Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

Posts

A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

#1

A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

Sgian Dubh

This is to try and establish what interest there may be in the forum users here in buying a new book on timber technology. The story, briefly, is that in about 2005 I started creating illustrated texts on the subject with the idea that they could be used as learning aids for the students I teach, as well as perhaps becoming published articles in woodworking magazines. For one reason or another as the text grew I decided I didn’t wish to go down the magazine article route, and the text had grown substantial enough that it would probably best suit a book format. Additionally, once I'd decided to go down the book route, as I was writing I considered how it might be seen when judged against Hoadley's Understanding Wood, a commonly recommended text on the subject. Hoadley's book is very good, but there are parts of it that are dense and without, I believe, adequate explanation of essentials or primary knowledge that would make the text more accessible, and I have tried to address that, and to cover several subjects that he doesn't.

Anyway, eventually the manuscript was finished in June this year and it’s being considered for publication by the Timber Research and Development Association (TRADA) here in the UK. TRADA seem to be genuinely interested in publishing my manuscript but are expressing some concern about how much they would have to charge, and how many woodworkers, professional, amateur, and others would buy it for them to make a profit on the venture. The manuscript is large I admit, covers a lot of ground, and has a great many images, and the impression I’m getting is that they are thinking the price of the finished book could be in the region of £35- £50, which might seem quite a bit, but over a year that's less than a pound a week. I'm guessing, but the price in the US might be about £40- $55.

The question is therefore, would you be willing to pay this sort of amount for a book on this subject, a subject that I believe is very important in our endeavours as woodworkers? If I could get some feedback and it’s generally positive, i.e., "Yes, I think I'd buy it", I can pass this back to TRADA, and that might be just enough to help persuade them to go ahead and publish. To help you make up your mind I have attached a synopsis of the text along with the manuscript’s Table of Contents below my signature.

Thanks in advance for your consideration and feedback, and apologies for the long post. Slainte.

________________________________________

Synopsis for

Trees, Wood and Woodworking:

Wood Know-How for the Woodworker

by

Richard Jones


________________________________________

Trees, Wood and Woodworking is an academically referenced and peer reviewed manuscript on timber technology written by a woodworker for other woodworkers. Most books on wood science are a challenging read because the subject can be very involved and highly complex, and this is surely because almost all the authors are timber technologists writing mostly for their fellow wood scientists or students of the subject. The primary driver for writing the manuscript was to create a text for an international readership that makes timber technology accessible to those without a scientific background, but perhaps with some knowledge of the subject through being an existing professional woodworker, or for those beginning a career in woodworking, along with catering for amateur woodworkers and even the general reader with an interest in the field. Significant effort has been expended to find ways to explain those elements of the subject that are especially challenging through, for example, such means as analogies, explanation of terminology and technical terms where required, and clear examples used in various formulae and calculations.

Core subjects include the physiology of trees, their worldwide distribution; tree felling, calculating log yield, log conversion, seasoning methods and drying faults. The subjects of water and wood along with wood movement and stability are discussed with sample calculations for wood expansion and contraction, along with appearance grading and strength grading, as well as fungi and wood, and insect pests and wood. Characteristics of timber are outlined, e.g., figure, texture, knots, shakes, et cetera, along with issues relating to wood strength and its use in structures and concluding with a section on ecological and environmental issues relating to trees, forests, wood use, et cetera. In addition to tackling these core topics the text also looks briefly at such subjects as socio-political issues, balanoculture, ancient trees and forests, deforestation in antiquity, the effect of The Black Death on forest regeneration in Europe, et cetera, with the purpose of rounding out a woodworker’s knowledge in the subject, supplemented by links through quotations and the bibliography to further reading.

The text, in its current draft form, is illustrated with approximately 300 photographs and 120 figures (tables, charts, sketches, et cetera), and, including the bibliography, glossary, index, et cetera, the word count amounts to a little over 170,000.

Please see the Table of Contents below listing all the subjects covered.

