A picture would help, but my first impulse is to think automotive or plumbing. You can get flat gasket stock from any auto parts store, and some hardware stores will have stickyback flat gasket stock used by plumbers. Either one might do the job, depending on how much "crush" you need the gasket to have.
The bottom gasket of the cartridge filter (about 1' in diameter) is worn out.
I need something that is about 1/4" or so thick.
Weather stripping doesn't work too well as it is difficult to get a "curve". What I would like is something that is ~1' in diameter so I could just trace it and cut it.
JL,I have no idea exactly hat your gasket looks like or what properties it must have, but here are a couple of suggestions.
You might try Backer Rod. Its closed cell foam that is round and comes in various diameters from about a 1/4" to maybe and inch or more. The borgs often have it but don't always know. Ask in the weather stripping and caulking departments.
Many cities have a commercial caulking supplier. The will have backer rod and also many other types of gasket material. I bought some Neoprene in various thicknesses. It comes in sheets (and other shapes). You could buy a sheet and cut a circle out of it. Come to think of it you could buy Pipe Insulation (either Neoprene or very similar) and cut it to fit.
Incidentally Backer Rod is not really a rod. Its very flexible.
How about closed cell foam used in packaging. Comes in various sizes and thicknesses. Easily cut and fairly cheap. Try one of the shipping services if you can't find it at a box store or craft store.
A friend of mine has several rolls of Neoprene that appear to be about 1" thick. If you tell me how much you need I will ship you a piece free, you pay the shipping.
You could get a "sheet" of it and cut a donut out of it. What he has is about four feet wide. Let me know and we will cut a hunk out for you. Tell me where you are and we will figure the shipping. Send me an e-mail if you are interested.