Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

Posts

How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#1

How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Of the several novel terms encountered in the glossary in a post below Hoppus stuck in my mind for contemplation. I have an inventory for the estate of J. Hibbard who died in 1737. His lumber is tallied in "feet", presumably bd.ft. One is to conclude that the colonies didn't invent bd.ft. as part of the Independence movement. Measuring in 12ths of a cubic ft makes practical sense, considering how the task of tallying a pile of lumber could be approached. Presumably bd.ft. was common to the mother country as well, at the time. So where did this thing called Hoppus come from and why? Must we await the book for an answer?

The rounding errors involved in using a ruler scaled in Hoppuses would become intolerable. Ditto for cubic meters. So how does one measure lumber precisely other than in bd.ft? What device is used and how is it used. (Use of the lumber stick to tally bd.ft. is described in my Article titled "Where Hardwood Lumber Comes From")

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#2

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?  *LINK*

Henry Higginbotham

I've never heard of it, either, so my knowledge is limited to the scant Wikipedia entry. I gather that it was an attempt to measure useful yield from standing timber, or maybe from felled trees.

I'm curious about your comment regarding rounding errors, especially with metric. Could you elaborate?


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoppus

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#3

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?  *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons

Here is the book by Hoppus explaining his methods and with tables.


http://books.google.co.uk/books?hl=en&id=M7tJAAAAIAAJ&dq=edward+hoppus&printsec=frontcover&source=web&ots=Ll9lRxtpY9&sig=geWnGpl8ZBg4uy9kE2wZG_R0Kxg&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=2&ct=result#PPT10,M1

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#4

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

Sgian Dubh

You'll need to read the book for simple explanations for a host of things Bill, including this subject ... but if it gets published you are one of the few people I've promised a free copy to anyway in acknowledgement for the help you've provided in the past, but here goes anyway. I think the explanation below is definitely easier to follow than the one in Patrick's link! (That was a tongue in cheek joke, by the way.)

Hoppus Feet (h ft) is the system devised by the English surveyor Edward Hoppus and appeared in a 1736 manual. It’s been in use by British foresters since then. It is said now to be redundant because the British timber industry converted to metric measure in 1971. This might be true but I still buy wood by the cubic foot, and timber merchants are as adept as I am at converting between metric and imperial units. As we buyers and sellers of wood are in the habit of converting between units of measure it’s useful to know that conversions exist between Hoppus feet and cubic metres, viz., one Hoppus foot equals 1.273 true ft³ and 27.74 h ft = 1 m³. 1 h ft = 0.03605m³. A Hoppus foot is roughly 21 percent less than a true cubic foot. There is an allowance built in to the h ft for the loss of material during the milling of a butt or log. For comparison a cubic metre is the same as 35.31 true cubic feet, which is almost the same as 424 board feet, with board feet (bd ft) being the standard measure of wood or lumber in the US where a bd ft, is 1/12 of a cubic foot.

Hoppus Feet

A calibrated girth tape takes log measurements. The user wraps the tape around the log and reads off the Quarter Girth (QG) in inches from the scale. The Hoppus Feet yield of hardwood round logs (sawlogs) and veneer logs is calculated by taking 1/4 of the logs girth in inches at its midpoint in the length, squaring the result and dividing this by 144. Finally the number of log length feet multiplies the result of the previous sum. The formula is written: Hoppus Volume (h ft) = ((Mid Quarter Girth in inches)²/144) X Length in Feet.

To put some numbers to this formula, let’s say the girth of a 16 foot long log measured at the midpoint of the length is 69 inches. Wrapping the calibrated girth tape around the log provides a reading of 17.25 inches. This, incidentally, is equivalent to a circle of 22 inches diameter, although here of course we’re not dealing with a perfect circle, we’re dealing with a rough log.

Example Sum 1: (17.25² / 144) X 16 ft = 33.06 h ft. For those more familiar with board feet (bd ft) i.e., primarily North Americans, multiply the result by 12, thus 33.06 X 12 = 397 bd ft.

Example Sum 2: A log 16 feet long with a 38 inch mid-length girth, i.e., a quarter girth of 9.5 inches as read by the calibrated tape. Calculate: (9.5² / 144) X 16 ft = 10 h ft or 120 bd ft. This log would have a theoretical mid length diameter of approximately 12” if it were a true circle.

