Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Lumber Bundles

Posts

Lumber Bundles

#1

Lumber Bundles

Jerry Nicholson

Has anyone had good luck with bundles from Wall Lumber? I bought a bundle of walnut from them last year and just got around to using it. This is the least dense and softest walnut I have ever used (softer than luan) and I have had serious problems with splitting out and fuzzy edges when routing. I would very generously say that it is 40 percent useable but I am using some that I would normally put in the firewood pile if I didn't need to get this project done soon. Some boards have the pith right on the surface or down the middle.

I haven't been able to find any decent sources of walnut around Wichita Kansas in the last few years. About 15 years ago I got a pile of really nice rough cut walnut from a barn near Winfield but I have used all of that.

Jerry

Re: Lumber Bundles

#2

No direct experience, but Steve Wall...

Henry W

Jerry - I have no direct experience with either purchasing walnut, or in purchasing anything from Wall Lumber - despite being in the same state as them. My overall impression however has always been that they are a first rate supplier. Given your displeasure with the product, I would simply call and ask them about it, even if your purchase was a considerable time ago. Give them the opportunity to address or correct the issue.

Henry

Re: Lumber Bundles

#3

Re: Lumber Bundles

Dick Coers

No experience with Wall, but I do know that walnut is graded differently than other hardwood. Do you remember what grade you bought? I'm pretty sure that walnut growth further north is more dense than southern grown. I'm certain that is the case for oak, just assuming the same for walnut.

Re: Lumber Bundles

#4

Re: Lumber Bundles

John McGaw

No experience with walnut from Wall but I bought a bundle or two of thin cherry (to save myself from endless milling and waste) and was quite satisfied with the quality and price. I'd suggest that you contact them with your concerns. Having an order number or some such would probably help.

Re: Lumber Bundles

#5

shop where the pros shop

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Hardwood lumber is a commodity easily shipped and available everywhere. Somewhere in a city the size of Wichita there will be one or more hardwood lumber dealers that supply the needs of the local cabinet shops, etc. Stop by some place that uses hardwood lumber and ask where they get their lumber, or look in the phone book.

Re: Lumber Bundles

#6

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Western Missouri is an important source of walnut logs. There will be several mills in the KC area that saw walnut and will no doubt be willing to sell you some if you are willing to buy a quantity that is of interest to them.

Re: Lumber Bundles

#7

not correct on either count

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

How fast the tree grows is what mainly determines its density. In the case of oak and walnut, normally fast growth produces the most dense lumber. However, I bought a pair of walnut logs a while back. One was very dark and the hardest walnut I ever worked, and I have worked several thousand bdft. It was a fast growth tree, but not unusually so. They other was normal growth rate but it worked like mahogany, and it was as light as poplar. I sent a piece to Mary May to carve a furniture part for me and she found it a dream to carve.

Typically in the case of poplar the location of the tree determines how dense it is. Field poplars tend to be hard, while deep woods poplar tends to be mellow. I have seen very slow growth white oak be as light as poplar and easily nailed.

Re: Lumber Bundles

#8

Re: No direct experience, but Steve Wall...

Jerry Nicholson

I am building keepsake boxes for my grand daughters and, unfortunately, I wouldn't have time to start over with new lumber even if I could get it. I am going to try some dark brown or black tinted epoxy on the tear out.

I remember reading several years ago that the weight of an M1 Garand rifle could vary a couple of pounds depending on the density of the stock.

Jerry

Re: Lumber Bundles

#9

Re: Lumber Bundles

Jeaae Cloud

I've bought bundles from Steve Wall a few times, several different species. Always top quality. Give them a call and see where it goes.

Re: Lumber Bundles

#10

question and comment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Is it possible you have a bundle of butternut? That would explain the characteristics. I have handled thousands of bdft of walnut and never seen any as light as luan, nor any that could not be machined reliably. I have much less experience with butternut, but it is very light weight and can be fuzzy.

As far as the poor edge routing try doing it in two lighter cuts.

Re: Lumber Bundles

#11

Re: question and comment

john Veerkamp

Sounds like Butternut aka "White Walnut".

Re: Lumber Bundles

#12

Am I at least correct that walnut is graded

Dick Coers

differently? Cheez.