Table of Contents

Table of Figures______________________________________________________ 9

Acknowledgements__________________________________________________ 14

Foreword_________________________________________________________ 16

Section 1 Introduction________________________________________________ 18

1.1 The Ubiquitous Oak______________________________________________ 21

1.2 Balanoculture___________________________________________________ 24

1.3 Oak: Partner of Mankind_________________________________________ 26

1.4 United Kingdom of Great Britain Tree Cover_________________________ 30

1.5 The Romans and Later Centuries___________________________________ 31

Religion, Forests and Ancient Trees_________________________________ 33

1.6 The ‘Baltic Problem’______________________________________________ 33

1.7 Tree History, Oddities, and Tree Migrations__________________________ 35

The Wollemi Pine________________________________________________ 36

1.8 The Latin Binomial System________________________________________ 39

Section 1 References_________________________________________________ 42

Section 2. Tree Distribution___________________________________________ 44

2.1 Equatorial rainforest_____________________________________________ 44

2.2 Montane Tropics________________________________________________ 44

2.3 Monsoon Forest_________________________________________________ 45

2.4 Savannah and Desert____________________________________________ 45

2.5 Mediterranean Forest_____________________________________________ 46

2.6 Temperate Forest________________________________________________ 46

2.7 Boreal Forest and the Taiga________________________________________ 46

2.8 Tundra________________________________________________________ 46

Section 3. Tree Classification, Growth and Structure._____________________ 48

3.1 Log Cross Section._______________________________________________ 51

3.2 Gymnosperms and Angiosperms- Essential Differences_________________ 54

3.2.1 Gymnosperms.______________________________________________ 54

3.2.2 Angiosperms._______________________________________________ 55

Section 3 References_________________________________________________ 55

Section 4. Roots, Leaves, Seeds, Flowers, Germination, Transpiration, Woodland Regeneration 56

4.1 Roots._________________________________________________________ 56

4.2 Buds.__________________________________________________________ 62

4.3 Leaves.________________________________________________________ 64

4.4 Flowers._______________________________________________________ 66

4.5 Seeds and Germination___________________________________________ 68

4.5.1 Acorn Distribution__________________________________________ 70

4.6 Transpirational Pull and Root Pressure______________________________ 72

4.7 Woodland Regeneration__________________________________________ 74

4.8 Characteristics Found in Deciduous Trees____________________________ 75

Section 4 References_________________________________________________ 78

Section 5. Felling, Conversion and Yield________________________________ 79

5.1 Viable wood for conversion._______________________________________ 79

5.1 Felling, Logging, Harvesting_______________________________________ 83

5.2 Conversion of Wood_____________________________________________ 87

5.2.1 Typical sawing sequence of sawlogs in North America.____________ 93

5.2.1.1 A Round-Up of Selected Sawmills__________________________ 94

5.2.1.2 Nidd Valley Saw Mills Photo Essay_________________________ 95

5.2.1.3 Bandsaw Blade Maintenance at Nidd Valley Saw Mill_________ 96

5.3 Measuring Log Yield_____________________________________________ 96

5.4 Hoppus Feet____________________________________________________ 99

5.5 Doyle Scale_____________________________________________________ 99

Section 5 References________________________________________________ 102

Section 6. Water, Water Vapour and Wood_____________________________ 103

6.1 Atmospheric Humidity__________________________________________ 103

6.2 Water in Wood.________________________________________________ 108

6.3 Hysteresis_____________________________________________________ 113

6.4 Moisture Gain and Loss in Wood- An Analogy.______________________ 113

6.5 Fibre Saturation Point___________________________________________ 114

6.6 Measuring Wood Moisture Content________________________________ 116

6.7 Microwave Oven Drying________________________________________ 119

6.8 Moisture Meters________________________________________________ 122

6.9 Green Wood Use and Chair Bodging_______________________________ 124

6.10 Wood Moisture Content Percentages and Appropriate Timber Use_____ 125

6.11 Atmospheric RH- Its Effect on Wood MC__________________________ 128

6.12 Allowing for Changes in Wood Moisture Content___________________ 132

6.12.1 Glued Edge Joint Failure During Panels Shrinkage_______________ 135

6.13 Moisture Content and Dimensional Change in Wood________________ 136

6.14 Tangential, Radial, Longitudinal Shrinkage_________________________ 139

6.15 Sapwood Movement and its Use in Projects________________________ 141

Section 6 References________________________________________________ 143

Section 7 Coping with Wood Movement: Dimensional Change, Distortion, Moisture Cycling and Stress Release (Kickback)____________________________________________ 145

