Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

Posts

Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

#1

Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

Barry Irby

I have sanded my dining room floor. 2 1/4" by 3/4 red oak. I sanded it with a Square Sand. Applied Cherry Minwax stain then two coats of Varathane. Its a ureathane with Aluminum Oxide in it for abrasion resistance. The problem is that I got a lot of nits in the finish. So, I sanded it with a ROS. Got it nice and smooth with the finish dulled. Applied a third coat from a brand new can with a new lambs wool pad. Got nits again. I had vac-ed the floor after sanding. I also used the vac attached to the sander. I thought the floor was very clean before I started with the finish.

So, what did do wrong? I suspect it would have been better to thin the finish.

I think some of the roughness is from bubbles that got trapped in the finish as it cured. And, is there a better technique that using the lamb's wool pad?

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

With waterborne finishes, too thin can cause problems, including bubbles. To make the suggested coverage rates, they typically have to go on at a rate that "feels" way too thick.

Secondly, especially with between-coat sanding, vacuuming is typically not enough. Running a damp terry-cloth (lint-free) towel over it helps get up that last bit of dust.

Third, application method can help with nibs. The pour/plow method helps to keep dust moving in the finish puddle without being deposited in the finish. If you see a chunk of something, you can pick it out with your finger (I wipe it IN my pocket then). No nose jokes here, please. I imagine you could find a YouTube video of the method--it's quick and you can do it standing up.

Jason

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

#3

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have done several floors over the years. I damp wipe everything in the room except the ceiling and probably that should be done too. I thin. I use a 4" brush. And then I seal the room off until dry enough to be dust free. That will be "forever" if it is cold. If I had to do a room when it was cold I would run the temperature up as high as I could get the room, 80+. Coat and then seal off and hope there was enough heat in the room to set the finish in a reasonable time. If air is circulated in the room I don't see a way to avoid dust.

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

#4

I think problem is with your applicator *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

Barry,

Take all of the precautions as Bill said and then DON'T use a new lambswool applicator. They will always leave nibs when new. Pros I know use one of the below linked "squeegee" type applicators and they do not leave anything behind.

You can also buy hands and knees type 12" foam applicators with the "mouse fur" pad on them for use in tight places. Those can be had at flooring suppliers for pro's.

Note that the image of the squeegee in my link depicts it being used upside down, which is less than ideal and will result in a mess at cleanup.

In use, you pour some finish on the floor, then use the squeegee to herd it around kind of like sealing an asphalt driveway.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa


applicator

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

#5

Thanks for the thoughts....

Barry Irby

The third coat actually turned out better than I thought and I think its acceptable.

I bought the applicator from the same display that had the Varathane. There were two types, a manmade one and a real lamb's wool one. The web site promoted the lambs wool one.

This has been a learning experience for me. Its a good example of why you should not experiment on yourself. Cooks get to eat their mistakes and us floor refinishers get to live with them.

One problem with the lambs wool applicator is the fact that it is way too "fluffy". Yes it carries a ton of finish, but it you press on it a little too hard and compress it, it makes a sort of slurping noise as it expands and that may pump air into the product. The mouse fir version might be better. Next time.....

And Bill and every body else is right. You can't get it too clean....

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

#6

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

vance

Never use a lambwool applicator. A lambswool applicator is used for oil base finishes. Use a paint applicator like a 10" padco.

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

#7

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

Barry Irby

I am confused. Varathane is a brand name for Ureathane. Isn't that an "oil" based finish? The applicator I bought is a Varathane brand product. They had a similar man made applicator I used for the stain, but the display implied the lambs wool was better. Maybe because it was more money? The cheaper one was about five bucks and the high dollar one was about eight. Did not seem like a big expense in the scheme of the floor project.

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Varathane is indeed a brand name, but they sell both a waterborne floor finish (black and blue label) and an oil-based floor finish (black and yellowish), along with other stains and finishes.

Waterborne clear finishes are often called "polyurethanes" as a generic term, even if they're really an acrylic. Don't ask me to explain the chemical difference. I couldn't. Wikipedia might be able to.

Oh, and don't thin a waterborne floor finish.

Jason

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

#9

My oversight....OOOps

Barry Irby

You are correct. I am using the oil based version. the finish actually came out as well or better than I expected. There are a few pieces of crud in it and a hair or two, but very few bubbles if any.

I intentionally left some of the damage in the floor as patina. If I had known it was going to turn out as well as it did I would have eliminated them.

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

#10

Solvent based urethane varnish and bubbles

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Regularly the issue of this vanish and bubbles comes up here at WC. It is well to know that solvent based products are formulated to meet EPA volatile regulations, NOT, ease of application. I have brushed many gallons of this stuff and never had a bubble dry before it broke and flowed smooth. The "secret" is to thin it a bit. It will flow out ever so much better. Thinned it can be sprayed successfully too. Use naptha(more volatile) if it is cool and mineral spirits if it is warm.

If a solvent based product says "don't thin" it is a good bet that the statement is in response to an EPA mandate and not some performance issue.

