The reason for the confusion
Michael Dresdner
Back in the day when you were my editor, there was only one type of blotch controlling wood conditioner on the market; an oil based one, either bought or home made. The only way it works is by flooding it on very liberally, wiping it off, then staining immediately while the conditioner was still wet. This works ONLY for oil based stains. The reason it works is that the oil based conditioner is essential uncolored stain. Blotching means the wood wants to preferentially absorb more stain in some areas (typically showing end grain, which occurs on flats as well as ends). If the wood first absorbs "clear" stain (ie. wood conditioner) it is then unable to absorb excess colored stain in those areas. The result is a more even, but less intense, coloration throughout.
What has muddied the waters is that now there is both waterbased and non-oil solvent based "wood conditioner" which is meant to be applied evenly, then allowed to dry. In short, they are using the same term for something that works very differently. In this case, what's happening is that you are partially sealing the wood with a very thin (we used to call it a piss coat) layer of finish, so that the stain is going over partially sealed wood. It, too, can sometimes help make staining more uniform, and it works on non-oil based stains as well. This could be the source of at least some of the confusion.
It should be noted that you CAN use stain, either colored or "clear," to partially seal wood before a colored stain application. In other words, you could let conditioner dry and it might work to some degree, but it is not designed that way and IMO is far less consistent and far less effective.
By the way, another common home made option is to use thin shellac to partially seal wood prior to staining. It, too, works, but has the same problems as any drying conditioner -- if you put on too much, it blocks the stain entirely, and if you put on too little, it does almost nothing.
Oil based wood conditioner is designed to be more or less foolproof, and not require, as does shellac or other "drying" conditioners, the experience of knowing exactly how much to apply.