Re: That's it, except....
Alan in Little Washington (NC)
I used semi-gloss as well.
The last time when I added on to a bedroom and put down new oak flooring, the existing flooring was 6 years old. I should have sanded and refinished the entire floor so the finish matched, that is what a floor guy who gave me an estimate said he would do. His quote just to finish the floor was way too high- almost 3 times what it cost me to do the entire job myself, including buying the oak flooring, a HF cleat nailer, and cleats, renting a sander, and buying the finish. That is why I attempted it myself. The sheen of the new section matched the old almost perfectly. After a few months of light foot traffic they matched perfectly. The success and cost were the reason I decided to try it again on the living room addition. The conditions were different and so, unfortunately, were the results.
I could close the bedroom door and open the windows, but we use the living room all the time and also have a cat that I had to keep out of the new section. I built a temporary wall from furring strip and plastic sheeting to keep the dust from the living room and keep the cat out of the new section.
I think the white oak I got from Lumber Liquidators was lower grade this time, too. There was a lot more darker planks in at least two bundles- it looked like swamp oak or a similar dark species of white oak.
After sanding, vacuuming and wiping it down, I put on a second coat of poly yesterday afternoon. Today, in the light I can still see a few nibs, some bubbles, and now some streaks where I made leveling passes with the lambswool applicator- as I said, this stuff starts to set up really quickly. Drying time to foot traffic hardness is still a few days, however.
Bottom line it needs another thorough sanding or screening and a third coat. Maybe someday. As my wife often says, I'm the only one who will notice the flaws, especially once it has foot traffic wear or we put furniture and/or an area rug there. In my mind it was a tough job with decent results, which were marred by the final step! It is just disappointing. Start to finish this has been one really tough job, in no small way because I am getting older. Due to the hard work (it involved jack hammering the porch slab! hoisting two 16' X 14" microlams, etc.) and sweating bullets in the process, I lost over 10 lbs. since I started at the end of September.