Re: Ethanol Treatment Discussion
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
quote from article
"On February 1st, I had the opportunity to speak with Mr. Tom Bingham, the Marketing Director of Gold Eagle. This gentleman was VERY knowledgeable about “Marine Formula Sta-Bil Ethanol Treatment” and the chemistry behind the product."
One can be assured that a marketing director will be largely clueless about chemistry issues and this fact was amply demonstrated in the details of the discussion. There is a reason this person is marketing manager and not director of R&D that leads to this generally valid assumption. Little of the chemistry explanations are technically sound.
In general all the claims are possible to achieve through additives except the third. A careful read will reveal they are not able to alter the solvent properties and a filter is required. If oxidation was prevented there would not be any tank film to be dissolving.
Claim 1 certainly possible if these ethers are present at high enough concentration. I doubt 1 oz per gallon will do the job.
Claim 2 if enough antioxidant is added, hydroquinone or a relative is typically used, it will prevent oxidation reactions in the fuel until the antioxidant is used up. So I have no doubt this product will prevent oxidation for some amount of time.
Claim 3 Again possible but it will be difficult to stop corrosion if much water gets absorbed into the fuel. The business about acetic acid and formic acid being formed from ethanol in gasoline is baloney.
Claim 4 The product failed to meet this claim.If the ethanol presence is dissolving seals and gaskets this product will do nothing to prevent it for no additive can alter the bulk solvent properties of the gasoline-ethanol mix.
Bottom line- this stuff should retard oxidation(gum formation) and it may help with corrosion both of which are a good reason to use it in ethanol gas or pure gas. The rest I doubt.