7.1 Dimensional Change and Stability_________________________________ 147

7.2 Calculating Wood Movement_____________________________________ 149

7.3 Sample Wood Expansion and Contraction Calculations_______________ 150

7.4 Distortion- Warping, Cupping, Bowing, et cetera.____________________ 156

7.5 Wood Movement and Joinery_____________________________________ 160

7.6 Built Up Laminations____________________________________________ 162

7.7 End Grain Orientation and Panel Glue Ups__________________________ 163

7.8 Wide Boards___________________________________________________ 165

7.9 Chatoyance Considerations______________________________________ 165

7.10 Edge Joinery__________________________________________________ 167

7.10.1 Rub Joints and Cramping Pressure___________________________ 169

7.11 Storing a Panel Between Glue-Up and Use._________________________ 171

7.12 Mitres and Movement__________________________________________ 172

7.13 Moisture Cycling______________________________________________ 173

7.14 Moisture Cycling in Table and Cabinet Tops________________________ 174

7.15 Water Damage: Surface Checking and Cupping_____________________ 175

7.16 Stress Release in Wood During Ripping Operations: Kickback_________ 176

Section 7 References________________________________________________ 178

Section 8 Seasoning or Drying of Wood_______________________________ 179

8.1 Drying Wood Using Air_________________________________________ 181

8.2. Wood Moisture Content in Response to Temperature and Relative Humidity 186

8.3 Stickers and Stickering___________________________________________ 188

8.4 Air Drying____________________________________________________ 192

8.5 Advanced Air Drying Methods___________________________________ 197

8.5.1 Forced Air Drying__________________________________________ 198

8.5.2 Accelerated Air Drying______________________________________ 198

8.5.3 Low Temperature Warehouse Pre-drying_______________________ 199

8.5.4 Climate Chambers__________________________________________ 199

8.6 Wood Drying Kilns_____________________________________________ 200

8.6.1 Conventional Kiln Drying___________________________________ 200

8.6.2 Dehumidification Kilns______________________________________ 201

8.6.3 Progressive Kilns___________________________________________ 202

8.6.4 Solar Kilns________________________________________________ 202

8.7 Circulating Air, Monitors and Kiln Controls_________________________ 206

8.7.1 Moving Air in Conventional and Dehumidification Kilns__________ 206

8.7.2 Vents____________________________________________________ 207

8.7.3 Supplying Heat and Steam___________________________________ 207

8.7.4 Monitoring Chamber Conditions______________________________ 209

8.7.5 Withdrawable Monitoring Samples____________________________ 210

8.7.6 Recording Devices__________________________________________ 213

8.8 Kiln Drying Schedules___________________________________________ 213

8.9 Special Kiln Treatments__________________________________________ 215

8.9.1 Equalisation_______________________________________________ 215

8.9.2 Case-hardening Relief (Conditioning)__________________________ 215

8.9.3 Collapse Repair (Core Collapse Repair)_________________________ 216

8.9.4 Steamed and High Heat Treatment of Woods___________________ 217

8.9.4.1 Steamed Wood________________________________________ 217

8.9.4.2 High Heat Treatments__________________________________ 220

8.9.5 Keeping Pests at Home______________________________________ 222

8.10 Kiln Drying Standards__________________________________________ 223

8.10.1 Target Moisture Content for Kiln Dried Wood__________________ 223

Section 8 References________________________________________________ 225

Section 9 Drying Faults______________________________________________ 227

9.1 Case-hardening and Reverse Case-hardening________________________ 229

9.2. Seasoning Induced Wood Discolouration___________________________ 232

9.2.1 White Stain in Oak_________________________________________ 232

9.2.2 Yellow Stains______________________________________________ 233

9.2.3 Metallic Stains._____________________________________________ 233

9.2.4 Dark Core in Pale Wood Species______________________________ 233

