Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT - bubble testing gas system

Posts

OT - bubble testing gas system

#1

OT - bubble testing gas system

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm installing a gas room heater, and have run the pipe into the room and installed the gas valve. I'm now attempting to bubble test the system. Putting a cap on the gas valve leaves me with bubbles at the outlet of the gas valve. I replaced the fitting, and tried a different cap, but I'm still getting bubbles. I know that the flare fitting on the gas flex will probably seat better, but is there any way to cap the gas valve to get a tight seal?

The reason for my question: the inspector wants to see the pressure test for the gas line at final inspection; but at final, the gas valve and associated piping will be behind a stove that I don't want to remove, what with having to pull the vent pipe and all, so I'd planned to pull the cap on the bottom of the exposed dirt leg on the line (had to run it outside the building) and put my pressure testing equipment there. To do that, I have to isolate the heater, cap the valve, and test it with the valve open. But if I'm getting bubbles at standard gas pressure, I'm not likely to pass the pressure test.

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

#2

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

They make special caps for flare fittings. I would suspect that most local plumbing supply houses would have them. Your mileage may vary at any of the big box stores.

Lee

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

#3

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

Randy Johnson

I’ve read your post several times and I’m still not exactly sure what you are doing.

Are you screwing a cap on the end of a fitting for a flex connector? If so, it is going to leak.

Go ahead and install the flex connector on the adaptor in the valve, and make sure to put a little dope on the mating surfaces like you would a union. The adaptor on the valve should be male. The adaptor for the other end of the flex connector should be female. Screw a nipple with a cap into the adaptor and then connect everything together, once again making sure to dope the mating surfaces of the flex connector and adaptor.

Since you made the remark about higher pressure for the test, here is an interesting little tidbit. Most of the time gas pressure is four ounces/seven inches of water column. If the test is in pounds, the shut-off valves will have to be closed to do the test or it could damage the appliance valves that are designed for a lower pressure. This means two things. 1. No leaks downstream of the shut-off valve are going to show up on an air test anyway. The gas will have to be on to find them. And 2. The shut-off valve you say is going to be behind a stove you don’t want to move is going to have to be accessible somehow to do the air test. Different companies and localities will have different rules of course.

But.

If I were doing a reconnect, or hooking up a new service. I wouldn’t even get the gauge and air tank out of the truck if a shut off valve was not near the appliance it was for and easily accessible.

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

#4

One word: neoprene

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Thanks, Lee and Randy (and Mark, for the side conversation).

The shutoff valve for this stove, and the flare fitting at the end of it, will be accessible behind the stove in the sense that I can reach back there and turn off the valve, disconnect the flex, etc. But there won't be room to swing two pipe wrenches to remove the shutoff valve and put a pressure testing manifold on. Since the inspector wants to see the pressure test at final inspection - and was specific that he wants the stove in place so he can inspect the vent pipe hookup - I have no real choice but to install the pressure testing manifold somewhere besides at the stove. We had to run the gas line into daylight and back into the house to reach the stove (which sits on top of a giant cube of concrete that once held up the fireplace), so I've got the cap for the dirt leg right there where I can hook it up.

I considered buying an extra flex and capping off the other end of it with a flare fitting and pipe cap/plug, but $30 seemed like a lot of money for purposes of testing the system. Instead, I spent 37 cents on a neoprene washer which, trimmed very slightly, fit down into the cap nicely, making a gasket between the cap and the flare fitting. This assembly not only didn't bubble under line pressure, it held 5.5 pounds for about half an hour, which is both higher and longer than our jurisdiction requires for the pressure test. Yay!

Now, as soon as I get questions answered by the stove dealer, clarifying the pitifully written installation manual, I can get the stove in place and move forward, ever forward, on this remodel. Which will get finished. Sometime.

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

#5

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

wayne goldstein

Bill, gas pressure tests are done with the valves removed and caps installed in their place. Gas valves are generally sealed with grease and will leak at pressures required for a leak test. Leak test pressures are 15 or so PSI and gas pressure is approx. 6 inches water column (approx. 0.25 psi). Most gas valves are not designed to be leak tight at test pressures.

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

#6

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm leaving the valve wide open, and capping the flare fitting.

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

#7

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

wayne goldstein

Bill,

The problem is that most gas valves are plug valves where the rotating part is tapered, spring loaded and sealed with grease. The leak will be to the outside world through the grease seal. That is why the valves are removed and caps are installed throughout the system for the leak test. I know this seems like a lot of work but, this is the proper way to pressure test.

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

#8

Ah - now I understand

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'd been thinking of the internal seal, not of the seal on the spindle. Well, that's a problem. Maybe I need to put a higher-pressure ball valve on; there are some, of the type used for cutoffs for water or gas, rated to 600 pounds. I've got the room.

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

#9

The valve I have in place will work, it seems

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The valve already in place (picture below, except mine has a yellow handle) is made by Mueller Industries. Their catalog rates it at 200 psi, without stating clearly what that context is. I checked with their tech folks this morning, and am told that it should have no problems with five psi for a pressure test.

This is, obviously, not necessarily true for all valves; it seems to be with this one.


img

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

#10

Re: The valve I have in place will work, it seems

Randy Johnson

The valve in the picture is a shut-off valve, and yes, it will easily handle any air test likely to be thrown at it. Downstream of it though will be the appliance control valve. This will very likely suffer some damage if it gets hit with much more than the standard four ounces / seven inches of water column.

I can’t speak for every area or every company, but I will tell you how my company does it. I usually do several of them each day because it is a company requirement for every new service and reconnect we do.

First off, all the valves like the one you have pictured are placed in the off position. We then drop the meter and screw a test gauge into the downstream side of the meter set. Standards have changed a little since I first started. Now it is three pounds of air for ten minutes or seven inches of water column for three minutes. It used to be ten pounds for ten minutes. Since the control valve is designed for seven inches of water column, it is not necessary to close shut- off valves when testing the lines at that pressure. As an aside, only one of the three servicemen in my company who do the job regularly has the tool required to test for water column. But that is a separate and kinda sore subject.

Testing the way I do it, the line should hold with nothing more than the shut-off valve in the off position. However, most places will require that you at least have a plug in the downstream side, if not completely plumbed in to the appliance. The down side to doing an air test this way is that any joints downstream of the shut-off valve don’t get tested. That will still require the bottle of soap water.

Re: OT - bubble testing gas system

#11

My plan...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Now that the stove is in place (yay!), I can see I have even more room than I expected to reach in there with a wrench and remove the flare fitting. Then I'll use a brass flare cap with the neoprene washer that worked so well in testing to close off the end of the line, leave the valve open, and run the test. After inspection, I'll reattach the stove and get out the dish detergent for another bubble test*.

It's interesting - you're the first person with field experience to say that it's OK to leave the shutoff in place. In all the other research I've done, everyone's said that you must remove the shutoff valve.

I've got a ball valve rated for 600 psi downstream from the meter that will allow me to isolate the gas in the house from the meter.

*My son has pointed out, with some bemusement, that inspectors get quite vocal about the pressure test - but that there will inevitably be at least one connection that can't be tested that way.