There. Clear as a bell I assume, and I really don't think this sort of information about timber technology is at all esoteric, a charge I find both amusing and intriguing in Clint Searl's response in my thread on the manuscript I've finished, where he reckoned 99% of the subject matter listed in my Table of Contents was "too esoteric". That response would lead most readers to conclude that Clint has almost no interest in woodworking at all, but I really don't think that's the case, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#5

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

Patrick Gibbons

I'm impressed with the brain power it took for Hoppus to develop a way to estimate volumes of resources. A practical application of mathematics.

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#6

Interesting but confused

Don Orr

Thanks for the explanation-thorough as always and easy to understand..

I'm confused where you described volume measurements. You said that 1 Hoppus foot is equal to 1.273 true cubic feet and then state that 1 Hoppus foot is 21 % less than a true cubic foot. How can that be ? Maybe a typo ?

And I did not respond to the earlier thread about your book but I would most likely buy it.

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#7

Re: Interesting but confused

Sgian Dubh

"I'm confused where you described volume measurements. You said that 1 Hoppus foot is equal to 1.273 true cubic feet and then state that 1 Hoppus foot is 21 % less than a true cubic foot. How can that be ? Maybe a typo?"

You are right, it was a typo and thanks for picking it up. The original text reads:

"A Hoppus foot is roughly 21 percent greater than a true cubic foot including an allowance built in to the h ft for the loss of material during the milling of a butt or log."

I'm not quite sure how or why I changed greater to lesser! Maybe it was a brain burp. Slainte.

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#8

PRACTICALLY, How does one measure in Hoppus feet? 

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.






The pictures show two typical log yard situations, a pile of logs, and graders grading and measuring individual logs. With a log rule calibrated in Doyle, Schribner or International scales one merely lays the ruler across the small end of the log and the bdft yield is read from the rule. To employ a measurement that involves measuring a circumference either the log needs to be elevated or a trench dug under it or if standing one needs a ladder that would enable one to reach up 9' to measure the standard 16' log from a tree. I don't see a how this measure is practically applied.

And again, how does one measure cubic feet or meters? Are there rules calibrated in 0.01 cubic meter or what ever. Or is some surface measure made and then the cubic meters calculated. And then what is done with American made lumber that arrives measured in bdft? And how , why, and when did England abandon the bdft obviously used in colonial times?

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#9

Re: PRACTICALLY, How does one measure in Hoppus fe

Sgian Dubh

Bill, I can't tell you of the practicalities of wrapping a tape around the log, but perhaps they were measured in an elevated position, or as they were lifted onto carts, maybe they were even measured as they were manoeuvred over a saw pit or other set up for boarding up the log.

As to bd ft historically being a measure here in the UK that's surely speculation on your part. Perhaps the American colonists devised the system for their own convenience, either before or after the country became independent and it stuck. I'd never heard of bd ft until I worked in the US some twenty years ago. Cubic feet is the long established system of measure here in the UK until the "official" adoption of the metric system about 40 years ago. In theory the Imperial measures are history in this country, but we can still buy wood in cubic feet, as well as by the cubic metre, and we still talk of pints, ounces, pounds, etc, although usage of these measures are diminishing slowly.

Wood imported from the US is sold to the client here by the cubic metre or by the cubic foot. We Brits seem to be very flexible when it comes to systems of measure - we convert readily from one to the other. And it's also possible the Americans export their wood overseas and give the volume in cubic metres. After all, converting bd ft to cubic metres is a very simple calculation, i.e., 424 bd ft = 1 m³, so 8,225 bd ft = 19.47 m³, etc, and converting bd ft to ft³ is even easier, i.e., bd ft/ 12 = ft³.

I don't understand your question about how you calculate cubic metres or cubic feet, apart from giving the obvious answer of determining the volume of a (perhaps roughly) rectangular object by multiplying its length X its width X its thickness, using whichever system of measure you prefer to work in, e.g., inches, metres, royal cubits, feet, nautical miles, etc. Perhaps you are referring to the tape used to measure the circumference of a log to determine its quarter girth, but I'm not sure? Slainte.

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#10

Re: PRACTICALLY, How does one measure in Hoppus fe

Patrick Gibbons

Bill, look at Hoppus' book at the link I gave above. One does not measure around a log. One takes a measure of thickness and width which can be converted, using one of the tables, to a square equivalent and that with the length will give you your Hoppus foot measurement. The log or cutting can be measured as it lays.

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#11

clarification of the question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



If someone is faced with tallying 87 boards, say a buyer of said boards, how is the tally done to yield a value in cubic feet or meters? In bd ft it would be done in less than 5 minutes employing a lumber rule and a tally book as illustrated in the picture. There must be some procedure equally fast.