Re: Lumber Bundles

#13

Re: Lumber Bundles

Keith Newton

Jerry, It sounds like your old stash was probably a mill run lot which had been air dried. Then what you bought, was probably FAS, which was mostly sapwood which had been steamed to darken it. Some will argue that it is just the same, but I think that it does loose some crispness of machining texture, and the sapwood is missing the extractives which add the color, weight, and decay resistance.

That being said, I would suggest that you buy a lower grade #3 for small projects. There will be some knots, but most of the wood will be heartwood, and at a lot cheaper price, which works out being closer to the same $ per usable board foot.

Even this heartwood, if it has been steamed will be missing some of the reds and purple hues. However, those neat colors that we woodworkers get to experience will all turn the same color as steamed over time as they fade away. For this reason, learning to fill the grain, and stain walnut makes the beauty last a lot longer.

Re: Lumber Bundles

#14

yes indeed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Additionally, the grading rules for walnut are more lax and more complex than for other species, allowing more cuttings, smaller cuttings and shorter overall lengths into the top grades. Bottom line, the variability of what one gets in a pack of "top grade", the definition of which depends on supplier and supply, has so much variation as to make grading of lesser value in judging what is in a pack of walnut. Walnut was the only species that we would not buy by grade alone. I always inspected and selected packs for purchase. When walnut was plentiful it was easy to find packs that could be resold in smaller quantities. When supplies were tight our typical customer would find a lot of a typical pack useless to them.

"Bundles" don't mean much without more information. They probably are "clear cuttings" from lower grade lumber. The lumber should be just fine if in fact they are clear cuttings and the lengths and widths are useful to the buyer. We never had any success selling walnut in this form, but then we never shipped lumber.

Re: Lumber Bundles

#15

Steaming

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I had a friend that ran a furniture factory that ran walnut products. He claimed that steamed walnut machined better.

I agree with the rest of your discussion except the #3 common part. #3common in all species is typically sold for pallet lumber. It will largely be the center of logs with all the problem that the center of logs have for lumber. I would recommend #2 common for small projects.

On a different note, I keep #2 common poplar on hand and get most of my drawer parts and internal framing from this lumber with very little waste.

PS you and I may be the only people on WC that think staining walnut is the preferred finishing procedure. I just refinished a Lane cedar chest because the unstained walnut had bleached to an unattractive light yellow brown color. The mineral pigment stain I added back will be there forever.

Re: Lumber Bundles

#16

I'm a convert

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"PS you and I may be the only people on WC that think staining walnut is the preferred finishing procedure."

After my last walnut project using your staining procedure, I am a convert. I was never a fan of staining things, but for walnut, using the General finishes stain, I am now a fan.

It looked soooo much better than using just poly or varnish. Thanks for that.

Re: Lumber Bundles

#17

OK, Maybe I was aiming a little low.

Keith Newton

But I'll admit I haven't bought any Walnut in a long time. Mine usually comes off my own mill, so is not graded. And I know to stay away from the juvenile wood.

The point I was making, is that FAS is chosen for one clear face, which might mean that the whole back face may be all sapwood, which when steamed moves in color somewhat toward the heartwood, without the other properties.

Bill, I don't have any issues with the machining properties of steamed. However, having started into my woodworking life as a carver, I'll assure you I can tell the difference. Of course, green is when it is really best for carving.

As for the staining, I'm less concerned with coloring the late wood, as I am getting the open pores filled with dark filler or pigments.

Congrats on getting your deer. I may be one up on you though.

Re: Lumber Bundles

#18

clarification on sap wood

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the NHLA standards are such that both faces of a FAS walnut board could be 100% sapwood. Sapwood is not a defect by NHLA standards. You are spot on that when walnut lumber is in tight supply that a pack of FAS1F (the best grade I ever saw for sale) will be loaded with sapwood due to the fact that small (as small as 10") trees are being sawed.

I saw a pile of walnut logs on a log yard in 2007 when walnut was in tight supply that I seriously thought was a reject pile set aside for firewood. Two years later when demand collapsed I saw a pack for sale at our suppler that had lots of 12" and wider boards. It was the best pack I ever saw for sale.