9.2.5 Water Stains_______________________________________________ 234

Section 9 References________________________________________________ 234

Section 10 From the Kiln to the User___________________________________ 235

10.1 Green or Dry Tally?____________________________________________ 239

10.2 Visual Grading of Timber (Lumber in North America)________________ 240

10.3 American Appearance Grading__________________________________ 241

10.3.1 First and Seconds Grade (FAS)_______________________________ 243

10.3.2 FAS One Face Grade (F1F)__________________________________ 243

10.3.3 F1F Grade in Cherry and Walnut_____________________________ 243

10.3.4 Selects Grade_____________________________________________ 244

10.3.5 Prime Grade and Comsel Grade______________________________ 245

10.3.6 Number 1 Common Grade (No 1C)___________________________ 245

10.3.7 Number 2 Common Grade (No 2AC)_________________________ 246

10.4 UK Appearance Grading_______________________________________ 247

10.5 Measuring Planks or Boards in the UK____________________________ 249

10.6 Appearance Grading of Oak Grown in Mainland Europe_____________ 251

10.6.1 Boules and Selected Boards: Q-B..., and Q-S... grades____________ 252

10.6.2 Strips and Square Edged Timber: Q-S... grades__________________ 254

10.6.3 Beams: Q-P... grades_______________________________________ 254

10.7 General Wood Buying Tips______________________________________ 255

Section 10 References_______________________________________________ 257

Section 11 Fungi____________________________________________________ 258

11.1 Physiology and Structure_______________________________________ 258

11.2 Beneficial Fungi_______________________________________________ 261

11.2.1 Ectomycorrhizae__________________________________________ 261

11.2.2 Endomycorrhizae_________________________________________ 261

11.2.3 Endophytic Fungi_________________________________________ 262

11.3 Unwelcome Fungi_____________________________________________ 263

11.3.1 Sap Stain________________________________________________ 264

11.3.2 Brown Rots______________________________________________ 265

11.3.3 Dry Rot: Serpula lacrymans_________________________________ 266

11.3.4 White Rots_______________________________________________ 267

11.3.5 Armillaria fungus_________________________________________ 268

11.3.6 Soft Rots_________________________________________________ 270

11.3.7 Dote or Punk_____________________________________________ 271

11.4 ‘Beautifying’ Fungi_____________________________________________ 271

11.4.1 Brown oak and Tiger oak___________________________________ 271

11.4.2 Spalting_________________________________________________ 273

11.4.3 Green Stained Timber______________________________________ 274

11.5 Health Risks of Fungi.__________________________________________ 274

Section 11 References_______________________________________________ 276

Section 12 Insect Pests_______________________________________________ 277

12.1 Termites_____________________________________________________ 277

12.1.1 Subterranean Termites_____________________________________ 279

12.1.2 Drywood Termites_________________________________________ 283

12.1.3 Dampwood Termites_______________________________________ 283

12.2 Common Furniture Beetle- Anobium punctatum____________________ 284

12.3 Death-Watch Beetle- Xestobium rufovillosum_______________________ 287

12.4 Powder Post Beetle- Lyctus Beetle_________________________________ 289

12.5 Pinhole borers- ambrosia beetles__________________________________ 290

12.6 House Longhorn Beetle- Hylotrupes______________________________ 291

12.7 Leaf-miner Flies- Pith Fleck______________________________________ 292

12.8 Carpenter Ants (Camponotus species)_____________________________ 293

12.9 Bees and Wasps_______________________________________________ 296

12.9.1 Solitary Bees______________________________________________ 296

12.9.2 Carpenter Bees____________________________________________ 297

12.9.3 Carpenter Wasps__________________________________________ 298

12.10 Insect Pest Control, Eradication, and Deterrents____________________ 298

12.10.1 Other Insect Control Methods______________________________ 301

Section 12 References_______________________________________________ 303

