OK, I need to build a chest for my nephew and I am waiting for repair parts for my planer. I have the drawer stock milled. What do you think about building the drawers first and then the chest. I am planing on making dove tailed drawers (Leigh jig).
And as an aside, what do you think of using ball bearing full extension Under mount runners?
I've only built one small chest but I think building the drawers first is asking for at best a lot of fiddling and fitting. A small size difference would mean either planning them down if too large or some sort of shimming if too small.
We went down to the Texas Furniture Makers show in Kerrville and saw some very high end custom furniture. Just about every type of drawer was shown. One thing I noticed and it is just my opinion those with ball bearing slides lacked a little in quality. FWIW, a couple pieces also didn't seem up there because the maker stopped short when finishing. One last note. If there was a category called worst beginning apprentice the skill demonstrated in that piece would have been beyond my skill.
In my mind ball bearing slides belong in the kitchen and shop not in furniture.
I agree with you about the ball bearing slides. I was wondering if I was an old Fuddy Duddy, having grown up in a house full of antiques. Maybe I was not keeping up with the time an slides had finally arrived.
Basically trying to figure out how to move this project forward, waiting for the parts.
While I certainly would build the frame first and then the drawers to fit, I don't think there is any reason not to do it the other way around if you are careful.
If you had to change the carcass for the drawers you would have a real problem.
I asked my wife about ball-bearing slides. She loves them in the kitchen since they are full extension and/or easy to roll. For bedroom furniture she says it wouldn't be much of an advantage although having a full extension on the bottom or lower drawers might be helpful to see what is in the back without standing on your head.
I got a chuckle on your new post today. I've worked a corporate job for 30+ years. Design by committee is not an effective method of design or decision making. You're in for a long project if you get 10 opinions on every aspect on this piece of furniture. Just an opinion, but I learned this craft long before there was an internet "crutch", it can be done!
I'd find it difficult to work in reverse order as you suggest but I find it hard enough working in forward order. As for slides, the visible side slides would be just too jarring for me but you got me to thinking about the 'invisible' bottom slides and I don't see where they would look any different than normal if one was doing the proper style of drawers to accommodate them -- basically the drawer front would have to extend downward far enough to cover the extra gap required by the slides. My experiences with furniture (non-cabinet) drawers are limited to flush, tightly-fitted dovetailed box types and those would clearly not work with any sort of slide I've ever seen.
If your nephew is a youngster, having built a number of items for my children over the years, I will say that full extension drawers are a plus for kids' furniture. Undermounts however, may not have the weight capacity that is appropriate to handle what kids will drop in them.
Purists will view my comment as making "cabinetry" rather than "furniture", but kids outgrow their "furniture" about as fast as their sneakers. "But Grandpa made that specially for you" doesn't carry much weight when young taste goes in another direction.
I have done it both ways and found it about the same amount of work. If you are looking for flush drawers with a small reveal, e.g., a tight fit, then you probably want to build the carcass first and then, if needed, build the drawers to fit with just a small bit of planing - and I agree, you probably don't want slides for that style.
If you are doing overlay drawers and using slides, then you have enough wiggle room to do pretty much whatever you want.
In either case, it would certainly be cool to make the drawers up to the dry fit stage while you are waiting for parts.
Barry, while I suppose one could make the drawers first and make it work, I'm just not in that camp. The logic of drawers first simply doesn't compute in my brain. I learned early on as a beginner some lessons that changed the way I approach order whenever I build any casework with drawers.
I started out building from plans but with my own tweaks. I moved on to building from my own custom plans, which I painstakingly poured over during drawing. One of my early lessons about proper fitting drawers, no matter the type, was sometimes the measurements of the openings on the actual project didn't work out like they did on paper. This caused me to build the casework first, take exact measurements for each drawer based on the openings, and build the drawers (slides or not). This is especially critical with inset drawers, or doors for that matter. Thinking about it now, it's the only way that makes sense to me. Others may do it differently but it's probably the route that avoids more possible problems.
As for the slides, I know you don't like spending more than necessary. I don't see a need for slides and wouldn't use them personally. If the drawer is built properly, there shouldn't be a need for center support a slide might offer. Also, wooden drawers have been successfully gliding on wooden drawer guides for quite some time. I wax the edges of the drawers and the runners inside the case and even large fully loaded drawers slide nicely.
David, I agree with you. I am just spinning my wheels until the parts come. Trying to turn the box inside out as it were. Drawers have worked perfectly well for a long time but then who would have thought we would have the Internet as we do now just thirty years ago? Things do change, even if very slowly here in the South. What heretic thought we would ever buy chicken already fried and let them hand it to use through the car window. Lunacy I tell you.
I guess the planer never breaks at the opportune moment.
I have a rule I follow when making almost anything. But, I definitely apply it to furniture.
When given a decision, choose the decision which if implemented provides the most degrees of freedom.
In chest of drawers, if you build the drawers first, you are eliminating a number of degrees of freedom. In effect, you are defining the range of dimensions that are the depth, the width, the height, the drawer opening sizes, the types of slides /runners you can use, and probably a few more I can't think of off the top of my head.
I would build the carcass first. You should decide on the slide runner type before doing the carcass. You may have to put in runners or support whil;e you are doing the carcass
You should decide on the slide runner type before doing the carcass.
Probably overlooked by some but a very important "rule" is to know going in which hardware you will use before starting anything. I pick what is needed and get it ordered or purchased locally together with any materials I have to buy. It makes a difference!