Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Glued up panel warped need a fix .

Posts

Glued up panel warped need a fix .

#1

Glued up panel warped need a fix .

Mark

I glued up four ash boards into a panel that is destined to be a headboard for a bed. Due to various circumstances I got distracted from the project over the summer and the panel has now warped about an inch and half from flat. I have heard advice here before that the solution is to rip the panel down the middle joint and re glue taking the warp out

Is this viable or does it cause other problems ...like a wavy panel ? Suppose I have nothing to lose just wondering if it's worth the effort or better to start from scratch and make a new flat panel

Re: Glued up panel warped need a fix .

#2

Step 1

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It cupped because one side gained or lost more moisture than the other. This situation is often reversible by getting both sides the same moisture content.

1. Is it really a problem? This situation comes up regularly and in many cases the cup is irrelevant. For example, if this was a table top it would be pulled back flat when fastened to the frame. So, when it becomes a bed will it be held in a way that will pull it back flat? If so, don't worry about it.

2. If it cupped by gaining moisture after assembly it will likely largely flatten itself if left so air circulates to both sides. This is a common situation using KD wood. The wood is glued up at some low moisture content. The panel gets laid on a bench where the exposed surface picks up moisture and it cups. Ditto if the panel was glued in the summer when the wood was higher in moisture content and now the heat is on and one side dried out. Get "fresh air" on both sides and hope for the best.

3. If the lumber was air dried and insufficiently dried the cup will be "set" and not likely to be straightened by exposing both sides of the panel.

4. If drastic measures are called for rip out each glue joint and reassemble.

Re: Glued up panel warped need a fix .

#3

Re: Glued up panel warped need a fix .

Lars Parrington

We need specifics on how the panel is warped. Is it twist, cup, bow, a combination.

Depending on the structural design of the bed and how the panel warped, you may not need to fix it. If you are attaching posts to the sides of the headboard, they would be able to take any cup out of the panel. If those posts are then connected rigidly enough to boards that run along the sides of the bed, any twist in the panel could be straightened out.

Re: Glued up panel warped need a fix .

#4

Ellis Walentine

Take stock first

Ellis Walentine

It sounds to me like your boards weren't dry enough when you glued up this headboard. That seems reasonable, since it was summer, and the wood was at its maximum annual MC, and now it's heating season and they're on their way to their minimum MC. It's also fair to assume that these were/are flat-sawn lumber, which cups because of the differential between radial and tangential shrinkage. If all the component boards were oriented with the same side out, that would account for a large cup across the entire headboard; while if they were oriented alternately, the headboard would have a wavy appearance because of the alternating cupping direction of the individual boards.

The severity of the cup could also have been increased by the way you stored the glue-up in the interim. The best way, in my book, would have been to store it on beams or stickers, with a piece of plywood or something stickered above it, allowing good air circulation over and under it, with some weights on top to help keep it flat as it dried.

There are a lot of variables that could influence your next move.

Now that the wood has had another season to move with swings in RH, unimpeded by a finish which would slow the moisture transfer, it will be moving somewhat less than originally, so you won't be dealing with quite as dramatic a cup.

How will the headboard be joined to the corner posts of the bed? If it will be captured in a groove, and the posts are sturdy enough, they will overcome the cupping forces and keep things relatively flat. If there will be just a couple tenons on each end, they won't be able to keep things very flat.

You might want to add a couple stiffening ribs on the back of the headboard to overcome the tendency to cup again. This is a dynamic relationship, as the headboard will be shrinking and expanding over the year, as well as wanting to cup depending on the grain orientation. My usual way of handling stiffener design is to build either a convex or concave curve into the edge of the ribs so that you can pull the cup flat, depending on which side of the panel the ribs are on. The center screw is fixed and the outer ones ride in slots to accommodate wood movement.

Either way, I would rip the headboard along the original glue lines, flatten and thickness it, and joint the edges and re-glue it. Orient the boards for appearance, not to outwit the cupping action. Add stiffeners if you think it needs them, or wait to see if it starts to move again without them, then decide. And, get a coat of sealer or finish on the whole shooting match to retard further moisture exchange.

Lots to think about here. I hope some of this helps.

Ellis

Re: Glued up panel warped need a fix .

#5

Re: Glued up panel warped need a fix .

Howard Acheson

How and where did you "store" your panel? Was it in a place and position where air could freely circulate to both sides? Was it stored on top of another flat surface that impeded the flow of air over one side?

If the problem was caused by improper storage, you may be able to remove much of the warp. Stack and sticker the panel on a flat, true surface allowing air to freely circulate. Put some weight on top but be sure its stickered above the surface so the weight does not impede the air flow.

Once it is as flat as it's going to get, you will likely be able to pull it flat when you attach it to the supporting frame system.

Re: Glued up panel warped need a fix .

#6

Re: Glued up panel warped need a fix .

Mark

Thanks everyone some ideas to work with

The headboard is for a 4 poster bed and will attach to the posts by two 2.5 inch tenons on each post that will fit into mortises in the posts..no way to change this as it is a twin size bed I built years ago and the now grown up little princess wants it resized to a double. So the current mortises are what I have to work with .

I don't think the two tenon joints will be enough to force it into flat.

The panel remained stored in the clamps which were then stood on their ends with lots of air circulation but no top pressure to keep it flat .

I think I just had some high moisture content boards. They were already dressed when I bought them and maybe had not stabilized when I glued them up.

Thanks again for the suggestions

Re: Glued up panel warped need a fix .

#7

One thing you can try

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

Before you rip the boards apart, try wetting (get it good and wet) the concave side of the piece with water, then cover it overnight with plastic. In the morning you should have a flat board. Then remove the plastic, place the board on a flat surface with stickers under it and over it. Weight the board down and leave it that way for about a week if you can. That should let the moisture equalize. If it is flat get it cut and mounted in the final configuration as soon as possible.

Lee

Re: Glued up panel warped need a fix .

#8

Lee, I'm sorry, while that may flatten,

Keith Newton

it doesn't get him any closer to a good ending. Adding moisture, which will probably need to get out of the finished product is too unpredictable.

The easiest thing I've found, is to simply add some heat to the convex side. It will give up some moisture to the air, bringing it on down to match the other side. Almost any radiant heat source will do, or forced air.

I keep a little space heater out in the shop, which I blow into a improvised tent for finish drying, using a tarp. If you lay the concave side down of the floor, a bench top, or sheet-goods, while blowing warm air into a chamber, this will dry the topside pretty quickly, and probably bring it back flat.

You didn't mention wood species, but soft woods dry a lot quicker than dense woods, so keep an eye on it.

Re: Glued up panel warped need a fix .

#9

Re: Glued up panel warped need a fix .

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Given this additional information I would rip the glue joints and reglue. If you need to add a sliver to make up the width it can be on the bottom and not show. If you carefully glue up one board at a time you should be able to get the edge alignment near perfect and not loose thickness.

If you are using pipe clamps be wary of them bending and setting a cup in the panel. I am not fond of pipe clamps.