Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

glycerin on Butchers Block???

Posts

glycerin on Butchers Block???

#1

glycerin on Butchers Block???

BBFisher

Has anyone ever used pure natural glycerin on butchers block before? I am having a heck of a time finding food grade mineral oil. I have glycerin and know that its a very good moisturizer so I thought it might be good to condition my butchers block

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#2

No

John in NM

Glycerin is water soluble and will not do what you want it to in this case - repel water from your wood.

At least one knowledgeable member here uses vegetable oil without negative effects. I wouldn't put it on a pretty cutting board that will never get used, but I wouldn't hesitate with a surface that will be wiped, washed, abraded, washed again, etc.

You can also look for oil at a feed store. $20 gallon or so. It is fit for animal consumption - as in no nasty machine oil smell. I would use it without hesitation. Of course if you must have FDA approved for human consumption, just got to the laxative isle of the drug store, you will find mineral oil there for about $5/pint.

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#3

Re: No

BBFisher

Thank you John!

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#4

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Mineral oil.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Go to a drug store or the pharmacy section of a grocery store. As long as it's not a scented baby oil, and is one meant to "keep things moving along in the digestive system", that's what you want. Heat it in a microwave or a double boiler so that it's good and thin, then apply it still hot to your cutting board (appropriate precautions apply) so that it penetrates readily. Saturate, let sit a while, re-saturate, let sit, wipe off excess. Repeat as long as it continues to absorb the oil.

Jason

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#5

Re: Mineral oil.

don stephan

And reapply as needed when the wood starts to feel rough after wash and dry.

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#6

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I agree with the others NO to glycerin. I have used a mixture of Bees wax, paraffin and mineral oil, heated on a hot plate until it was very thin, then brushed it on (heavy on the end grain areas).

I have also used Walnut oil from a health food store, it seemed to work quite well. It does cure to a somewhat hard surface and I suppose some people may be sensitive to the Walnut. I made that board for my Son and his wife - no one in our family is allergic to Anything!

As the board was composed of hard maple, Walnut and a few other woods, didn't see any reason to not use it. Really doubt enough of the Walnut wood or oil would transfer to the food to have any effect on anyone anyhow.

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#7

The down side of this treatment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

After this treatment for the next forever the mineral oil will come back out again and leave the surface oily. A very light treatment does leave the board looking great to sell or gift.

if you intend to use the board it will soak up oil and fat from use. Preempt this fact by coating with vegie oil of any kind to begin with. It partially cures and doesn't come back out. Has worked for our well used boards and counter tops for 40 years.

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#8

Standard Answer

Howard Acheson

An excellent treatment for wooden food preparation surfaces like cutting boards and butcher blocks is a mixture of mineral oil and either paraffin or beeswax. This is what is used on many commercial wood surfaces. It will last longer and be more protective than just mineral oil. Mineral oil can be found in most supermarkets in the pharmacy section or in a true pharmacy. Paraffin is found in the canning section of the store or in a hardware store.

Heat the oil in a double boiler and shave in some wax. The exact proportions are not critical--a 5-6 parts of oil to one part of wax will work fine. Stir the mixture until all the wax is liquefied. Apply the mixture heavily and let it set 10-12 hours or overnight. Next day do it again and continue until the wood will no longer absorb the finish. Let it set for 10-12 hours and then lightly scrape off any excess. Then buff it with a rag.

Reapply whenever the wood begins to look dry.

Never put a wood board in the dishwasher and don't soak it in dishwater for long periods.

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#9

Kneale Brownson

^^^^^This^^^^^^


Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#10

The down side of Veg oil

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

All vegetable oil will go rancid after a time, which is not something you want on a cutting board used for food prep.

Warm up your wood in an oven, apply a light coat of mineral oil, wipe off the excess and you are good to go. There is no need to saturate the wood with mineral oil. Bacteria is less likely to grow on wood cutting boards than on plastic ones if they are cleaned right after use. A scrub with soap and water is all that is needed, then let it dry. Yo can apply more mineral oil later if you want, personally I don't.

Lee

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#11

let's explore this objection

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. Any board I use is exposed to oils and fats for kneading bread, cutting up meat, etc. Whether I add any or not the board will soon become coated with fat and oil from use. Your results my differ depending on how the board/counter is used.

2. What is rancid? Is it bad?. Most fats and oils contain esters made from large fatty acid molecules which have weak places in the molecule(unsaturation) that can react with oxygen and break. The pieces that break off are smaller acids- acetic, propionic, butyric etc.They stink more or less. The chemistry that generates these smaller acids is described as the material becoming rancid. It is the same chemistry that "cures" linseed oil, varnish, etc. and generates the same smells.

These smaller acids also happen to be the normal products of fermentation and other ageing. We eat lots of them. They give cheese and bread its desirable flavors. That overnight fermentation of the bagels I made this weekend resulted in the generation of these acids, which provided these bagels exceptional flavor compared to same-day grocery store bagels (not to be confused with real bagel shop bagels).

