Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

applying stain over blotch control

Posts

applying stain over blotch control

#1

applying stain over blotch control

Jerry Gibbs

I have been trying to apply oil based pigmented stain over blotch control with a rag. I have figured out the directions on the can don't apply to other than bare wood. If you let the stain set and then try to wipe it off it will streak badly. I have learned to simply wipe off the stain to the desired effect immediately. The directions I found misleading on the stain can were not to let the stain dry on the wood. If the stain is not being absorbed, there is no other way. I am open to comments and suggestions. Jerry

Re: applying stain over blotch control

#2

What brands of blotch control and stain?


Re: applying stain over blotch control

#3

Re: What brands of blotch control and stain?

Jerry Gibbs

blotch control was Charles Neil and the stain was Minwax. For what it is worth, I have had the same issues trying to apply stain over a film finish.

Re: applying stain over blotch control

#4

The technique I use

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have pigment stained every walnut and cherry piece (and most oak) I have ever made which has resulted in a bit of experience.

Blotch is an ill defined term. Any piece of wood is going to have depth of color variations, some from the structure of the wood and others potentially from improper surface preparation. In the first case, I do not try to hide these effects. In most cases woodworkers try to enhance these effect, for example curly maple. Why some try to hide them in the case of cherry has always mystified me.

Darkly stained areas resulting from improper surface preparation do look ugly. They are easily avoided by proper surface preparation. I find that most people inadequately sand for pigment staining. If the surface looks dull it means it has torn grain and it is catching sanding dust. It doesn't mean you need to sand to 600 grit. It does mean that at 120 grit all the torn grain is sanded away. These areas will excessively take stain. Sanding must yield a surface of uniform luster.




I have described proper sanding and application of stain numerous times and a search of the Archives will find these discussions. I stain with a rubber like what is used to apply shellac. The rubber, rag and result can be seen in the picture.

Re: applying stain over blotch control

#5

Stain is not a glaze.......

Dick Coers

and if you are trying to use Minwax stain on top of clear, it's just plain not going to work. The binder that carries the dye and stain in it is not designed to dry on top of clear anything. I'm also wondering if you are letting the blotch control dry before trying to stain? I've only understood that you put on the blotch control and wipe off soon. Then you stain before the blotch control dries. If you need to color on top of any dried finish, you'll have to scuff sand it and use a GLAZE. Or you can also spray a dye, but pretty soon you won't be able to see the wood.

Re: applying stain over blotch control

#6

Re: Stain is not a glaze.......

Jerry Gibbs

I followed the instructions from Neil, which are to let the conditioner dry and then apply dye or stain.

Re: applying stain over blotch control

#7

Directions

David Yoho

I remember reading recently that you must allow the blotch control to dry before anything else. If you are following the directions to the letter and still are having problems, then I don't know what to suggest. I do know it works from experience so as long as you're following what they say to do it should.

Re: applying stain over blotch control

#8

Re: Stain is not a glaze.......

David Yoho

The directions say to apply a wet coat and let dry. Then a light sanding and apply a second coat and wait a minimum of 6 hours but overnight is better. Did you do that?

Re: applying stain over blotch control

#9

yes


Re: applying stain over blotch control

#10

OK then... *LINK*

David Yoho

When in doubt it's best to go to the horse's mouth. Try posting your problem over on Charles Neil's forum and see what he says.


http://charlesneilwoodworking.com/freeforum/index.php

Re: applying stain over blotch control

#11

the problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

we don't know what the problem is. If the surface preparation is poor no blotch control product is going to fix the problem. At the other extreme, something figured is not going to be made plain. Perhaps for the desired effect a pigment stain is inappropriate. We can't provide reliable advice until the problem is better defined, with a picture for example.

Personally I have never had occasion to need blotch control on furniture. It is handy on house trim where perfect surface preparation is impractical.

Re: applying stain over blotch control

#12

Re: the problem

David Yoho

Bill, while your methods serve well, there are many times when I think a product such as the one offered by Charles Neil comes in handy. There are certainly those species of woods that are known to be prone to blotch. Cherry and pine instantly come to mind. For a lot of folks, using a product such as this eliminates the issue the easiest way.

I don't think I'd ever use it on a figured wood like curly maple as it's a case where you would want the figure to stand out.

One of the best uses I've seen for the CN product is when you have glued up a panel from cherry where the individual boards have a slightly different coloration from each other (darker to lighter). The blotch control allows the finish to look uniform.

Another use I've seen that works is when there's a little sap wood (cherry or walnut) you couldn't work around. The CN Blotch Control will allow the finish to look uniform there too. You wouldn't know the sap wood was even there in the finished product.

I have several cans of this stuff in my arsenal of finishing products and have used it when necessary. It works for me and has made a difference in the end result whenever I have used it.

Re: applying stain over blotch control

#13

Ellis Walentine

About wood conditioner *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Over the years, I've talked with Michael Dresdner and Jeff Jewitt about how to use wood conditioner, and they both say that you should *not* let it dry prior to applying the stain. Just to be sure, I checked Jeff's book to confirm his advice, and I also looked up a Dresdner magazine column that I edited back in '94. (See link below.)

Personally, I've always put on the conditioner, waited a few minutes, then wiped off the excess and stained immediately. It always worked for me.

Then again, you have Bob Flexner, who advocates letting the conditioner dry overnight. I've never found that this approach works as well.

I suggest you try staining while the conditioner is still moist. And, never let pigment stain dry on the wood, regardless of what it's being applied over.

Ellis Walentine


Blotch-Free Staining

Re: applying stain over blotch control

#14

The reason for the confusion

Michael Dresdner

Back in the day when you were my editor, there was only one type of blotch controlling wood conditioner on the market; an oil based one, either bought or home made. The only way it works is by flooding it on very liberally, wiping it off, then staining immediately while the conditioner was still wet. This works ONLY for oil based stains. The reason it works is that the oil based conditioner is essential uncolored stain. Blotching means the wood wants to preferentially absorb more stain in some areas (typically showing end grain, which occurs on flats as well as ends). If the wood first absorbs "clear" stain (ie. wood conditioner) it is then unable to absorb excess colored stain in those areas. The result is a more even, but less intense, coloration throughout.

What has muddied the waters is that now there is both waterbased and non-oil solvent based "wood conditioner" which is meant to be applied evenly, then allowed to dry. In short, they are using the same term for something that works very differently. In this case, what's happening is that you are partially sealing the wood with a very thin (we used to call it a piss coat) layer of finish, so that the stain is going over partially sealed wood. It, too, can sometimes help make staining more uniform, and it works on non-oil based stains as well. This could be the source of at least some of the confusion.

It should be noted that you CAN use stain, either colored or "clear," to partially seal wood before a colored stain application. In other words, you could let conditioner dry and it might work to some degree, but it is not designed that way and IMO is far less consistent and far less effective.

By the way, another common home made option is to use thin shellac to partially seal wood prior to staining. It, too, works, but has the same problems as any drying conditioner -- if you put on too much, it blocks the stain entirely, and if you put on too little, it does almost nothing.

Oil based wood conditioner is designed to be more or less foolproof, and not require, as does shellac or other "drying" conditioners, the experience of knowing exactly how much to apply.