Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Fastening on tops-pocket screws

Posts

Fastening on tops-pocket screws

#1

Fastening on tops-pocket screws

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In a post below some questioned the use of pocket screws for the top in question and recommended some sort of table top fastening hardware. The thought was that the pocket screws led to the top splitting. I noted that there was a split only at one end of the table top and that this board appeared to have other smaller end checks. I question that the screws were the cause of the split.

I have never seen an old table top not fastened on with pocket screws. When I took the class at the Mack Headley shop, a shop steeped in Virginia furniture building tradition, we were instructed on how to locate, size and carve the pockets for fastening tops with pocket screws. Although drilled to accept a screw without pounding it through the hole, I do not recall any warning about over sizing the hole beyond what was necessary to get the screw to drop through.

What are other's experiences with pocket screws? I have been using then without concern since the Headley class. Are there precautions inherent in using them that were practiced by Period craftsmen that we need to know about?

Re: Fastening on tops-pocket screws

#2

Mixed

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Depends on the wood.

Really stable stuff like Walnut has never given me an issue. I use a pocket screw in each cross-grain apron located in the center of the top (where there's never a glue joint).

Ash and Cherry (like to dance),? I approach one of 2 ways since I've had "supposedly KD" wood tops split:

1. "Z" clips (or shop-made slot blocks) on the cross-grain aprons or

2. 1x1 strips glued on the cross-grain aprons with slots for the flat-head screws to allow seasonal movement + pocket screws in the long apron (grain-parallel) to keep the top in a fixed location but allow the other edge to expand and contract.

Since using these methods, I've not had a single problem.

Re: Fastening on tops-pocket screws

#3

Dale Lenz

Re: Fastening on tops-pocket screws

Dale Lenz

Based on what I Think I know about wood, it will move across the grain due to humidity changes, such as winter vs. summer. So when I attach the top to my flag case pedestal with pocket screws I will drill a slightly larger screw shank hole on one side of the pedestal base to allow for some movement. My pedestal's top is only something like 5.5" in width, it may not matter, but I error on the side of caution. On a large dining room table, I'd surely think not to Trap the wood, as screwing the top to the table's apron would surely do, without some sort of a way for the top to move during seasonal changes.

Re: Fastening on tops-pocket screws

#4

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

When working with a slab (1.5>3") tops, w-w/o natural edge, I try to use 3-4 screws located along the center line of the top thus allowing the top to expand/contract away from or towards that center line. No other fixing has been needed.

Re: Fastening on tops-pocket screws

#5

Re: Fastening on tops-pocket screws

don stephan

My two cents every method including pocket screws should make a similar allowance for potential seasonal movement. It may be easier to allow for more movement using figure 8's, Z clips and wood buttons than with pocket screws.

Re: Fastening on tops-pocket screws

#6

I agree

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I concur. Wood changes seasonally and you should allow it to move. A self tapping pocket hole screw is not going to ally any movement, which could cause serious problems on widths as wide as a table top. I would make slots for teh screws.

Lee

Re: Fastening on tops-pocket screws

#7

Usually that is what I do...

John in NM

I never really liked the other options, and pocket holes seem to work fine. I usually just hog the pocket out with a large sweep gouge, then drill an oversize hole for the screw. I've seen a shop made jig for using a forstner bit, probably in a 1990's vintage FWW.

From some of the responses, I gather some have the image of using those little Kreg screws or something. Traditionally, it's just a fairly large pocket cut with a chisel (or brace maybe) and a regular wood screw.

Re: Fastening on tops-pocket screws

#8

not that kind of pocket screw

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

See pocket screw in picture of table in earlier post.