Section 13 Characteristics of Timber___________________________________ 306

13.1 Grain________________________________________________________ 306

13.1.1 Figure___________________________________________________ 309

13.1.2 Texture__________________________________________________ 312

13.1.3 Colour__________________________________________________ 313

13.1.4 Lustre___________________________________________________ 316

13.2 Knots- Knot Formation and Structure_____________________________ 316

13.2.1 Knot Descriptions_________________________________________ 318

13.3 Shakes_______________________________________________________ 320

13.3.1 Radial Shakes_____________________________________________ 321

13.3.2 Tangential Shakes (Ring Shakes and Cup Shakes)_______________ 321

13.3.3 Cross Shakes_____________________________________________ 322

Section 13 References_______________________________________________ 323

Section 14. Wood Strength and Structures_____________________________ 324

14.1 Frequently Tested Strength Properties_____________________________ 324

14.1.1 Compression Parallel to the Grain____________________________ 325

14.1.2 Compression Perpendicular to the Grain_______________________ 325

14.1.3 Tension Perpendicular to the Grain___________________________ 325

14.1.4 Tension Parallel With the Grain______________________________ 326

14.1.5 Shear Parallel With the Grain________________________________ 326

14.1.6 Shear Perpendicular to the Grain_____________________________ 326

14.1.7 Impact Bending___________________________________________ 327

14.1.8 Hardness________________________________________________ 327

14.1.9 Modulus of Elasticity and Modulus of Rupture__________________ 328

14.1.10 Work to Maximum Load___________________________________ 328

14.2 Rarer Strength Properties_______________________________________ 329

14.2.1 Rolling Shear-- in plywood__________________________________ 329

14.2.2 Torsional Rigidity_________________________________________ 329

14.3 Wood Strength Testing_________________________________________ 330

14.3.1 Beam Types______________________________________________ 333

14.4 Stress, Strain and Strength______________________________________ 335

14.4.1. Compression, Tension, Shear and Torsion_____________________ 340

14.5 Additional Factors Affecting Strength_____________________________ 342

14.5.1. Creep and Duration of Load________________________________ 342

14.5.2 Fatigue__________________________________________________ 342

14.5.3 Aging___________________________________________________ 343

14.5.4 Moisture Content__________________________________________ 343

14.5.5 Temperature_____________________________________________ 344

14.5.6 Growth Ring Orientation and Strength________________________ 344

14.5.7 Brashness or Brittle Heart___________________________________ 345

14.6 Deformation in Pure Bending____________________________________ 346

Sidebar-Bending Theory Glossary and Notation in This Section_______ 349

14.6.1 Beam Carrying Capacity____________________________________ 350

14.6.1.1 Beam Load Carrying Capacity Variations_________________ 351

14.6.1.2 Beam Deflection Under Load____________________________ 353

14.7 Strength Grading of Structural Timber_____________________________ 354

Sidebar. Moisture Content of Structural Timbers in Habitable Buildings.__ 356

14.7.1 Visual Strength Grading____________________________________ 357

14.7.2 Machine Strength Grading__________________________________ 357

14.8 Structures____________________________________________________ 359

Section 14 References_______________________________________________ 366

Section 15 Ecological and Environmental Issues________________________ 368

15.1 Worldwide Forest Coverage and Wood Extraction___________________ 371

15.2 Non-Wood Forest Products (NWFPs)______________________________ 376

15.3 Wood Consumption____________________________________________ 378

15.4 Tree Planting, Ownership and Management Responsibility____________ 382

15.5 Growth of Forest Protection Efforts_______________________________ 386

15.5.1 Forest Stewardship Council (FSC)____________________________ 387

15.5.2 Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certification (PEFC)____ 391

