Cordless Drill Driver
Chris K in MD
I need to replace my old DeWalt 12V drivers since batteries are more than new drills!!!
What is the best and best value out there these days?
Bosch?
Festool?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Cordless Drill Driver
Chris K in MD
I need to replace my old DeWalt 12V drivers since batteries are more than new drills!!!
What is the best and best value out there these days?
Bosch?
Festool?
Re: Cordless Drill Driver
Clint Searl
Consider a Milwaukee impact driver.
Re: Cordless Drill Driver
Dustmaker Mike
I have several I use a lot.
20V Dewalt got it as a kit on Black Friday last year heavy duty Hammer Drill and driver. This it the new battery style and the charge last a long time
Boush 12V I have the Hammer Drill and two different drivers these I garb for normal everyday jobs.
A Hitachi I got at the blue borg a few years ago that I use a lot also because it is light but the current ones at the borg are not the same.
To make a long story longer I use the Boush more then the Dewalt and the Hitachi more then the others. Since the Hitachi is not the same anymore I would stay with the Boush 12V kit and if you need more power then the Dewalt 20V kit
Home Depot
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
what ever it is they sell. Lifetime battery guarantee. They have replace 4 of mine so far....painlessly. Li ion batteries will die eventually so a battery guarantee is as good as a new drill
get an 18 V with 1/2 chuck....more versatile
Re: Home Depot
Joseph Mulherin, sr
Chris, I bought the Rockwell 3rill a couple yrs ago and it also has the hammer drill opportunity
built in. Also, the have the lifetime battery replacement...you just have to pay shipping.
Cost of my 3rill when I bought it was around $136, and I have used it for everything I have built in those years. Great tool.
Re: Home Depot Sells
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
them all but the Brand Bill's talking about is Rigid.
Must be careful, however, to make sure the model you buy has the "Lifetime Battery" deal labeled on the outside of the box. I bought their 18v 1/2 drill + impact driver "combo" set and both units are very nice, small, well balanced, with plenty of torque, all for $180.
Be careful as well because you must register the purchase within 30 days; easy on-line website.
Re: Cordless Drill Driver *LINK*
William Duffield
This little independent demonstration may just answer all your questions regarding "best"
correct registration is paramount
Dick Coers
You must register properly. I think it was an on-line registration PLUS a mail in requirement for the Rigid. My HD will not replace with store stock, you must go to the front desk and then they mail you a battery. So really not that friendly. We use Bosch Lithium Ion at work, much better grip and feel than the Rigid.
Re: Cordless Drill Driver
Christopher Fitch Memphis
Couldn't be happier with my T-15. Sure beats the crap out of my old Dewalt that I gave away when the batteries stopped holding a charge for long.
Re: Cordless Drill Driver
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
My old 14 v. DeWalt held on just long enough for Festool to introduce the new generation LiIon batteries for their T-series and C-series drills, leaving me on the horns of a dilemma. I knew I wanted a light weight drill, but the new Festool CXS doesn't have the offset chuck, which I feel is essential for drilling and driving up against inside cabinet corners. I had to decide between the C-12 and the T-12, and chose the latter. For anyone looking for one, which handle configuration and battery size to choose has to be a personal decision. That can best be made by walking into a dealer's showroom and trying them both out. To make it even more difficult, Festool now also offers a Ti-15 impact driver.
Note that when discussing drills, people on internet fora often confuse impact drivers and hammer drills. The former are for driving phillips head drywall screws; the latter are for drilling holes in masonry and concrete using a masonry drill bit. I'm going to keep my corded DeWalt DW511 hammer drill for that function.
For more info on the Festool Ti-15:
http://www.halfinchshy.com/2012/10/review-of-festool-ti-15-hybrid-impact.html
The feature I liked best about my old DeWalt was the keyless chuck, because it's the only drill chuck I've found that doesn't give me "rope burn" when I grip it and the bit with one hand and the trigger with the other to tighten or loosen it.
Re: Cordless Drill Driver
AZ in Colorado Springs
The Milwaukee 12 volt drill has an intermediate position on the forward-reverse switch that locks the shaft and makes tightening or loosening very easy. You can grip the body of the drill in your opposite hand and hold the drill quite steady. I really like that feature.
Great Test
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
I wonder how the tool was doing a week, a month, 6 months later after all that crap has worked it way into the switch, the circuit boards and the rest of it. Absolutely no reason that I should spend 5-600 for a dril when I can get one that will perform just as well for me for years at 1/4 the price. Unless of course I'd like to brag about how much I spent for it.
