We live in a turn of the Century @ 1895 Home with lath and plaster walls. My wife had a cabinet against one wall for many years-I knew some problems lurked behind the wall . Last week she had me move the cabinet to a different location and now I get to deal with the open wall. Mrs. Young wants the wall paper removed, the wall "fixed" and then painted. The damaged ares look to me like the skim coat coming loose-it's about 1/8-3/16 thick. I think if I strip the wall paper it will pull much more of the coat off. So I'm wondering what is the best way to approach this. A few pictures are attached which should demonstrate the problem.
Finish coat is separating from the brown (intermediate) coat. No good repair except removal and replacement. Test the plaster for attachment to the wall; plaster attaches by forming "keys" as the first coat of wet plaster slops through the lath (wood or metal). Over time, these keys can break off, leaving the plaster standing just on its own, not a good situation. There are plaster washers that can reattach the plaster, but they work best when the plaster is intact in itself, just loose from the wall. The finish coat is much harder than the underlying coats, so a plaster washer won't hold as well when the finish coat is gone.
All of which is to say you've probably work work and grief ahead of you. And like so many home maintenance projects, it started out so innocently.
If you're lucky the finish coat has just separated and the brown coat is still sound. As long as the brown coat is fairly hard, you can skim over it again with some un-sanded finishing plaster. Around here, all the finish plasters are made by US Gypsum. Imperial and Red Top are two common finish plasters and are fairly easy to use as these things go. Another is Diamond, which is a veneer plaster intended to go over wallboard of some kind. It can be used as finish plaster but can be a bit more tricky than the other two I mentioned (and they are all trickier than topcoating with drywall mud).
Top coating with drywall mud is a viable option as well if you use hot mud - the dry stuff in 20# sacks. Avoid bucket mud, it's not appropriate for this, it shrinks too much since it dries rather than cures, and it is likely to flake off sooner than an actual plaster product. Hot mud has a bit of plaster in it, plus a lot of clay and stuff like perlite that makes it soft, light, and easy to sand. The genuine plasters are pretty well impossible to sand, so it takes a bit of practice to get a nice smooth wall with no bumps where you transition to the older finish plaster.
1. . . you'd like to OTJ learn a new trade, take a shot at removing as much finish as you can and the reapplying finishing plaster. Warn SWMBO ahead of time
2. . . you'd like a nice wall to paint, hire a real plaster guy to redo the area
3. . . you'd like a nice wall to paint at 1% of the frustration of No. 1, 10% of the cost of No. 2, and can spare 1/2" of room space, rip off the loose stuff, then put up rock, schmutz, paint and call it a day.
Tried No. 1, the wall wasn't worth No. 2, they never noticed the 1/2". Done!
There are three or four approaches to this. Some of them have already been mentioned.
You could make a historically accurate "proper" repair. At the extreme this might include replacing the base coats with real horse hair plaster. Probably not a priority to go to that extreme, but you could hire plasterers and have them remove any loose base coat to the lath and replace it and replace the finish coat as necessary.
You could use the plaster washers and screws mentioned above to secure the base coat and skim it with plaster.
You could cut out the loose base coat and install drywall like pieces of a jigsaw puzzle and tape them like a drywall patch. Sometimes the drywall is close enough to the thickness of the plaster for this to work. Clearly this is low budget repair and considered "tacky".
You could remove all the plaster to the laths and then drywall over them and then tape the drywall. This has the advantage of keeping the wall thickness nearly identical to the original.
And they make drywall designed for installation over the plaster. Locally its "blue board" and is fiberglass reinforced to give it the strength to restrain the plaster. You sue screws long enough to penetrate both the drywall and plaster and into the laths or framing. This works fairly well, but if you are doing a large area, it adds a huge amount of weight to the building and may set off a new round of settling.
The methods that involve removing lots of plaster can be incredibly messy. Tons of dust.
Alan, last August we had two storms which let water into our roof and into the bedroom walls and bathroom wall. I cut away all of the loose old plaster until I got some steady surface, then took a notched masonry flat trowel and applied drywall mud from the gallon container...let it dry over night, then used a flat trowel to smooth over the notches filling the grooves , let dry and then sanded to the finish I wanted to match the original surface....worked out just fine and at a reasonable cost and work time....repainted it the next day and finished.
I live in an 1873 house and just made a plaster repair with what they used to call Durabond. It goes under a different name now, made by, I believe, US gypsum. It comes in a blue and white bag in various working times, 20 minutes 45 minutes etc. It doesn't shrink and does a great job. I spread it out with a wide drywall knife, I think about 14". I have done this many times over the years, sometimes on bare lathe, sometimes on cases like yours where the underlying plaster is OK. When you mix the powder with water you only have as long as the bag says, It'll start to harden in the pan. Also, when you clean out the pan get all the old out before you mix in the new, or it will cause the new mix to harden prematurely. I did mucho work in old houses when I was in business and always enjoyed it....well most of the time. I retired 21 years ago and enjoy life more now.
One more thing, if its a wide repair, wider than the knife, don't try to do it all in one coat, Go back over it after it dries with another coat or two.
Vastly better than the bucket stuff once you get the hang of mixing it and working on a time limit
Durabond is more like plaster but still has fillers like clay that make it drywall mud rather than plaster. EasySand is the stuff I usually buy because it's lighter and does sand more easily. Either one would be an acceptable substitute for plaster.
I sometimes find Durabond at the hardware store, but all the home centers I've been to carry the EasySand variety instead.