15.5.3 Similarities and Differences Between FSC and PEFC_____________ 393

15.5.3.1 Similarities___________________________________________ 393

15.5.3.2 Differences__________________________________________ 394

15.5.5 Criticisms of FSC and PEFC_________________________________ 394

15.6 Considerate Usage of Forest Products_____________________________ 396

15.6.1 Protecting Forest Resources_________________________________ 398

Section 15 References_______________________________________________ 400

Glossary___________________________________________________________ 403

Bibliography_______________________________________________________ 428

Websites___________________________________________________________ 461

Name_________________________________________________________ 461

Subject________________________________________________________ 461

Website URL and date first accessed________________________________ 461

Appendix 1.________________________________________________________ 463

Shrinkage Factors for a Selection of Wood Species._______________________ 463

Index 465

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

#2

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

Paul in NJ

Hi Richard,

I would buy your book even though I own the Hoadly book. I have been following your posts here on WC for a long time and I like your style and breadth of knowledge. If you don't have luck with a publisher on your side of the pond you might try Lost Art Press here in the US. They have a loyal following of buyers for their books and the quality of the books they publish is superb.

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

#3

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Hi Richard,

Yes I'd buy the book.

I always enjoy buying a book authored by someone I know. (even if it's only through your posts here on WC over many years). In reading those posts, I've come to feel like i know you and have great respect for your work, and appreciate your contributions to woodworking in general. As to the subject, though I've been a hobby WW all my life, my knowledge of the material is rudimentary at best and at present I find myself wanting to learn more details.

So again, YES reserve a copy for me!

Bob in NJ

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

#4

Sorry, not in present form

Gary Smyth

Since you asked. For me it’s not the price. It’s the shotgun approach to all things wood. As a reference I’m of the opinion that this work (and it is a work) could be edited by 50%. Topics identified as “socio-political issues, balanoculture, ancient trees and forests, deforestation in antiquity, the effect of The Black Death on forest regeneration in Europe, et cetera” have no interest to me when I’m looking for woodworking answers.

Sections 5 – 10- and portions of 13 and 14, and glossary & shrinkage charts, show me interest. I can't speak to your photos and charts. Those section/pages strike me as more important to the non-researcher woodworker. The remainder would, for me, be mostly a $55 paperweight. Pros and students information ought to be different. I have not seen your work. I can not provide anything other than an opinion based on a short look at what has been presented. I do not wish to discourage you from pushing hard to get published what you feel is critical information for an intended scholar. Throughout my own academic career I have had my share of words revised, edited, and deleted. I've won some and lost more. It happens. And in publishing, marketers have as much or more to say as authors and editors. Let’s see what others think. I truly wish you well with your effort.

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

#5

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

Merle

If TRADA won't publish your book, you might try self publishing on the internet. If you google "internet self publishing" you will get many hits describing the process.

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

#6

Yes I would buy it!

don stephan

Just my opinion, woodworkers in general do not know enough about the material they use. And not just the basics like cross grain construction, differential shrinkage rates, and seasonal movement. Shoppers expect but don't like poor quality of factory furniture, and I see more and more people who respect a better understanding of wood; matching grain; using flat, rift and quartered appropriately; and so much more. What is that swirl of color (mineral stain, what causes it, how to blend it into heartwood and sapwood, and so much more. If someone just wants to make weekend projects that may or may not stand up to use, no need to undrestand wood; for the rest of us, knowledge is our friend. And Hoadley's books, as helpful as they are, leave me in the dark at times. There is a definite need for more books like Hoadley's, and I fervently hope you are able to have it published.

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

#7

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In general yes. There are topics I was surprised to encounter. I would say at this point that if the target audience is the woodworker that a woodworker book editor would be of great value in helping to decide on what to include and how to reach a price point.

If your illustrated posts on WC are any indication a second book on woodoworking techniques would be even more welcome.

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

#8

Definitely - but

Howard in Toronto

As others have pointed out, why not self-publish.