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

#11

Re: Solvent based urethane varnish and bubbles

Barry Irby

Thanks Bill. In the end I am very pleased with my results. Could have done better. Was doubtful I could remove ALL of the old marks and damage, so I left some of it with the idea it would be "Patina". Its fine, but now that I look at it I could have removed the rest of it with some work with a scraper. I set my sights a bit low. The other thing I could have done is a better job on cleaning. It's 99.99% but some more effort would have gotten it even better. (Its a curse to be a perfectionist.) Next time.....

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

#12

Re: Solvent based urethane varnish and bubbles

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Barry, just today I finished applying the second coat of what I believe might be the same Varathane you used- oil-based polyurethane, high traffic formula, contains aluminum oxide, AND is fast drying. It is good stuff. I used it when I expanded a bedroom into an attic a few years ago, but it can be a pain to put down.

I stirred it but avoided making bubbles and poured it straight from the can before spreading it. However, my new lambswool applicator left nibs, too, and I also got some bubbles. Both were my fault- one, I didn't have a good light shining at a low angle so couldn't see and remove them quickly, and two, most of the instances of bubbles happened when I worked it too fast and/or too long- sometimes I made several spreading passes and one or two leveling finish passes. I think that was too much because this stuff starts to thicken and set-up pretty quickly. I didn't see what I was doing until it was too late.

After my first coat I knocked down the nibs and bubbles with 120 grit, I thoroughly vacuumed the area, then wiped it down with mineral spirits to remove any remaining sanding grit and dust. The second coat came out much better, but again, in areas where I worked it too much I still got some bubbles (and still a few wool nibs). On the can it recommends three coats, but I'm stopping at two- the area I finished is an extension of my living room and I would like to be able to watch TV without killing brain cells. Someday, but not anytime soon, I may hit it with a steel wool or Scothbrite pad and give it another coat of poly.


Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

#13

That's it, except....

Barry Irby

I used the Semi-gloss version.

I put on the first coat over Minwax stain that was about 10 hours old, expecting to put on a second coat six or eight hours later. Nope. It was clearly two sticky and had not cured. I think that was a combination of the room being too cold (maybe 65 degrees) and the fact the stain had not fully cured, which may have been a result of the lower temps as well. When I thought I could get on the floor without messing it up, I put on a second coat. Rougher than I wanted, nibs, trash, etc. I brought in a couple of heaters and raised the temp, let it cure for several days, sanded the entire surface with a ROS and 150 grit. Ran the vac one the ROS and then vacuumed the floor. Did not use a tack cloth but should have. Used a new lambs wool bonnet on the third coat and tried to very even and consistent. Its MUCH better. Alas, it appears I dragged whatever few pieces of trash over to the exit point, which is the most used part of the room. I doubt anyone but me will notice but now that I have seen it, I can't un-see it.

(I did not run my central heat because I was afraid there was dust and debris in the ducts, and there was)

In hind sight, I am wondering if I could have gotten the potted plant stains out and should have scraped out the "patina"? Curse that perfectionist gene....

The third coat really did pay off for me. But you are right, the oil smell persists. Might be a better summer project.

Re: Applying finish to Oak Flooring Questions?

#14

Re: That's it, except....

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

I used semi-gloss as well.

The last time when I added on to a bedroom and put down new oak flooring, the existing flooring was 6 years old. I should have sanded and refinished the entire floor so the finish matched, that is what a floor guy who gave me an estimate said he would do. His quote just to finish the floor was way too high- almost 3 times what it cost me to do the entire job myself, including buying the oak flooring, a HF cleat nailer, and cleats, renting a sander, and buying the finish. That is why I attempted it myself. The sheen of the new section matched the old almost perfectly. After a few months of light foot traffic they matched perfectly. The success and cost were the reason I decided to try it again on the living room addition. The conditions were different and so, unfortunately, were the results.

I could close the bedroom door and open the windows, but we use the living room all the time and also have a cat that I had to keep out of the new section. I built a temporary wall from furring strip and plastic sheeting to keep the dust from the living room and keep the cat out of the new section.

I think the white oak I got from Lumber Liquidators was lower grade this time, too. There was a lot more darker planks in at least two bundles- it looked like swamp oak or a similar dark species of white oak.

After sanding, vacuuming and wiping it down, I put on a second coat of poly yesterday afternoon. Today, in the light I can still see a few nibs, some bubbles, and now some streaks where I made leveling passes with the lambswool applicator- as I said, this stuff starts to set up really quickly. Drying time to foot traffic hardness is still a few days, however.

Bottom line it needs another thorough sanding or screening and a third coat. Maybe someday. As my wife often says, I'm the only one who will notice the flaws, especially once it has foot traffic wear or we put furniture and/or an area rug there. In my mind it was a tough job with decent results, which were marred by the final step! It is just disappointing. Start to finish this has been one really tough job, in no small way because I am getting older. Due to the hard work (it involved jack hammering the porch slab! hoisting two 16' X 14" microlams, etc.) and sweating bullets in the process, I lost over 10 lbs. since I started at the end of September.