3. The stinky acids generated through oxidation are readily volatile. Unless captured in a confined space they go away as fast as they are generated.

4. The cooking oil in the bottle which I am recommending to add to cutting boards is exposed to oxygen and this chemistry in the bottle or on the board. The plastic used to contain these oils is readily permeable to oxygen.

5. Walnut oil, blessed for cutting board use, is more susceptible to these oxidations than typical cooking oil. We call it curing but it is identical chemistry to "going rancid" , a more pejorative description.

6. Olive oil doesn't have the weak places in its fatty acids and will not oxidize to generate the smaller smelly acids, for what that is worth.

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#12

Ellis Walentine

So, if I get this right...

Ellis Walentine

... the smell we think of as rancid is not harmful, at least not as far as cutting boards are concerned. We shouldn't regard it as a negative.

To recap briefly, mineral oil and most vegetable oils are non-drying, so they retain their greasy personality in the board forever, until they get leached out by repeated washings, and then they need to be replaced, if that matters to you. I'm not sure I understand if or why anyone would prefer one type over the other. Wash either type with soap and water and it comes clean of nasty bacteria etc., no?

As for wax/oil blends and other approaches... it begs the question of what we want in a cutting board finish. Does it need to look great? Clean up well? Not show fats from cutting up meats? Is there a unified theory of all this?

Inquiring minds, ...

Ellis

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#13

Clarification

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Disclaimer: all my experience is with regularly used boards and counters.

The products of fat and oil oxidation stink, but they are not harmful. They are volatile so they don't accumulate. If the board is used it will contain fats and oils from use. In fact, once treated just using our counter top butcher block areas keeps them well oiled and not "dry".

Using vegie oil was not my invention. I got the tip from someone in the Southern Highlands Craft Guild that makes wooden ware.

Bottom line- The fats and oils that accumulate with use, as well as the accepted walnut oil (or anything else with organic oil in its name, linseed etc.) experience identical reaction with oxygen to generate the same volatile products. Adding some from the cooking oil bottle is no different.

Vegie oil sticks to wood better than mineral oil. I don't see the endless bleeding back out that I saw when I over soaked with mineral oil and vegie oil lasts much longer. For one it is more viscous so the wood doesn't have an oily feel and it sticks better. Second, if one selects the optimum oil (corn, soy, cotton) it will partially cure, not as much as walnut and linseed, but some and its viscosity will increase a lot. Too thick a layer and it will become a sticky surface. A thin layer will be tenaciously stuck to the wood.

Bottom line: vegie oil sticks better and everyone has it handy as needed in the kitchen

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#14

more oil chemistry

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Any oil that can undergo oxidation will "cure" more or less. Oils with a lot of reactive sites like Linseed and Tung cure to a rubber-like polymer that is a useful film former for wood finish. Oils like soy oil react with oxygen but can't react enough to make a rubbery cross-linked film. Their viscosity will however slowly increase to make them a sticky film, if the film is thick enough to feel its stickiness. Oils like olive have so few reactive sites that they experience little reaction with oxygen and don't get detectably more viscous.

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#15

Re: more oil chemistry

John in NM

And I gather that mineral oil is more like olive oil, but maybe even more so? Just to round out the comparisons.

The other thing to consider about odors - a lot of it has to do with associations. The odor of oxidized veg oil or animal fat tends to smell bad to us because we associate it with spoiled food. The odor of oxidized tung or linseed oil tends to smell good (to me at least :D ) because I associate it with a finished project! If we used linseed oil on our salads, I might have a different view of the odor of cured oil.

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#16

Re: let's explore this objection

Lars Parrington

Ihis is excellent info on a on a subject that many woodworkers are confused about. I'd recommend this be archived as an article.

Is there any interesting chemistry happening when wax is mixed with the oil?

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#17

comparing mineral to "organic" oil...substantial

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Mineral oil is refined from crude oil. It is just like the oil used in your car except more refined. This fact could be repulsive to true Greens.

It is a hydrocarbon and it is composed only of carbon and hydrogen. It is simply another step in the hydrocarbon series- methane, ethane, propane, butane....

Fats and oils are esters of fatty acids and glycerin. They are all very similar and differ only in the details of the fatty acid. The acids typically are composed of 14 to 18 carbon atoms and a bunch of hydrogen and some oxygens on the end of the molecule to make them acids.(I am sure Google will have a picture of the molecule) These acids are just bigger molecules in the series formic(1 carbon), acetic(2 carbons), propionic(3 carbons), butyric(4 carbons)..........> up to the 14 to 18 carbon containing molecules of the acids that make fats and oils.