There are a few ways to do so. All of them driven by producing only what you need as you make sales.

Feel free to get in touch if you'd like to be pointed in useful and practical directions.

All the best.

Howard

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

#9

Re: Sorry, not in present form

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

So, don't read the parts that don't interest you. But, don't try to censor it for the rest of us, who will find much of the rest of it of interest or even invaluable. The more people Richard can interest in the whole book, by including more subject matter and more in depth information, the lower the cost to everyone. While I like building furniture one piece at a time, each one different, mass production makes sense for publications. I think Gutenberg figured that out centuries ago. Just because I don't use the slow lane on the interstate, doesn't mean I don't appreciate its presence, since it keeps the slowheads out of the way of those of us who are going somewhere (usually).

Yes, I would buy your book, Richard. Just don't forget those of us who still prefer Imperial units. It's easy enough to include two systems of measurement.

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

#10

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

Patrick Gibbons

I would be very interested in the historical material. Past use of resources directly influences their present use. The work seems to have a balance geographically and would speak to those subjects that apply to North America. It also covers many subjects that are universal. All in all, there is a lot of information here to which I'd appreciate the access. In the U.S., would the price be $55 or £55? $55 would be no problem. £55 would be a higher price point that would probably delay my purchase. I hope it gets published.

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

#11

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

Keith Newton

Richard, I'd like to see it in digital format, so I could get your take on some of the subjects that I've been chewing on for quite some time now. So count me in if you go that rout.

Just wondering about Plant physiology, and what instruments you have for testing, like water pressure and movement, or is this just a distillation of what you have found on the subject?

Odd that you mention structure of Deciduous Trees, without mention of Evergreen or Tropical, but I understand, if this is a work in progress.

Nice to see that you devoted space for Ecological and Environmental Issues, and wondering if you had any interest in Dendrochronology, which is a subject that I find fascinating.

Also, in the chapter on defects, I wonder if you mention Woodpecker marks as a defect, or if you could mention that there are some of us out here with a different aesthetic eye, who view those peck and mineral streaks as beauty marks, rather than blemishes. Also, you might add that those sap wells do have other benefits to nature, like nourishment for early arrival Humming birds, and plenty of insects that feed other bird species through the Winter here in the South.

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

#12

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

Sgian Dubh

Many thanks for the comments. They are all useful. I'll pick up on a few of them.

Self publishing. This might be an option, but at this point I'm resisting it because I'd really rather have a good editor on my side to improve the draft manuscript, but hopefully not too much improvement! I like to think I write reasonably well to start with. Editors, and their publishing houses have a marketing arm and know all the people to contact to negotiate deals, etc-- this is something I know nothing about, except that I'm aware it can be a real struggle for the independent publisher.

The Lost Art Press only seems to have a North American distribution network, which rather limits opportunities to sell outside that continent. Taunton I suppose might be interested, if they didn't already publish Hoadley's Understanding Wood. I wonder how willing they would be to publish something they might consider a rival to that, although there are distinct differences in many of the subjects discussed?

Bill, interesting to read that you found some of the subjects "surprising".

Keith, I didn't separate out Tropical and Evergreen trees, because they are covered in discussions about deciduous trees (angiosperms) and softwood (gymnosperms). I also didn't discuss some of the issues you mentioned such as woodpecker damage, but mineral streaks, etc are discussed. On plant physiology, root pressure, transpirational pull, etc, the discussion is a generalised one on the various mechanisms. I didn't undertake measurements. It's a large manuscript already, and trying to decide what to leave out was as difficult as what to include. If I had the patience I suspect I could have created something that is much bigger, but I think this is big enough already! Slainte.

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

#13

Clint Searl

Too esoteric for the 99%


Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

#14

Re: A new timber tech book. Would you buy it?

don stephan

Editorial comments can be very useful, but one thing that makes some of your explanations and comments so enjoyable is your sense of humour. I'd hate to see some ham fisted editor try to take out your personalised style. And you can keep the quaint Great Britain spelling in.