot ceilings, I'd continue the lower wall color all the way to the ceiling. I'd still stop wallpaper at the picture molding, but I would then paint the upper wall the dominant color of the wallpaper, not the ceiling color, to increase the visual height of the wall. I'm no kinda arkitektural eggspert; just observations about what I see in this area, for what they're worth.

So, it's a definite feature of a room, not just something up there.

Thinking as I type here; that is, not organizing these thoughts particularly...

Unless you're building the kitchen cabinets with a space between doors up there at the height of the picture molding, so that it has somewhere to continue, I don't see how you could continue it across the face of the cabinets; and the pattern of the picture molding would need to be something that wouldn't look stupid on the cabinets.

If you continue the picture molding across the face of the cabinets, you are effectively saying that the cabinets are part of the wall. If you're doing upper and lower cabinets with a counter in between, you would need to consider what kind of treatment to put on the ends of the counters to make them "wall-like." For instance, you might need to close in the free ends (those not against a wall/corner) with a cap that runs from the upper to the lower cabinets.

Otherwise, they're furniture, and the picture molding should die into the cabinets when it encounters them.

You asked about "historically accurate." Well, depends on what part of history. Built in kitchen cabinets date, if I recall correctly, from the 1920s, or turn of the last century at the oldest. Built-in cabinets were pretty revolutionary when they happened. Before that, kitchen cabinets were, in fact, furniture, mostly lower than the molding. If your house is older than 1900, I'd go with the "furniture" effect over the "wall" effect, which argues against the continuity of the molidng. In theory, this also argues against running the crown molding on the cabinets - and pretty much everyone runs the crown along the cabinets. But I think the picture molding might have a different visual impact.

Any well-restored publicly viewable historic houses in your area the age of yours? If so, tour them and check, although you'll probably find that the kitchen doesn't have any picture molding at all (servants didn't get to view much fine art in the kitchen, even in the most progressive houses; too much grease and moisture to keep your Rembrandts in there). This is another alternative, if the kitchen is a separate room: don't have picture molding. Or look on the interweb for historic houses of the vintage of your house, and see if there are pictures, or contact the staff for those houses, and see what they say.

And see what your library has; it may have some good picture books of houses in the right time period.

I'll say something here that may get stuff thrown at me: do your research and trust your own instincts over the decorator's. I've seen too many things done by people who think they can design that make me to cringe for the historical, functional, and aesthetic violations on view. Not that they're all bad; but that some of them are. For instance, stepping outside for a minute, there are some houses down on Main Street here that were "restored" from a state of seriously remuddled a couple of years back. The architect or the builder specified head moldings (like crown, but at the top of the top casing across the window) above the window trim outside, which is correct; but they cut the molding to be the same length as the casing, so it just sits there, looking slightly embarrassed. What they should have done is run the molding longer than the casing and put a mitered return on each end, so that the molding pattern continued around the casing and back to the wall. If I'd been the trim carpenter on those buildings, I'd have offered to do it right on my own time, if I had to, just so I wouldn't have to deny I'd worked on the place forever after.

Positive I'm leaving something out here, but this is what comes to mind.

Re: Any trim carpenters here?

#10

Alex, I've got over 40 years doing this

Keith Newton

You ought to give us more info about the style of house to work with.

Otherwise, Whether the picture mold carries around the front of the cabinets or not, I would still consider braking the cabinet doors somewhere along that line. I don't think upper doors over 4' long would work for me. If you change the paint color above it around the rest of the room, I would do the same on the cabinets.

I like changing levels, in and out, as well as heights. It is a way to add interest without really doing much, or needing a lot of embellishment to make it stand out.