Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

Posts

Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#1

Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

Carmen

I just finished a cedar chest and polyurethaned both sides of the bottom of the chest and the floating tray above. I'm not sure about using yellow glue to secure the cedar planks to the bottoms. I'd rather not use nails. Is it OK to use yellow glue, or do I need to use some other kind of adhesive?

Thanks in advance!

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#2

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

Henry W

I'm not sure I have all of hte parts you name straight, but I think the question is:

"Can I use glue on a surface that has a polyurethane coating on it?"

My answer is: No, not if you expect a normal glue bond.

The polyurethane will block the glue/resin from penetrating the wood fibers, and so you will only have a glue to polyurethane bond there. That may stick, but don't expect the same adhesion as a normal wood glue joint.

Henry

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#3

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would consider a contact cement.

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#4

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

Keith Newton

It had better be a water-base contact. I think the normal solvent base/ lacquer thinner base will destroy the poly.

I was thinking of suggesting a two sided foam tape, or even a hot glue. however, I'm not sure why not tack it, but small screws would make it easily reversible.

There should be several thick adhesives in caulking gun format which would be good also, like silicone.

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#5

Are the planks the bottom or

Gary Smyth

are they resting on the bottom of the chest? If they are placed on the "floor" of the chest that has a bottom do they need glue at all? If the planks are the bottom is it too late to add a couple of long "L" shaped cleats to hold them?

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#6

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

Howard Acheson

I have used double faced carpet tape on some. On others hot melt glue works excellent.

Normal woodworking adhesives do not adhere well at all to poly surfaces. Nothing adheres well to poly surfaces.

Now a final point. It may be too late but you never want to apply an oil based finish on the inside of an enclosed space. Oil based finishes off-gas almost forever and the odor will permeate any cloth or clothing items stored inside.

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#7

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

Carmen

Thank you, all. I had a suspicion that I couldn't use wood glue here. Yes the cedar planks would be resting on the interior bottom. They're the tongue and groove type sold in the big box store. I just might tack a few here and there and let gravity do the rest.

Thank you for the note about the odor! In my rush to get done, I completely forgot!!

You guys always come through!!

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#8

Is that solvent based poly?

Dick Coers

Because solvent base polyurethane coated wood, trapped inside a box, will smell for years.

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

Jesper, Denmark

Why glue them down? Can't they just lay there?

Fitting might be a little difficult if there is a cleat for the tray.

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#10

I just successfully did it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A fully cured varnish is a crosslinked polymer and as such it is insoluable in everything. Some solvents may soften it however, but as soon as they volatilize the film will re-harden. A lengthy exposure to an aggressive solvent (paint stripper) would indeed compromise the film.

I sprayed 3M 90 high strength contact cement on a fully cured varnish surface and there was no obvious effect on the varnish. After letting the contact solvent evaporate I then attached a piece of ash to the tacky surface and it stuck.

Before attempting to attach cedar to a finished piece I would definitely test the concept with the materials at hand, but my experiment suggest it has a good chance of working.

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#11

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

paulsv

I agree with those who suggest not to glue them. I like the fresh cedar smell, and over a period of time, as the cedar oxidizes, the smell gets weaker. If you don't glue them down, you can pop out the boards and run them through your planer for a fresh surface, and get that new cedar smell back.

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#12

I wasn't thinking about the spray,

Keith Newton

As fast as it flashes, I see your point. But I wonder about brushing or rolling on a heavier coat, which may take 5~ 10 minutes down in the bottom of a chest to dry.

If Carmen chooses to use quick setting contact, I hope it wouldn't grab any of the individual parts before getting the tongue seated in it's groove. Things could get messy, pretty quick down there working in limited space.

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#13

Were I Carmen

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I'd glue up my cedar and cut for a precise fit in the chest. Then I'd thin some solvent contact cement 70/30 with lacquer thinner, don my mask, and paint a thin layer in the chest floor. I'd then put a full strength coat on the bottom of the cedar. When dry, drop the cedar 1-piece into place and put some clean bricks on it for over night. That should 'bout git'er done.

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#14

I'm convinced!

Carmen

Thanks, all. I'll be tacking them in---no glue.

C

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

#15

Re: Gluing Cedar to polyurethane surface

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Shellac will adhere well to a poly surface, and will also seal in the VOCs so they won't escape to penetrate the contents of the chest. The glue you use to tack down the cedar will also adhere better to the shellac than to the poly. Hot melt glue will give you significantly fewer problems with outgassing of its own VOCs than contact cement. I would give the inside a coat or two of shellac and then tack down the cedar with hot melt glue.