Pros in my area regard tools as expendable. While they don't shop at Harbor Freight (or Sears) for power tools, they don't blow money out the door for something that will get just as thin when the truck runs over it at the jobsite. I've never seen one of them put power tools in a bucket of water, sand, or joint compound. A truly stupid "test."
With a better writer and production crew, this guy could have a future with the next chopper-in-a-hopper . . .
Re: Cordless Drill Driver
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
I don't think that's what he was talking about. Pretty much anyone I know in the trades grips the chuck with the off hand and pulls the trigger with the other hand, using the driver motor to quickly tighten and loosen the chuck. Some have better grips than others.
Heck, I even do it with my corded drill now (with a standard keyed chuck), though I'm careful to not let it slip in my hand! Then I follow up with the key if it's a round-shaft bit.
Jason
Re: Cordless Drill Driver
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
Jason has the right idea. The ribs on the DeWalt just happen to be a bit less abrasive than most, right out of the box. Of course, you could easily (with sand paper, rattail file, card scraper, etc.) take the edges off of any of them. Just be careful that you don't make them so smooth that you lose your grip when you need it. Also, I think most cordless electric drills have the locking central position. I would recommend anyone buying one to check for that feature and reject any drill that doesn't have it.
Locking Gear?
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
My Milwaukee corded 1/2" hammer drill doesn't have that and I've had to put a stilson on the keyless chuck to loosen it after drilling concrete. Same for my Rigid 18v cordless; no center-position spindle lock but I can't turn it by hand except to open and close the chuck jaws.
And, beyond hammer drills,
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
we have rotary hammers, which can drill yet larger holes in concrete, rock, and so on, using masonry bits.
Re: Great Test
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
Well, they come with a 3 year guarantee.
If your expendable tool fails in the middle of a critical installation, you still have downtime, and mileage to the nearest Borg, and maybe even late penalties to consider.
Festool does even more demanding tests on these than the drywall hanger gorilla in the YouTube. After driving close to a million screws with one, they took it back to the bench, where they found that the wear was not even measurable. Then they sent it back to the guy with the box of screws to drive several hundred thousand more.
Another significant advantage of the Festool system is security. Most of the pros who do installation in the Big Cities need their tools contained in the Festool/Tanos Systainers, because everything they need to do their job can be continuously controlled under one hand. While loading and unloading the truck, or going through doors, or up and down in the elevator, there is no chance that some upstanding citizen will remove part of their kit to a pawn shop while they are moving something else.
Upstanding Citizen . . .
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
"Yo, Dude, Where's my truck?"
"Can we spell Impound, Sparky?"

I guess' at those prices a tool box may become a "Systainer" but it's still just a tool box
Re: Upstanding Citizen . . .
William Duffield
Of course, a furniture dolly, a stack of apple crates and a ratchet strap will do the job, but sooner or later the inefficiencies start to add up.
I've had professional customers who have told me, "I can't afford to not use Festools."
Cost
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
I've pitched several cordless drills, Dewalt, PC, Milwaukee, but not one of them was worn out or inoperative. The cost of new batteries (little more than having them rebuilt) was close to the cost of a whole new tool, so it has been the batteries, rather than the drills themselves, that has driven the replacement decision. I have no doubt that if I could have gotten replacement batteries at reasonable cost, my old D-W or Milwaukee would still be going strong after a million screws. That cost is what drove my decision to buy the Rigid; as long as Emerson Electric exists, I won't have to buy another drill because batteries are replaced FREE.
Make no mistake. I don't "down" Festool's quality or design. Their pricing and merchandising is another matter in my view. If you pay $650 for the drill, you'll be more likely to spend $125 a piece for new batteries. Festool guarantees their batteries for 3 years. Emerson guarantees their Rigid batteries forever, their drill costs 75% less, and will do the same job for me.
Re: Cost
paul in AZ
This thread has the makings of a "my tool is bigger than your tool" conversation.
Actually
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
"My tool is cheaper than your tool"

ps: If you've got the extra coin to spend, enjoy! That's why Lamborghini and Honda, Cold Duck and Dom Perignon are in business, right? 
Re: Cordless Drill Driver
Chris K in MD
Thank you all for your input. I have to agree that the issue is my batteries are the issue, not the drill. Unfortunately I cant buy another drill with the same batteries like I did last time to interchange them.
I like the rigid guarantee. I will check that out when feeling these different units