let's explore this objection
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
1. Any board I use is exposed to oils and fats for kneading bread, cutting up meat, etc. Whether I add any or not the board will soon become coated with fat and oil from use. Your results my differ depending on how the board/counter is used.
2. What is rancid? Is it bad?. Most fats and oils contain esters made from large fatty acid molecules which have weak places in the molecule(unsaturation) that can react with oxygen and break. The pieces that break off are smaller acids- acetic, propionic, butyric etc.They stink more or less. The chemistry that generates these smaller acids is described as the material becoming rancid. It is the same chemistry that "cures" linseed oil, varnish, etc. and generates the same smells.
These smaller acids also happen to be the normal products of fermentation and other ageing. We eat lots of them. They give cheese and bread its desirable flavors. That overnight fermentation of the bagels I made this weekend resulted in the generation of these acids, which provided these bagels exceptional flavor compared to same-day grocery store bagels (not to be confused with real bagel shop bagels).
3. The stinky acids generated through oxidation are readily volatile. Unless captured in a confined space they go away as fast as they are generated.
4. The cooking oil in the bottle which I am recommending to add to cutting boards is exposed to oxygen and this chemistry in the bottle or on the board. The plastic used to contain these oils is readily permeable to oxygen.
5. Walnut oil, blessed for cutting board use, is more susceptible to these oxidations than typical cooking oil. We call it curing but it is identical chemistry to "going rancid" , a more pejorative description.
6. Olive oil doesn't have the weak places in its fatty acids and will not oxidize to generate the smaller smelly acids, for what that is worth.