Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Cedar Chest

Posts

Cedar Chest

#1

Cedar Chest

Kelly M. Robison

I am building a "hope chest" for my granddaughter for xmas. I want to line it with cedar. At this time since I am still in the design stage; not sure what the box will be made out of. Somebody said that I could use cedar strips that are used in closets for the inside of the chest. Now; my question: What is the best way to attach or fasten the cedar to the inside of the box??? This will be my first time to build a box lined with cedar. I have made some jewelry boxes in the past and just used glue to adhere the cedar to the inside; is the principal still the same????? Suggestions would be greatly appreciated; as I know that you all have a wealth of information at your fingertips.

Kelly in Port Orchard

Re: Cedar Chest

#2

brad nailer.....

Dick Coers

Two of the sides barely need anything because they will be trapped by the sides going in last. I do all the finishing first, then just tack the cedar lining in as a final assembly.

Re: Cedar Chest

#3

Re: Cedar Chest 

Gary Smyth

A hope chest and a cedar chest are not necessarily the same thing. They can be but they do not have to be the same. If it not specifically requested for a cedar chest I’d make a regular chest and then perhaps add the 3/8” cedar tongue and groove paneling planks as a second layer on the chest bottom. Eastern red cedar has been determined to be a bug repellant but it is not toxic. I could not get the link to work but check it out here -- Repellency of Aromatic Eastern Redcedar to Urban Pests

by Arthur G. Appel, Ph.D. Department of Entomology

Auburn University, Alabama --Abstract | Insects & Apparatus | Toxicity Testing | Analysis | Results & Discussion

It is aromatic. But you don’t have to line the whole box. You could just place the cedar on the bottom of the box. When the chest is closed it will have the same effect as a fully lined box. Of course stuff touching the cedar will get the heaviest dose. Using paneling planks in this manner, when the aroma fades after a period of time it will be easy to pull up the planks turn them over and/or do a quick sanding for renewed life. If you fit the tongue and groove planks on the bottom, you can save money on the cedar and you will not have to fasten them using nails or glue. Note: Cedar oil is also available rather than planks. If the chest you build has a sliding tray on runners, the tray also can have cedar paneling on its bottom. Finally, some people are sensitive to the odor of cedar and the contents of the chest will carry cedar smell for a period of time. Having removable cedar may be helpful at a forward time.

Re: Cedar Chest

#4

Very Interesting......

Barry Irby

Years ago I talked to an entomologist At Virginia Tech. He said there was no evidence that the cedar did anything. He said it did not seem to repel bugs and certainly did not kill them. He was very familiar with Lane cedar chests and his explanation of why they "work" is that you clean the clothes before you store them (eliminating the eggs. larvae, and moths) and since the box is nicely made and sealed, none can enter.

He thought it was almost comical that the entire Cedar Chest industry was based on a myth.

I will tell you that the cedar oil/smell with ruin elastic. If you or your wife put your unmentionables in there for a while, they will lose some of their pzazz and fall off. (Actually, that might be appealing.) It will ruin some fabrics as well. I would shellac the inside of the box and eliminate any smell.

Also, you might want to look into safety hardware. A soft close lid so that a kid or bigger person does not bang their head or fingers. And don't have a latch that can not be opened from the inside, or no latch at all.

I have not read the report mentioned above, perhaps it is newer that the one referred to by the guy from Tech.

Re: Cedar Chest

#5

Barry, I thought the same as you.

Gary Smyth

I remember reading about the ineffectiveness of cedar as a bug killer. When I started my response I was going to suggest that cedar didn't provide any protection but then thought I'd check facts. In that process I ran across the deterrent information I mentioned. Frankly it was a surprise. I thought for years now that cedar was an item that killed moths and other fabric destroyers. That turns out not to be the case. Even the article says that cedar is not toxic. But.....from the article, it is a repellant for select critters found in a typical urban home. I read the abstract but not the full paper. If you care to delve further you can make your own decision as to the effectiveness of cedar and bugs. It's not my project but I'd just as soon leave out the cedar completely and build using other wood.

Re: Cedar Chest

#6

Ellis Walentine

Re: Cedar Chest

Ellis Walentine

If you're going to use cedar strip closet planking, use a brad nailer to toenail the boards in. I wouldn't glue it.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Cedar Chest

#7

Re: Cedar Chest 

David Yoho

I've built several blanket chests that included aromatic cedar tongue and groove planks for the bottom. Since the lower part of the chest had two drawers, the planks were laid on top of the frame above the drawers. They are simply cut to fit and held in place with a quarter-round molding I made. The molding is tacked in place with small pins. The reason is so if the owner locks the chest and looses both keys it's easy enough to pop out the cedar plank bottom and reach in to unlock the lock. This method keeps you from having to attach the planks and allows wood movement that might occur.


Re: Cedar Chest

#8

Kneale Brownson

Re: Cedar Chest

Kneale Brownson

I've done the same as David: Cut to fit/retain with trims bradnailed in place.