Shoplights
Doug Ridley
Are T12 andT8 bulbs interchangeable?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Shoplights
Doug Ridley
Are T12 andT8 bulbs interchangeable?
Re: No
Re: Shoplights
Tony - Memphis
I've been upgrading my shop lights with T8's. The ballast are not compatible, but the fixtures are (sockets are the same). I can swap out a ballast and bulb in about ten minutes. Lowes has the ballasts for about $16. Not a bad deal. The new bulbs are much brighter and use less energy. My bulbs were getting pretty old, so it’s not surprising new bulbs made a difference (not all the T8 vs T12). I have been thrilled with the new lights. I still have a few fixtures left to swap. 8 fixtures at ~$30 a swap adds up. Need to get the old bulbs to the recycler drop too...
Tony
Re: Shoplights
Jay Lombardo
No but it's easy to change the ballast out and then switch to T8's.
brightness-energy metrics
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
When it comes to light, what is important is how many lumens of light the lamp puts out. This value can be found on the lamp packaging.
There are T12 lamps that put out more light than T8 and visa versa. It all depends on the chemistry of the phosphor that converts the primary UV energy of the lamp to visible light. The T12, because of its inherently higher wattage, will put out significantly more light than a T8 for an equivalent phosphor.
For the same lumen output the T8 lamp surface will appear brighter because the surface area of the lamp is smaller. The same amount of light is illuminating a surface that is 1/3 smaller. This observation is not to be confused with the lamp putting out more total lumens of illumination.
An old T12 fixtures can be less efficient if they have the old style magnetic ballasts. I think it is correct that no T8 will have the old style less efficient ballast.
PS
Tony - Memphis
Another observation I made is that the new ballasts turn the lights on instantly. Not that it ever mattered, but it is pretty obvious when I turn on the switch.
Now that I'm thinking about it, I think I'll pick up another setup today!
Tony
many advantages of electronic(modern) ballast
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
they don't hum
they don't flicker at 60 Hz
they are more efficient
T5?
John McGaw
I've been looking forward to adding a new 4-lamp T5HO fixture to the center location in my shop, the one above the Robland machine. I got an advert from Costless Lighting which had 8ft 4-lamp T5HO strips for $68 which doesn't look bad. Of course they had similar T8 strips for only $48 so my choice might be shifting downscale (or upsize).
Re: T5?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I posted some time ago on T5HO. Two of the 4x48" units from Home Depot replaced a stack of T8 and T12 fixtures over my bench. Again....look at the lumens of output as that is what is important.
Mine are over a bench 7' off the floor, not 20' as theya re designed for. But, I do not feel any heat from them. The lamps are over 50 watt, and pricey.