Some of these acids have "missing hydrogens" and where the hydrogens are missing(lacking) this part of the molecule can react with oxygen and break this piece off generating a new smaller acid, many of which stink, especially the 4 and 5 carbon containing acids. These acids result in the odor of cheese, traditional bread, rancid fat and the insides of cabinetry finished with linseed oil.

But, these same reactive sites can do something else. They can react with oxygen and then instead of breaking off, the whole molecule can react with a neighbor to generate a larger molecule. Oils that have lots of these sites can react so much that a few giant molecules result (we call it cross linking). These giant molecules will form a tough rubbery film, useful for finishing furniture and gun stocks.

So, while all fats and oils are largely the same the details of their constituent acids that make the ester with glycerin determine whether they are solids or liquids, and whether they can "go rancid" and how much, and /or crosslink to make a durable film or just react to get bigger and more viscous.

To make soap we break the ester group with lye which results in glycerin and the fatty acid which has been neutralized(reacted with) the lye. Neutralized fatty acid with lye is what we know as soap or shampoo.

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#18

answer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Is there any interesting chemistry happening when wax is mixed with the oil?........no, it just dissolves. Both are hydrocarbons, the wax containing more carbon and hydrogen in the molecule than mineral oil and hence it is a solid instead of an oil. Continuing adding the same carbon and hydrogen building block that made wax from oil and when you have added several hundred thousand of these units together you get polyethylene.

Hydrocarbons are largely unreactive chemicals, unlike the fats and oils.

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#19

Re: Standard Answer

Chuck Hans

This may be a strange question, but what is Paraffin Oil, and can it be used on boards? I know it was added to paint in years past, and therefore may not be suitable for use on a cutting surface.

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#20

answer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Chemically it is like mineral oil. I don't know how much it is purified. Without knowing a lot more about it I would not use it for food contact. But then I would not use mineral oil either unless it was USP or otherwise "food grade".

All these names just indicate a generic chemical composition and boiling range as it is distilled from crude oil. The impurities retained will determine what it is suited for.

Bottom line if it isn't food or medicine, don't eat it.

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#21

more on the job data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We are butchering a deer today. I have a maple block I put on the butcher block counter section for the task. The added maple block intercepts meat saw and cleaver abuse. I have been using it for many years and each year after cutting up a lamb or deer it is washed, disinfected and coated with whatever vegie oil happens to be at hand.

I noticed that the side I use less often, which has been vegie oil coated many times and not worn off as much, has a tough film of what must be "cured" vegie oil. It looks like what might be the result of having slathered linseed oil on it, except it was vegie oil slathered on it, some years or decades ago.

Now it may have taken 20 years to form this film, but it illustrates that at least some of the vegie oils slowly cure which means they don't come off readily and hence offer enhanced and more durable protection like one might get with walnut oil or linseed oil.

(The linseed oil in the can is not food grade and I am not suggesting using it on a food contact surface, though I doubt it would present any practical problem).

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#22

Ellis Walentine

Re: more on the job data

Ellis Walentine

some of the vegie oils slowly cure which means they don't come off readily and hence offer enhanced and more durable protection like one might get with walnut oil or linseed oil.

Ah, this seems like another piece of this puzzle. Oils cure at different rates, if at all. There is a continuum from "doesn't cure", as in mineral oil, and "cures', such as linseed oil and some of the nut oils. Everything else is in between, similar to the way "Danish Oil" finishes don't form films, so they need to be wiped off. If you do this enough times, you can gradually build a thin film, although it won't have the impermeability of a more substantial varnish film.

The upshot for cutting boards, I guess, is that all oils offer some degree of protection, and cheap vegetable oils are perfectly functional if you don't mind an occasional whiff of rancidity. I'm going to try some canola oil on one of my boards and report back if I find anything of interest.

Good discussion. It's been 45 years since I took organic chemistry, so it was nice to be reminded of some of the relevancies here.

Ellis

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#23

additionally

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"cheap vegetable oils are perfectly functional"....

I would suggest using the word "handy" rather than cheap. The bottom line for me is that my workhorse boards and counter tops get coated with some degree of vegie oil and animal fat from daily use. If they get a bit "dry" looking from use it is "handy" to reach for what ever vegie oil is in the cupboard to freshen them up.

For "new construction" I think the vegie oils provide a better feel to the board. To me the surface does not feel oily when I use vegie oil.

Re: glycerin on Butchers Block???

#24

Russ Fairfield Said.....

Barry Irby

You can't sell a bowl or cutting board that stinks of anything. (Lacquer, Waterlox, rancid oil. whatever.) His recommendation was to use sunflower oil (double check this in the archives, might have been safflower oil. Some kind of "s" oil) His explanation was that it had no odor and nobody was allergic to it, unlike walnut oil.

I have coated numerous end grain cutting board with it. Some of them acted almost like a filter. You could coat one side and the oil would practically drip out of the other.