Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Chemist in the House?

Posts

Chemist in the House?

#1

Chemist in the House?

don stephan

Have black iron stains on just turned oak bowls. Oxalic acid removes the stain very easily and quickly, but the label says it is poisonous. Suggested procedure is, after applying the oxalic acid, to rinse the wood twice and then "neutralize" with baking soda solution.

Anyone a chemist that can say what results when the oxalic acid is neutralized with baking soda? Is the remainder still poisonous? After drying and sanding the bowls will be finished with three coats of mineralspirits-boiledlinseedoil-alkyd varnish which will seal the wood, but I'd still like to know whether the oxalic acid-baking soda result could be hazardous.

Re: Chemist in the House?

#2

Re: Chemist in the House?

Terry in Edmonton

The result would be calcium oxalate which is not soluble in water. As a note, oxalic acid is found in most green vegetables. While calcium oxalate is somewhat toxic very little will remain on the wood and virtually all of this will be removed in your final sanding. As to the picogram or so that would be left, spread over the item,would be well below the threshold of toxicity.

Re: Chemist in the House?

#3

Re: Chemist in the House?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

that would be sodium oxalate, not calcium, which is soluble and the reaction does not alter the amount or toxicity of the oxalate. That said the piddly amount is not to be worried about.

Re: Chemist in the House?

#4

the best way to answer these questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

type "MSDS Oxalic Acid" into Google. If reading the MSDS sheet is incomprehensible go to the WoodCentral Articles, search "MSDS" and read the article on decoding the MSDS jargon.

Re: Chemist in the House?

#5

JL

Speaking as a chemist...

JL

Bill is right about the piddly little amount. You would get more in eating a bowl of spinach. You do have the ability to digest oxalic acid.

I don't think you are talking about 15-20 grams of oxalic acid - which is about what it would take to have a lethal dose.

Re: Chemist in the House?

#6

Ellis Walentine

So, is there a way to make the residue non-toxic?

Ellis Walentine

There must be something that will reduce this residual sodium oxalate to something harmless, no?

Ellis

Re: Chemist in the House?

#7

not likely

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Sure, there are all sorts of ways of destroying oxalate in a jar. But as far as doing it on wood and not affecting the wood.....probably not. Certainly not worth the effort. Best bet would be to wash it off. Also, for those wanting to avoid all traces of this stuff it would be good to avoid rhubarb for it contains oxalic acid.

Re: Chemist in the House?

#8

So THAT's Why

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I'm "lergic" to it!

Another one of the burning questions from my youth answered. Could never understand why they'd go ruin perfectly good strawberries that way . . .

Re: Chemist in the House?

#9

another answer....yes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"There must be something that will reduce this residual sodium oxalate to something harmless, no".....

yes, dilution. Works every time. Make it a small enough amount that it becomes harmless. Nothing is toxic or harmful if the concentration is low enough. What level is harmful will be described in the MSDS. It is a safe bet the spinach greens eaten from the bowl in question will not be toxic.

Re: Chemist in the House?

#10

I agree with that

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For those bewildered, some misguided cooks mix rhubarb and strawberries. There is nothing the equal of a rhubarb pie. Rhubarb sauce triumphs over bland apple sauce. Diluting these delicacies with fruit is so wrong.

When it comes to rhubarb I am shameless. I once traveled up Rt 12 in NYS one rhubarb season searching for the telltale leaves of an unharvested rhubarb patch. Found one north of Binghamton. Found the owner and begged for some stalks, explaining how I could not grow it in TN. A true rhubarb enthusiast would understand, and my efforts were rewarded with a 25 pound bundle of stalks which we froze for future uses.

Re: Chemist in the House?

#11

Re: Beebopareebop

William Duffield

My wife's dad used to grow rhubarb here on the Cohansey, but we have been totally unsuccessful in spite of trying several times. We get a couple stalks the first season, but it never comes back, except maybe a couple runt leaves. Maybe we could blame it on climate change?

Re: Chemist in the House?

#12

Except, of course, for those of us

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Who have enough rhubarb we can mix it with whatever we feel like :D

Last year, Bill, we gave away six plants because we couldn't use it all. My beloved makes enough rhubarb jam that I have it every morning for breakfast. Not to mention pies, breads, desserts. I could go on and on, but you get the idea...

Re: Chemist in the House?

#13

Rhubarb is a weed in MN

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When I lived there I could find it everywhere, even in people's lawns. Some organism in warm soil gets it here in TN

Re: Chemist in the House?

#14

I just couldn't help myself

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I know that you know what MN is like.