Additionally, how is 4/4 lumber, which in fact will be about 1 1/8 to 1 1/16" thick tallied in cu ft or cu m? Ditto for 4/4 planed to 13/16 or its metric equivalent? In other words is a cu ft of lumber derived by calculation from a measured surface area or is there a means of measuring actual volume quickly that I am not seeing? Alternatively, if I purchase a cu ft of surfaced 3/4" lumber am I getting 12 bd ft?

Given that for furniture use it is the surface area a piece of lumber covers that is most relevant it is curious that volume became the metric for trade. I wonder if the cuft resulted from the fact that building in England was with post and beam where the volume is the relevant metric. Perhaps in the lumber rich colonies most lumber was sawed into boards where the surface measure was most relevant and hence bdft became the preferred metric.

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#12

Re: PRACTICALLY, How does one measure in Hoppus fe

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When I read the section on logs it called for measuring the girth which requires an elevated log. It is unclear how the tables handle the issue of bark on the log.

While these historically interesting tables would be handy for making volume estimates in cases where that would be important I don't see any practical application in hardwood lumber production.

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#13

Re: clarification of the question

Sgian Dubh

"Additionally, how is 4/4 lumber, which in fact will be about 1 1/8 to 1 1/16" thick tallied in cu ft or cu m? Ditto for 4/4 planed to 13/16 or its metric equivalent? In other words is a cu ft of lumber derived by calculation from a measured surface area or is there a means of measuring actual volume quickly that I am not seeing? Alternatively, if I purchase a cu ft of surfaced 3/4" lumber am I getting 12 bd ft?"

Generally, where I buy rough sawn wood, the merchant takes a measure across the board and, knowing the thickness and length, they mentally arrive at a volume. They do this all day, every day so they're good at it, but I need a calculator. If the board is waney edged and tapered they most often take a measure across the narrower face under the bark roughly 1/3 up from the wide end, and use this width as the average width for the whole board. Then they do the same sum as before, i.e., multiply by width and thickness. To be honest I think these guys do it so often they simply carry the numbers in their head, because they're darned quick about it!

With regard to our equivalent of your 4/4 we talk of 1" rough sawn, and rough sawn is cut a bit thick, just as in the US to allow for shrinkage during drying. Milled boards are commonly sold as PAR (planed all round), and usually sold in "running" feet or "running" metres: for example softwood PAR to 19 mm T X 50 mm W is sold at a price per "running " metre. Obviously the 19 mm came out of stuff that was 25 mm (~1") thick after drying, so you pay for that and the machining to the finished dimension. So, after that explanation, which I hope was clear enough, in response to your question "if I purchase a cu ft of surfaced 3/4" lumber am I getting 12 bd ft", the answer is no. Slainte.

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#14

Re: PRACTICALLY, How does one measure in Hoppus fe

Sgian Dubh

"While these historically interesting tables would be handy for making volume estimates in cases where that would be important I don't see any practical application in hardwood lumber production.

Aren't estimates of yield, i.e., volume of sawn wood per log universally useful though Bill? Surely a mill owner wants to know roughly what sort of volume he or she might expect to attain from a felled saw log if it is (or they are) being purchased either felled or on the stump? Or are we talking at cross purposes here? Slainte.

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#15

more clarification

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I don't see any practical application in hardwood lumber production"...... for the Hoppus tables or method.

It is however an interesting exercise in solid geometry.

There is no place in the process where the girth of a log can be easily measured. Even when cursing timber girth is not used. Rather diameter at breast height (DBH) is measured and bdft calculated from this measure by means of a table or rule adjusted for "form class" (taper). In fact one clever stick is used to measure DBH and the number of 16 foot longs in the standing tree. From these values a bdft yield is obtained. Every forestry student has done this in their field exercises. It is quite easy to learn. Once on the log yard the logs will be measured(and maybe bar coded) with a log rule as illustrated in an earlier picture.

Re: How does one measure in Hoppus feet?

#16

Re: more clarification

Sgian Dubh

""I don't see any practical application in hardwood lumber production"...... for the Hoppus tables or method. "

On the other hand, Hoppus must have seen a value in being able to estimate yield from a log (and a raft of other applications) and devised a method for doing so. I have to assume loggers, wood buyers, mill operations, timber wholesalers and the like in the UK must have found it useful in the trade they undertook otherwise the system of measure he devised would not have survived until the present day. I understand it's rarely used now because other means have been devised to to the job, primarily in SI units. Slainte.